COMPETITIVENESS OF THE POLISH BEEKEEPING INDUSTRY IN THE EUROPEAN MARKET

tekst: Janusz Cichoń, Jerzy Wilde

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XL, Nr 2, 1996 — Janusz Cichoń, Jerzy Wilde

strona 7

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XL, Nr 2 1996

Janusz Cichoń, Jerzy Wilde*

Department of Marketing & Market Analyses, University of Agriculture and Technology in Olsztyn, POLAND *Apiculture Department, University of Agriculture and Technology, ul. Oczapowskiego 5, 10-957 Olsztyn, POLAND e-mail: jurwild@moskit.art.olsztyn.pl

Summary

An analysis based on hypothetical productivity of apiaries has been carried out, in order to answer the question whether the Polish beekeeping industry may successfully compete in the European market. It is only large apiaries with at least 200 – 300 colonies, yielding on average over 20 kg of honey from one colony, that can stand a chance. Smaller apiaries with 50 to 100 colonies may compete in the Europen market either as homestead apiaries or else producing expensive assortments of honey. Therefore, the present beekeeping management model should be changed an intensive, movable system, which will include the use of 3-4 honeyflows and introduce pollen trapping.

Key words: beekeeping, Poland, European Market, honey, rentability of apiary

INTRODUCTION

The crisis in the Polish beekeeping industry, caused mainly by the lack of adjustment of our agriculture to market, has encouraged beekeepers to look for new ways to intensify beekeeping management. Nonetheless, in order for Polish beekeepers to run profitable apiaries, they should not only intensify production but also increase the number of bee colonies. In Poland, an apiary with 80-120 colonies would turn a satisfactory profit, if supported by an effective marketing strategy (Wilde 1995, 1996). Unfortunately, such difficult, labour-consuming marketing activities are not always undertaken. This regards mainly to to professional beekeepers who manage apiaries with 200 – 300 colonies and over (Wilde 1995).

Polish apiaries should be restructured before they can successfully compete in world markets. At present, an average Polish apiary has 20 bee colonies, whereas it is an apiary with 200 – 300 bee colonies, each yielding on average 50 kg of honey, that can turn gross profit (Cichoń and Wilde 1996). Such requirements can be met by an

strona 8

intensive, movable apiary, whose colonies are brought to 6 – 8 honeyflows, sometimes distant by 300 – 400 kilometers, during one production season. Our analysis also indicates that smaller apiaries with 50 to 100 colonies can be profitable, provided they keep production costs to a minimum (homestead apiaries), or manufacture expensive assortments of honey that later realize fancy prices. Prices for honey in the European market are undoubtedly affected by both world prices and the tases of consumers. Inexpensive honey ($2-3/kg) sells next to expensive assortments. West European consumers demand high quality honey, which sells at fancy prices (up to $13-15/kg). Consequently, in Poland exporters to West Europe offer $4/kg for honeydew honey and $5/kg for heather honey.

Is it, therefore, possible to restructure Polish beekeeping so that it will effectively compete in the European market? In order to answer this question, a break-even point analysis has been made and potential gross profit calculated on the basis of hypothetical (potentially attainable) productivity of apiaries.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Production costs were analysed for demonstration apiaries with 50, 100, 200 and 300 colonies. Two types of an apiary with 50 colonies were examined: stationary and movable. The other apiaries, of neccessity intensive, were movable and used at least 3 honeyflows during one production season. Productive expenditures were adopted from Pidek (1987, 1988, 1990), whereas the expenses incurred by pollen trapping – from Wilde and Cichoń (1990). Costs were split into fixed and variable. Fixed costs included depreciation of hives (10%), honey houses (2,5%) and beekeeping equipment (10%), as well as some labour costs (connected with maintenance of apiary by its extensive production, in the scale of minimum of net salary) and rent charges for apiary grounds (Tab.1). When calculating costs, it was assumed that property assets were created by own labour and then effectively used. The value of a hive was estimated at 50 zl, provided it was made from cheap, easily available materials (either hardened foamed polystyrene boards or hard felt boards, on a wooden frame) by the beekeeper. Two facts motivated this assumption. Firstly, no hives suitable for intensive, movable production were available on the market. Secondly, the hives sold on the market were so expensive that their price would exceed four- or five-fold the value of a hive assumed in the calculations. Similar recommendations were made as regarded pollen traps (Tab. 1). Top pollen traps (Bobrzecki et al. 1989) were applied, as they allowed to remove pollen from drawers no more than 2 – 3 times a fortnight

strona 9

(Wilde, Bobrzecki 1989).

Table 1 Fixed cost of production in apiary of different size (in zl) Koszty stałe w pasiekach różnej wielkości (w zł)

Specification Wyszczególnienie Size of apiary – Wielkość pasiek: 50 Size of apiary – Wielkość pasiek: 50* Size of apiary – Wielkość pasiek: 100 Size of apiary – Wielkość pasiek: 200 Size of apiary – Wielkość pasiek: 300
Depretiation: – Amortyzacja: beehives – ule (10%) 250 250 500 1000 1500
pollen traps – poławiacze (10%) 150 150 300 600 900
beekeeping equipment – sprzęt pszczel. (10%) 250 250 400 450 500
honey house (2.5%) – pracownia 300 300 400 450 500
Work – Praca 3000 3000 3000 3000 3000
Rent charges – Dzierżawa 100 100 200 400 600
Together fixed cost – Koszty stałe razem 4050 1050 4800 5900 7000
  • – Homestead apiary – Pasieka przydomowa

Depreciation costs of hives and pollen traps grew proportionally to the growth in the number of colonies. Other depreciation costs – honey houses and beekeeping equipement – increased more slowly. Fixed costs of labour were incurred by hiring one person full time in order to manage a large commodity apiary. These costs approximated to minimum net salary in Poland.

Table 2 Unit variable cost by different level of intensity of production (in zł per kg of honey) Jednostkowe koszty zmienne przy różnym poziomie intensywności gospodarowania (w zł/1 kg miodu)

Hypothetical productivity Zakładana wydajność Size of apiary Wielkość pasieki: 50 Size of apiary Wielkość pasieki: 50* Size of apiary Wielkość pasieki: 100 Size of apiary Wielkość pasieki: 200 Size of apiary Wielkość pasieki: 300
20 4,82 3,95 4,29 4,05 4,09
30 3,22 2,63 2,86 2,70 2,73
40 2,41 1,97 2,15 2,02 2,04
50 1,93 1,58 1,72 1,62 1,64
  • – Homestead apiary – Pasieka przydomowa
strona 10

Variable costs included the costs of sugar, pharmaceuticals, transport, partial labour and electricity (Tab. 2). Some costs (e.g. sugar and pharmaceuticals) were exclusively related to the size of an apiary, while others (e.g. transport, commuting, labour, electricity) varied according to expeceted and actual productivity. When hypothetical average yield was 30 kg from one colony, an apiary had to travel 200 km from their home location (robinia or heather honeyflow): when it rose to over 40 kg from one colony, the distance grew up to 400 km (honeydew honeyflow).

Based on those assumptions about productivity and costs involved in honey production, break-even points were calculated at three prices for honey: $2, 3 and 5/kg ($1 = 2.28 zl). They are the transaction price, which beekeepers can get for different assortments of exported honey. This price is without ad valorem duty. The gross profit was calculated, which was different between income from selling of the bee colony products and sum of fixed and variable cost.

RESULTS

For a homestead, stationary apiary with 50 colonies, the break-even point, expressed as kilograms of honey produced by one colony, at the price of $2/kg, is mere 5.2 kg (Tab. 3). At the prices of $3 or $5/kg of honey, the break-even points are 3.1 and 1.7kg, respectively. An apiary of this size (50 colonies), situated 15 km away from the beekeeper’s home, would have to yield on average 28.1, 12.4 and 6.7kg of honey per colony, sold at the prices of $2, 3 or 5/kg, respectively,. Such production output can be obtained in every production season in our country.

Table 3 Break-even point of beekeeping production in kgs of honey per colony Próg opłacalności produkcji pasiecznej (kg miodu przeliczeniowego od 1 rodziny)

Export price Cena (Eksport) [ $ ] Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 50 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 50* Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 100 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 200 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 300
2,0 21,8 5,2 12,2 7,3 5,8
3,0 12,4 3,1 7,1 4,3 3,4
5,0 6,7 1,7 3,9 2,4 1,9
  • – Homestead apiary- Pasieka przydomowa
strona 11

Apiaries with 100, 200 or 300 colonies would reach break-even points more easily. Even at the low price of $2/kg, it is small and amount to 12.2, 7.3 and 5.8 kg, respectively. Such outputs of honey can be produced in any production season and need not be supplemented with the by-product production of pollen trapping.

The beekeepers, who run an intensive aspiary, will mainly be interested in gross profit earned by their production. Table four shows that the gross profit of 5,225 zl could be turned out by an apiary with 50 colonies, each yielding 50 kg of honey, which sells at the price of $2/kg. The productivity of 50 kg may occur only in the years of exceptionally favourable conditions to honey production, provided bees are transported to at least 3 – 4 honeyflows. It is only big apiaries with 200 or 300 colonies that can turn a satisfactory profit of 11,750 zl or 19,233 zl, respectively, at the productivity of 30 kg and the price of $2/kg (Tab. 4). On comparison with average of net salary in Poland (8,000 zl) it was 147 and 240%, respectively.

Table 4 Gross profit by differential productivity of apiaries (by price = 2.00$) Zysk brutto przy zróżnicowanej wydajności produkcyjnej (przy cenie wynoszącej 2,00$)

Productivity Wydajność Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 50 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 50* Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 100 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 200 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 300
20 -3234,4 643,6 -2104,4 470,4 2302,8
30 -414,4 3463,6 3535,6 11750,0 19223,0
40 2405,6 6283,6 9175,6 23030,0 36143,0
50 5225,6 9103,6 14816,0 34310,0 53063,0
  • – Homestead apiary- Pasieka przydomowa

At the price of $3/kg, the beekeeper running an apiary with 50 colonies can earn a satisfactory profit (8,045.60 zl – about 100% of average of net salary in Poland), provided each colony yields 40kg of honey (Tab. 5). A homestead apiary with 50 colonies can earn a small gross profit (3,463.60 zl) at the average productivity of 20kg. Should productivity rise to 40 or 50kg, the gross profit would increase to 11,924 and 16,154 zl, respectively. An apiary with 200 or 300 colonies will turn a satisfactory profit of 11,750 and 19,223 zl, respectively, at the productivity of 20kg. When 1 kilogram of honey costs $5, an apiary of any size can earn a good profit producing 20 kg from one hive (Tab. 6).

strona 12

Table 5 Gross profit by differential productivity of apiaries (by price = 3.00$) Zysk brutto przy zróżnicowanej wydajności produkcyjnej (przy cenie wynoszącej 3.00$)

Productivity Wydajność Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 50 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 50* Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 100 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 200 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 300
20 -414,4 3463,6 3535,6 11750,0 19223,0
30 3815,6 7693,6 11996,0 28670,0 44603,0
40 8045,6 11924,0 20456,0 45590,0 69983,0
50 12276,0 16154,0 28916,0 62510,0 95363,0
  • – Homestead apiary- Pasieka przydomowa

Table 6 Gross profit by differential productivity of apiaries (by price = 5.00$) Zysk brutto przy zróżnicowanej wydajności produkcyjnej (przy cenie wynoszącej 5.00$)

Productivity Wydajność Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 50 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 50* Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 100 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 200 Size of apiary [number of colony] Wielkość pasieki [liczba rodzin]: 300
20 5225,6 9103,6 14815,6 34310,4 53062,8
30 12275,6 16153,6 28915,6 62510,4 95362,8
40 19325,6 23203,6 43015,6 90710,4 137662,8
50 26375,6 30253,6 57115,6 118910,4 179962,8
  • – Homestead apiary- Pasieka przydomowa

DISCUSSION

The break-even points for all the apiaries under study, at the prices of $2, 3 and 5 per kilo of honey, are small enough to be reached in any production season, however unfavourable to beekeeping. The beekeeper, who manages an apiary with 50 colonies may expect to produce sufficient amounts every year. Some doubts may arise as regards the profitablity of an apiary with 50 hives at the price of $2kg of honey,

strona 13

especially when the average honey yield in Poland for the past years is considered (10 – 15 kg from one colony). The by-product pollen trapping should make it feasible. Nevertheless, in order to reach the break-even point at an apiary with 50 colonies at the price of $3 or 5/kg (3.1 and 1.7 kg, respectively), the beekeeper should live in an area rich in either heathers or honeydew yielding corniferous forests. In Polish climatic conditions, those honeyflow may not be available every year. In conclusion, it can be assumed that Polish apiaries will compete rather well in the European market.

All the analysed apiaries can earn gross profit. Homestead apiary, with its low production costs, may successfully compete in Europe at yields of 20 – 30 kg. This conclusion is in consent with our earlier studies (Cichoń and Wilde 1996), which proved that homestead apiaries can be competitive in the world markets, even at a price as low as $1/kg. Nevertheless, gross profit is more readily realized at large commodity apiaries with 200 – 300 hives. When attractive assortments of honey which sell at fancy prices are produced, a satisfactory gross profit is turned at the yield of 20 kg from one colony. Apart from an intensive, movable system of production, another chance for Polish beekeepers is pollen trapping at apiaries. This production sustains high produtivity, also in unfavourable years, as pollen trapping is less weather-dependent than honey production. This recommendation finds support in the studies by Pidek (1988), Wilde (1991), Wilde and Bratkowski (1995) as well as in our previous investigations (Wilde and Cichoń 1990).

The calculations of gross profit at the price of $3 or 5/kg and the yield of over 20 kg are disputable. Such a high yield of honeydew honey is potentaily attainable, nevertheless, it should be remebered that honeydew in Poland occurs no more than 2 – 3 times in a ten-year period. It is only heather honey that sells at $5/kg, but it is not produced in every year. Moreover, a yield as high as 20 kg from one colony on heather honeyflows seems unlikely to occur in the Polish weather, even in favourable years.

Our analysis clearly shows that large commodity apiaries will find it easier to compete in Europe than small ones with 50 hives. Therefore, Polish apiaries need to be restructured. Nowadays, an average Polish apiary has 20 colonies, while large apiaries of the type described in the study are very rare.

strona 14

CONCLUSIONS

1.The Polish beekeeping industry in its present form cannot compete successfully in the European market. Polish apiaries should therefore be restructured. Effective competition would be possible if the number of colonies kept at one apiary increased to 100.

2.Large apiaries with 200 -300 colonies will compete better in the European markets, even at an average yield of 30 kg of honey produced by one colony.

3.Smaller apiaries with 50 to 100 colonies may compete in the Europen market either as homestead apiaries or else producing expensive assortments of honey.

REFERENCES

Bobrzecki J., Wilde J. (1989) – Wpływ pozyskiwania obnóży pyłkowych na rozwój rodzin pszczelich. Acta Acad. Agricult. Techn. Olst., Zootechnica , 32: 253-262.

Cichoń J., Wilde J. (1996) – Konkurencyjność polskiego pszczelarstwa na rynku światowym. /w: / Konkurencyjność polskiego rolnictwa i agrobiznesu na rynkach międzynarodowych. III Kongres SERiA, Olsztyn: 579-586.

Pidek A. (1987) – Warunki ekonomiczne produkcji pszczelarskiej w latach 1982-1985. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk. 31: 75-90.

Pidek A. (1988) – Wpływ pozyskiwania pyłku na rozwój i produkcyjność rodzin pszczelich oraz efekty ekonomiczne pasiek. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk. 32: 197-213.

Pidek A. (1990) – Uwarunkowania efektywności pasiek w gospodarce rynkowej. Ogólnopolska Konferencja Naukowa: Współczesne problemy pszczelarstwa w Polsce. AR-T Olsztyn: 97-106.

Pidek A. (1991) – Trendy w ekonomice pasiek w latach 1970-88 na podstawie estymacji funkcji. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk. 35: 83-90.

Wilde J. (1991) – Einfluß der Einsatzdauer einer Pollenfalle auf die Pollenernte und Entwicklung von Bienenvölker. Apidologie 22 (4): 432-433.

Wilde J. (1995) – Czy istnieją warunki pszczelarstwa zawodowego w Polsce? Pszczelarstwo, 46 (7): 5-6.

Wilde J. (1996) – Marketing sposobem podnoszenia rentowności pasiek (część I). Pszczelarstwo, 47 (1): 16-17.

Wilde J., Bobrzecki J. (1989) – Użytkowanie powałkowego poławiacza pyłku. Pszczelarstwo, 40 (5): 14-15.

Wilde J., Bratkowski J. (1995) – Pozyskiwanie obnóży pyłkowych w pasiekach – moda czy konieczność pszczelarstwa europejskiego? Olsztyn: Nauki Rolnicze w warunkach integracji europejskiej. Materiały konferencyjne Tom III/IV. Chów i hodowla zwierząt: 112-115.

Wilde J., Cichoń J. (1990) – Pozyskiwanie obnóży pyłkowych jako sposób na poprawę opłacalności produkcji pasiecznej. Ogólnopolska Konferencja Naukowa: Współczesne problemy pszczelarstwa w Polsce. AR-T Olsztyn: 138-145.

strona 15

KONKURENCYJNOŚĆ POLSKIEGO PSZCZELARSTWA NA RYNKU EUROPEJSKIM

J. Wilde, J. Cichoń

Streszczenie

W oparciu o hipotetyczne wydajności pasiek dokonano analizy progu opłacalności, aby odpowiedzieć na pytanie czy polskie pszczelarstwo może być konkurencyjne na rynku europejskim. Szansę taką mają wszystkie analizowane pasieki, już przy cenie 2$ za kg miodu i średniej wydajności z pnia nie mniejszej niż 40 kg. Pasieki duże liczące 200-300 pni, przy cenie 2$ są konkurencyjne na rynku europejskim produkując średnio 30 kg miodu przeliczeniowego z jednej rodziny pszczelej. Pożądana jest zmiana struktury pasiek w Polsce, które powinny ulec co najmniej 3-5 krotnemu powiększeniu. Zmiana modelu gospodarowania na intensywną gospodarkę wędrowną, z wykorzystaniem 3-4 pożytków oraz wprowadzeniem pozyskiwania pyłku w pasiekach, ułatwi konkurencyjność polskich pasiek nawet w wyjątkowo niesprzyjające lata, pod względem warunków klimatyczno-pożytkowych.

Słowa kluczowe: pszczelarstwo, Polska, rynek europejski, miód, opłacalność pasieki


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 7, 14: „Europen” → European
  • s. 7: „mainly to to” → mainly to
  • s. 8: „tases” → tastes
  • s. 8: „neccessity” → necessity
  • s. 9, tab. 1: „Depretiation” → Depreciation
  • s. 9: „equipement” → equipment
  • s. 10: „expeceted” → expected
  • s. 10: „28.1″ → 21.8
  • s. 11: „aspiary” → apiary
  • s. 11: „19,233″ → 19,223
  • s. 12: „profitablity” → profitability
  • s. 12: „$2kg” → $2/kg
  • s. 13: „corniferous” → coniferous
  • s. 13: „produtivity” → productivity
  • s. 13: „potentaily” → potentially
  • s. 13: „remebered” → remembered
  • s. 14, piśmiennictwo: „von Bienenvölker” → von Bienenvölkern

Podobne wpisy