THE PARENTAL EFFECT ON THE PROGENY BROOD POST-CAPPING STAGE DURATION

tekst: Maciej Siuda, Jerzy Wilde

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XL, 1996 — Maciej Siuda, Jerzy Wilde

strona 7

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XL, Nr 1 1996

Maciej Siuda, Jerzy Wilde

Academy of Agriculture and Technology, Apiculture Division, 10-957 Olsztyn, POLAND

Summary

The post-capping developmental stage (PCS) of queens, drones and workers was determined. The queens with known PCS were inseminated with sperm of one drone with a shorter or longer PCS or with doses of 8 mm3 mixed semen. The queens were kept in „kirchhainer” nucs and the PCS of the progeny of the crossing were determined. The correlation between the queens and their sons was highly significant (r= 0.54, p<0,01) but the correlation calculated between queens and their queen daughters was only r= 0.29, p<0.07. The regression coefficient of the mother-queens on their daughters was b=0.78, and that of the sons-drones was 2.34. The estimated coefficients of the PCS heritability amounted h2=0.6 for the daughter-queens and h2=0.45 for the sons. The correlation between the workers and their mothers and their drone fathers were similary low (r=0.26 and r=0.28 respectively), but both were highly significant (p<0.01). According to these results queens have a greater influence on the postcapping duration of their sons than on that of their daughters. The PCS of the worker correlated significantly with that of both parents. Because of the low correlation coefficient, a rapid process of selection for low PCS in workers, and the appearance of bees tolerating varroatosis because of this trait, appears unlikely.

Keywords: breeding, selection, resistance, Varroa jacobsoni, post capping period, correlation, heritability.

INTRODUCTION

Since 1991, the Division of Apiculture of University of Agricultural and Technnology in Olsztyn (NorthEast Poland) has been working on breeding out the honey bees with a short post-capping developmental stage (PCS). Attempts to obtain such bee strains are one example of work that has been carried out in order to create bee lines resistant against Varroa jacobsoni. This kind of resistance against the parasite invasion was found to exist in South-African bee Apis mellifera capensis. Its workers emerge as early as 10-11 days after the duration of the postcapping stage, and the still immature Varroa parasite progeny dies (Moritz, Mautz 1990). It was supposed that a short period of the host’s post-larval development

  • This research was supported by the KBN Grant Nr. 5 S311 010 07.
strona 8

would restrain the mite reproduction to only a direct reproduction level and therefore would enable us to limit or completely restrict the introduction of acaricides, which should thus not only free the honey-bee colonies from Varroa jacobsoni but also free the bee products from the remains of acaricide substances.

In our Division, we have been breeding bees with a short PCS within the carniolan bee race, and also, in co-operation with The Apiculture Institute of Oberursel (Germany), within hybrids of Apis mellifera capensis x Apis mellifera carnica, crossing them back with carniolan drones. The Langenbach method (1991) was most often used when selecting the worker bees for a short PCS. The time of cell sealing of 60 cells on average was determinated by marking individual cells on a plastic sheet at 3-hrs intervals. Approximately 10 hrs before hatching, the cappings of these cells were marked by attaching numbered queen marking disk. By the time the worker bees emerged, cell capping had been removed. The marking disks fell through a grid attached to the bottom of the hive and through a tunnel on a circular register plate. This plate was subdivivided into 24 segments, and revolved once in 24 hrs. The time of emergence could be read from the position of the marking disks. The cell was identivied from the number on the disk, and the duration of the sealing period was calculated from the respective sealing time. In the conditions of NorthEast Poland, this procedure permits us to rear three generations of queens and their worker progeny but only two of them can be tested in the same season. New, more efficient methods are therefore desired. It appears that one possible way could be by establishing the correlation coefficients between the PCS duration in the different honey bee castes. Such an approach could possibly enable us to avoid the time-consuming determination of workers’ PCS duration and ensure instead that we obtain five – six generations of queens annually.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The experiment was carried in the apiary of the Apiculture Division of the University of Agricultural and Technnology of Olsztyn in 1992-1994. In 1992, the carniolan honey bee race was used, and since 1993 its hybrids with Apis mellifera capensis (F5 and the further generations), crossing them back with the carniolan drones. The queens were reared continuously in the queenless rearing colonies. The time of the queens PCS duration was determined by the authors own method (Wilde 1994, Wilde and Siuda 1992). The time of queen cell sealing of all cells was determinated individual at 4-hrs intervals by inspection of rearing colonies. Approximately 10 hrs before hatching, the cappings of these queen cells in the incubator at 1-h intervals were observed. Once emerged, the queens were introduced to

strona 9

the newly settled small mating hives (made of foamy polystyrene) and following two days of holding them in a cellar (temp. 10°C) they were placed in an apiary. The very moment of the comb’s cells capping was detected by marking a sample of 60-100 cells on a transparent plastic sheet. The duration of the workers PCS was estimated using the method by Langenbach (1991). As for drones, the authors own method was elaborated (Wilde and Siuda 1992). A number of queens were inseminated with semen taken from one drones with known duration time for their PCS, individually selected and different for each queen. The remaining queens with known PCS were inseminated with semen of one drone with shorter or longer PCS or with single dosis of 8 mm3 mixed semen. The queens were kept in „kirchhainer” nucs and the PCS of the progeny of the crossing were determined.

In 1992, the time of PCS duration was determined for 40 queens, 327 drones and 1300 workers of the carnica F2 generation (tab. 1 and 2). Of this number, five queens started the regular oviposition following their insemination with the semen from an individually selected drone. In 1993 the PCS durations were determined for 14 – daughter-queens of hybrid F6 generation, for 246 carniolan drones and for 128 workers, and in 1994 for 223 carniolan workers – the progeny of queens that had been inseminated with mixed semen. The results of these experiment, were statistically tested using the „Statgraphics” computer package procedure (Dąbkowski 1992).

RESULTS

In 1992, the queens emerged between 161.0 and 186.0 hours, on average after 175.0 hrs of the PCS development, while the sons-drones between 288.0-356.0 hrs, on average after 328.2 hrs (tab. 1). The correlation coefficients were calculated between the PCS durations in the mother-queens and their progeny – daughter queens and sons (tab. 3). A moderate, however highly significant correlation was found between the mothers and their sons postlarval development time (r= 0.54, p<0.01). Correlation coefficient for the mother- and daughter-queens was low (r= 0.29) and was at the margin of significance limits (p<0.07). The regression coefficient for mother and their daughter-queens on was b=0.78, and for mother and sons-drones was 2.34. The estimated coefficients of the PCS heritability was to h2=0.6 for the daughter-queens and h2=0.45 for sons (tab. 3).

In 1992, the workers originating from queens inseminated with semen of a single drone emerged after 284.5 to 310.5 hrs, on average after 294.1 hrs of the post-capping development (tab. 2). The correlation coefficients between workers and their mothers, and between workers and

strona 10

their fathers were r=0.26 and r=0.28 respectively (tab. 3). Both the values were highly significant (p<0.01). The obtained regression coefficients were to b=0.33 and b=0.12 respectively, while the heritability coefficient were h2=0.37 for mother-queens and workers, and h2=0.24 for fathers and worker bees.

T a b l e 1 PCS duration in daughter-queens and sons (hours) Długość OCZ matek-córek i synów (w godzinach)

n range – rozstęp x̄
daughter-queens 1992
matki-córki 1992
40 161.0 – 186.0 175.0
daughter-queens 1993
matki-córki 1993
14 176.0 – 205.0 184.3
sons – synowie 128 288.0 – 356.0 328.2

In 1992, the workers, originating from queens inseminated with the mixed semen, had the PCS ranging from 274.5 to 310 hours, on average 284.2 hrs (n= 1088; tab. 2). The estimated correlation coefficient between the mother-queens and workers was r= -0.14 and it was statistically significant (p<0.05) and that of heritability h2= 0.37 (tab. 3).

T a b l e 2 Workers’ and drones’PCS duration in successive generations and years of experiment (hours) Długość OCZ robotnic i trutni w kolejnych pokoleniach i latach doświadczenia (w godzinach)

Generation
Pokolenie
n range – rozstęp x̄
workers – robotnice 1992 F2 1088 274.5 – 310.0 284.2
workers – robotnice 1992* F2 212 284.5 – 310.5 294.1
workers – robotnice 1993* F6* 128 268.5 – 306.0 279.7
drones – trutnie 1993 P 246 321.0 – 357.4 343.6
workers – robotnice 1994 F5 223 262.5 – 303.5 279.4
  • workers from mother-queens inseminated by a single drone
  • robotnice od matek unasienianych pojedynczymi trutniami
strona 11

In 1993, the daughter-queens emerged between 176.0 and 205 hours, on average 184.3 hrs after brood cell capping (tab. 1). The correlation coefficient between the PCS durations of the mother-queens and daughter-queens of the hybrid F6 generation was high (r= 0.73) and statistically highly significant (p<0.01), the regression coefficient of the daughter-queens on their mother was to b=3.51; whereas the heritability coefficient had been overestimated (h2>1; tab. 3). Three queens from that F6 generation laid eggs regularly after being inseminated with semen from an individually selected drone. In this case, the workers emerged between 268.5 and 306.0 hrs, on average 279.7 hrs after brood cell capping. The correlation coefficient between the PCS of workers and their mother-queen was high to r= 0.83. It was also high between the PCS of workers and drones orginating from the same queen to r= 0.97 (tab. 3). Both the last coefficients were

T a b l e 3 Coefficients of regression (b), correlation (r) and heritability (h2) Współczynniki regresji (b), korelacji (r) i odziedziczalności (h2)

b r p h2
mother-queens/daughter-queens 1992
matki/matki-córki 1992
0.78 0.29 p<0.07 0.6
mother-queens/daughter-queens 1993
matki/matki-córki 1993
3.51 0.73 p<0.01 1.64
mother-queens/drones 1992
matki/trutnie 1992
2.34 0.54 p<0.01 0.45
mother-queens/workers 1992
matki/robotnice 1992
-0.18 -0.14 p<0.05 0.37
mother-queens/workers 1992*
matki/robotnice 1992*
0.33 0.26 p<0.01 0.66
mother-queens/workers 1993*
matki/robotnice 1993*
1.03 0.83 p<0.01 1.61
mother-queens/workers 1994
matki/robotnice 1994
-0.19 -0.14 p<0.05 0.60
father-drones/workers 1992*
ojcowie/robotnice 1992*
0.12 0.28 p<0.01 0.24
father-drones/workers 1993*
ojcowie/robotnice 1993*
1.75 0.97 p<0.01 0.63
  • workers from mother-queens inseminated by a single drone
  • robotnice od matek unasienianych pojedynczymi trutniami
strona 12

highly significant (p<0.01). The workers on their parents regression coefficients were b= 1.03 and b= 1.75 respectively. The heritability coefficient of the mother-queens’ PCS duration by workers appeared to be overestimated (h2> 1), while for the parent-drones and workers it amounted to h2= 0.63.

In 1994, the workers emerged after 262.5-303.5 hrs, on average 279.4 hrs after brood cell capping (tab. 2). The respective coefficients were of similar values in the case of the progeny of the mother-queens inseminated in 1992. The correlation coefficient was low and negative r= -0.14. However it was statistically significant (p<0.05), the regression coefficient of workers on their mothers was b= -0.19, and the heritability coefficient was to h2= 0.6 (tab. 3).

DISCUSSION

The heritability coefficients obtained in the year 1993 for the mother – daughter-queens, and for the workers and their mothers, was overestimated. The low genetic variation, estimated at 5.23%, was probably the cause of such results.

In the years 1992 and 1994, the coefficient of correlation and regression for the workers originating from mother-queens inseminated with 8mm3 of the mixed semen, were negative. In the remaining cases they were positive. The values of the calculated coefficients for the workers originating from mother-queens in 1992 were comparable to those obtained by Büchler and Drescher (1990). The negative values of the considered coefficients can point to evidence of the drones’ considerable influence in determining the PCS in bees. Moritz and Jordan (1992) came to a similar conclusion. However, they obtained higher heritability coefficients (h2= 0.76) than those in our own experiment.

The heritability coefficients estimated for workers in the 1992 season were similar to those reported by Büchler and Drescher (1990) and by Le Conte et al. (1994). In 1994, the coefficient obtained in our investigations was of similar value (h2= 0.6) to that reported by Harbo (1992). The increase in the heritability coefficient value was accompanied by the investigated trait ranging towards the lower values and by the mean PCS value decreasing. Similarly to heritability coefficients evolved the remaining parameters estimated in our own experiment. This suggests that genetic factors are an increasing influence on the trait of the short duration of the capped brood period.

It is, however, difficult to explain why, regardless of the high correlation and heritability indexes, only small breeding progress, as concerns the selection trait, was achieved. Most probably, some impact on this situation exerts the relatively small number of the bred and selection

strona 13

individuals which is limited by the PCS monitoring possibilities. Better results could possibly be obtained, using the estimated coefficients and changing the selection procedure. It would be advisable to abandon the determination of the PCS of each individual and in each generation and to concentrate efforts instead on breeding out and selecting the more numerous material.

REFERENCES

Büchler R., Drescher W. (1990) – Variance and heritability of the capped developmental stage in European Apis mellifera L. and its correlation with increased Varroa jacobsoni Oud. infestation. J.Apic.Res., 29:172-176.

Harbo J.R. (1992) – Breeding honey bees (Hymenoptera: Apidae) for more rapid development of larvae and pupae. J.Econ.Entomol., 85:2125-2130.

Dąbkowski J., (1992) – Statgrafics – System statystycznego opracowania danych. Komputerowa Oficyna Wydawnicza „Help”, 1-240 s.

Langenbach K. (1991) – Bestimmung der Zellverdeckelungsdauer verschiedener Bienenherkünfte. Apidologie, 22:448-450.

Le Conte, Bruchou C., Benhamouda K., Gauthier C., Cor-nuet J.M. (1994) – Heritability of the queen brood post-caping stage duration in Apis mellifera mellifera L. Apidologie, 25:513-519.

Moritz R.F.A., Jordan K (1992) – Selection of resistance against Varroa jacobsoni across caste and sex in the honeybee (Apis mellifera L., Hymenoptera: Apidae). Exp.Appl. Acarol., 16:345-353.

Moritz R.F.A., Mautz D. (1990) – Development of Varroa jacobsoni in colonies Apis mellifera capensis and Apis mellifera carnica. Apidologie, 21:53-58.

Wilde J. (1994) – Hodowla pszczół o skróconym okresie postlarwalnym, odpornych na Varroa jacobsoni. Acta Acad. Agricult.Tech.Olst., Zootechnica, 39B:1-43.

Wilde J., Siuda M. (1992) – Próba selekcji na skrócenie stadium czerwia zaskle-pionego u pszczoły miodnej Apis mellifera carnica. Ann.UMCS. Sectio DD, 47: 137-140.

WPŁYW RODZICÓW NA OKRES CZERWIU ZASKLEPIONEGO POTOMSTWA

M. Siuda, J. Wilde

Streszczenie

Od roku 1991 prowadzone są w Zakładzie Pszczelnictwa AR-T w Olsztynie prace hodowlane prowadzące do wyhodowania pszczół o krótkim okresie czerwiu zasklepionego (OCZ). Poszukuje się nowych bardziej efektywnych metod selekcji. Wydaje się, iż jedną z nich może być zastosowanie współczynników korelacji pomiędzy rozwojem czerwiu zasklepionego poszczególnych kast pszczelich. Pozwoli to być może na zaniechanie czasochłonnego określania OCZ robotnic, a tym samym na wyhodowanie 5-6 pokoleń w ciągu roku.

strona 14

W 1992 roku do hodowli użyto pszczół rasy kraińskiej, a od 1993 roku również mieszańce A. m. capensis x A. m. carnica (F5 i dalsze pokolenia) krzyżowanych wypierająco trutniami kraińskimi. Okres trwania stadium zasklepionego matek określano metodą własną (Wilde i Siuda 1992). Moment zasklepiania komórek pszczelich określano posługując się metodą znakowania 60-100 komórek na przykładanej do plastra folii. Przy określaniu OCZ robotnic posługiwano się metodą opracowaną przez Langenbach (1991). Do określenia OCZ trutni posłużono się metodą własną (Wilde i Siuda 1992). Część matek pszczelich unasieniano nasieniem pobranym od jednego trutnia o znanym OCZ, pozostałe matki – jednorazowo dawką 8 mm3 nasienia.

Pomiędzy matkami a ich synami stwierdzono umiarkowaną lecz wysoko istotną korelację (r=0,54 p<0,01) (tab.3). Współczynnik korelacji dla matek i matek-córek był niski (r=0,29), lecz bliski istotności (p<0,07). Współczynnik regresji matek-córek na matki wynosił b=0,78 a synów b=2,34. Współczynnik odziedziczalności OCZ dla matek-córek wynosił h2=0,6 a dla synów h2=0,45 (tab.3).

Współczynniki korelacji oszacowane w 1992 roku wynosiły, pomiędzy robotnicami a ich matkami r=0,26 p<0,01 i r=-0,14 p<0,05 oraz ich ojcami r=0,28 p<0,01 (tab.3). Współczynniki regresji wynosiły odpowiednio: b=0,33 i b=-0,14 oraz b=0,12. Natomiast współczynnik odziedziczalności wynosił h2=0,66 i h2=0,37 pomiędzy matkami a robotnicami oraz h2=0,24 pomiędzy ojcami i robotnicami.

Współczynnik korelacji pomiędzy matkami a matkami-córkami pokolenia F6 mieszańców był wysoki (r= 0,73) oraz wysokoistotny statystycznie (p< 0,01), współczynnik regresji matek-córek na matki wynosił b=3,51, natomiast współczynnik odziedziczalności został przeszacowany h2>1 (tab.3). Współczynnik korelacji pomiędzy robotnicami a ich matkami wynosił r=0,83 p<0,01 oraz ich ojcami r=0,28 p<0,01 (tab.3). Współczynniki regresji wynosiły odpowiednio: b=1,03 oraz b=0,12. Współczynnik odziedziczalności pomiędzy matkami a robotnicami natomiast wynosił h2>1 oraz h2=0.63 pomiędzy ojcami i robotnicami (tab.3).

W 1994 roku współczynnik korelacji wynosił r=-0,14 i był statystycznie istotny (p<0,05), współczynnik regresji robotnic na matki wynosił b=-0,19 a współczynnik odziedziczalności h2=0,6.

W 1993 roku pomiędzy matkami dla matek-córek i robotnic od strony matek przeszacowano współczynniki odziedziczalności. Przypuszczać należy, iż powodem była mała zmienność genetyczna oszacowana na 5,23%.

W 1992 roku oraz 1994 współczynniki regresji oraz korelacji pomiędzy matkami unasienionymi 8 mm3 nasienia jednolicie mieszanego a robotnicami, były ujemne. Świadczyć to może o dużym wpływie trutni na kształtowanie się OCZ u pszczół. Do podobnego wniosku doszli Moritz i Jordan (1992). Jednak oszacowane w doświadczeniu współczynniki odziedziczalności były niższe niż uzyskane przez tych autorów (0,76).

W naszym doświadczeniu współczynniki odziedziczalności były podobne jak u Büchlera i Dreschera (1990) oraz Le Conte i in. (1994). Natomiast w 1993 i 1994 współczynnik ten osiągnął podobną wartość (0,6) jak u Harbo (1992). W związku z uzyskaniem tak różnorodnych wyników w poszczególnych latach badań, wydaje się, iż na obecnym etapie prowadzonych prac nad uzyskaniem pszczół o krótkim OCZ możliwe jest ograniczone wykorzystanie tych współczynników w dalszej hodowli. W pracach selekcyjnych należy więc opierać się nadal na bardzo pracochłonnym określaniu OCZ każdego hodowanego pokolenia.

Słowa kluczowe: hodowla, selekcja, odporność, *Varroa jacobson*i, okres czerwiu zasklepionego, korelacja, odziedziczalność.


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 7: „similary” → similarly
  • s. 7, 8: „Technnology” → Technology
  • s. 8: „subdivivided” → subdivided
  • s. 8: „identivied” → identified
  • s. 10, tab. 1, synowie: „128″ → 327
  • s. 11: „orginating” → originating
  • s. 13, piśmiennictwo: „Statgrafics” → Statgraphics
  • s. 13, piśmiennictwo: „post-caping” → post-capping

Podobne wpisy