ANTYBAKTERYJNE WŁASNOŚCI PROPOLISU A WARUNKI POZYSKIWANIA TEGO SUROWCA

tekst: Helena Rybak-Chmielewska, Janina Muszyńska, Zofia Konopacka

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XXXV, 1991 — Helena Rybak-Chmielewska, Janina Muszyńska, Zofia Konopacka

strona 47

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XXXV 1991

Helena Rybak-Chmielewska, Janina Muszyńska, Zofia Konopacka

Apiculture Section, Institute of Pomology and Floriculture Puławy, Poland

Summary

A total of 129 propolis samples were collected over the years 1979—1981, 1982, 1983 and 1985 from the apiaries of the Apiculture Section, Inst. of Pomology and Floriculture in Pulawy. The collected propolis showed substantial variation from sample to sample both in the content of contaminants and in antibacterial activity. In the majority of cases high activity was associated with high yields of the product and with the site of the apiary (decidou) trees including poplars and birches). The activity of propolis was not directly related to contamination rate and colony strength.

INTRODUCTION

An increased demand for propolis makes it necessary to determine as comprehensively and accurately as possible the factors that promote the collection of high amounts of the contamination-free and active product.

The aim of the study was to determine the relationship between the antibacterial activity of propolis and the conditions in which it arises. The study was a follow-up of earlier investigations (Muszyńska, Konopacka, Rybak 1983) and are jointly meant to improve the methods for stimulating propolis production.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The investigations were conducted in the years 1979—1981 and in the year 1982, 1983 and 1985 in the apiaries of the Apiculture Section in Puławy. In the years 1979—1981 a relationship was investigated between propolis activity and the timing of its production and between propolis

strona 48

activity and the strength of the colonies of origin. In the remaining years a close attention was paid to the comparison of propolis samples coming from apiaries located at different natural environments and to the relationship between propolis activity and its contamination rate.

In the years 1979—1981 propolis was yielded by colonies described in detail (Muszyńska, Konopacka, Rybak 1983). Later on, detailed descriptions of individual colonies were discontinued to allow a simultaneous study of a greater number of propolis — producing apiaries. Those apiaries were located at different sites: woodless farmland, Vistula — side terrain bordering on farmland, Vistula — side mixed groves, river-side parkland and meadow groves, spruce forest.

In the present study the propolis was collected only from the escape boards made of perforated zinc as described earlier (Muszyńska, Konopacka, Rybak 1983). The boards were fitted in the hives after the bars were removed and were allowed to stay there for at least a month. Three collection periods were recognized each year: from 24th April to 21th June (spring), from 7th June to 10th August (summer) and from 11th August to 1st October (autumn).

Board a placement date in a given season and in a given apiary was determined both by climatic and nectar flow patterns affecting plant growth and bee colony strength and by organizational considerations. 'The boeards were fitted on different dates in different years but always within the time limits as given above. In order to obtain more unified results, the amount of propolis deposited on the board by a single colony over one study period was converted to 10 days collections. The propolis was analysed for contamination rate and antibacterial activity. The total amount of propolis collected over a given study period from a colony was subjected to analysis. To measure the contamination rate all propolis in a sample was dissolved in 96% ethanol to make a 10% propolis solution. The solution was kept in a tightly stoppered flask for 4 days and the liquid was stirred every day. Subsequently, the flask content was chilled to +4°C and passed through soft quantitative filter paper. The sediment was washed with chloroform to measure its wax content. Since the content of impurities was known for each sample the samples could be accurately compared for their antibacterial properties. The 10% solutions of propolis fractions in 96% ethanol were taken for antibacterial studies.

The antibacterial activity of propolis was tested microbiologically using the standard strain of Bacillus subtilis (Rybak-Chmielewska, Szczęsna 1990). The concentration of propolis in the medium that resulted in the complete kill of the bacterial culture was taken as an index. The range of concentrations was tentatively put at 60—600 µg/cm³. Propolis was assumed to have a high activity when it killed all bacteria in a culture at 60—200 µg/cm³, medium — active propolis killed bacteria at 200—600 µg/cm³ and low-active propolis required concentrations of more than 600 µg/cm³ to kill bacteria.

strona 49

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Description of the propolis samples. The percentag of impurities was determined in 180 propolis samples collected over the study period (Table 1).

Table 1 Distribution of investigated propolis samples over contamination ranges Udział badanych próbek propolisu w określonych przedziałach zanieczyszczeń

Trait / Cecha Total contamination level (%) / Poziom zanieczyszczeń ogólnych w procentach: do 15 Total contamination level (%) / Poziom zanieczyszczeń ogólnych w procentach: 15,1—20 Total contamination level (%) / Poziom zanieczyszczeń ogólnych w procentach: 21,1—25 Total contamination level (%) / Poziom zanieczyszczeń ogólnych w procentach: 25,1—30 Total contamination level (%) / Poziom zanieczyszczeń ogólnych w procentach: 30,1—35 Total contamination level (%) / Poziom zanieczyszczeń ogólnych w procentach: 35,1—40 Total contamination level (%) / Poziom zanieczyszczeń ogólnych w procentach: 40 and more Total contamination level (%) / Poziom zanieczyszczeń ogólnych w procentach: together / ogółem
No. of samples / Liczba próbek 14 35 36 44 24 17 10 180
Per cent samples / Procent próbek 7,8 19,4 20,0 24,4 13,4 9,4 5,6 100

The high total content of impurities exceeding 25% in more than a half of the samples arises from treating wax as a constant element of propolis contamination. The content of wax alone in the studied samples was from several to more than 10 percent and frequently reached 35%. The samples varied for their size which was due to unequal lengths of collection periods as explained in the material and methods section and also to colony-to-colony differences in propolis production capacity. Some of the samples were too small to be analysed for antibacterial activity. The characteristics was measured in 129 propolis samples. Ca. 70% of the samples were found to show medium-strong activity (Table 2). High and low-activity propolis accounted for less than 20% of all samples.

Antibacterial activity of propolis vs. year and season of collection. The average activity of propolis collected from the same site accomodating colonies originating from queens of the same bread differed over the years. Likewise, within the same apiary propolis collected in the same year and season but from different colonies may show different activity (Table 3). The substantial differences in propolis activity suggest that there are colony-to-colony differences in the way the same plant species are utilized for propolis production (Ghisalberti — 1979). We were unable to determine unequivocally which yielded propolis of especially high activity. It is noteworthy, however, that samples with the highest activity level came from locations where deciduous teres were abundant: Vistula-side meadow groves and parklands,

strona 50

Table 2 Distribution of investigated propolis samples over antibacterial activity ranges Udział badanych próbek propolisu w określonych przedziałach aktywności antybakterynej

Trait / Cecha Antibacterial propolis activity (µg/cm³ of medium) / Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu (µg/cm³ pożywki): 60—100 Antibacterial propolis activity (µg/cm³ of medium) / Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu (µg/cm³ pożywki): 200 Antibacterial propolis activity (µg/cm³ of medium) / Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu (µg/cm³ pożywki): 400 Antibacterial propolis activity (µg/cm³ of medium) / Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu (µg/cm³ pożywki): 600 Antibacterial propolis activity (µg/cm³ of medium) / Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu (µg/cm³ pożywki): over / ponad 600 Together / Razem
No. of samples / Liczba próbek 17 26 37 26 23 129
% samples / % próbek 13,2 20,2 28,7 20,1 17,8 100

Table 3 Antibacterial activity of propolis (µg/cm³ of medium) as affceted by season and year of harvest Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu (µg/cm³ pożywki) w zależności od pory sezonu i roku zbioru

Apiary / Pasieka 1980 year / 1980 rok: colony no. / Nr rozdz. 1980 year / 1980 rok: spring / wiosna 1980 year / 1980 rok: summer / lato 1980 year / 1980 rok: autumn / jesień 1981 year / 1981 rok: colony no. / Nr rozdz. 1981 year / 1981 rok: spring / wiosna 1981 year / 1981 rok: summer / lato 1981 year / 1981 rok: autumn / jesień
Stationary *¹ / Stacjonarna 36 100 100 200 12 200 — 600
39 100 200 200 48 400 400 600
48 200 400 400 4 600 400 600
40 400 400 400 33 600 400 600
12 600 600 600
Itinerant *² / Wędrowna 15 200 400 200 14 400 400 200
12 400 400 600 2 400 400 400
14 600 600 600 13 600 400 400
19 600 600 600 17 600 600 600
20 600 600 600
10 600 600 600

*¹ — all year the same area; stałe stanowisko pasieki *² — in each season different area; w każdym sezonie inne stanowisko

Vistula-side deciduous woodland, orchards and mixed groves with a high percentage of poplars and birches. The results support earlier opinions on the occurrence of resins from birches and poplars in propolis

strona 51

and their contribution to the antibacterial properties of the product (d’Albore 1979, Konig 1985, Warakomska 1985, Szalai, Szalay 1987). It is also of interest that propolis produced by the same bee colony showed little variation in activity over the entire producing season (Table 3) which may be explained by worker bees’ consistent interest in the same plant species. There are departures from the above regularity (Table 3).

Antibacterial activity of propolis vs. colony strength. The comparison of propolis activity and the strength of the producer colonies (Table 4) showed that both strong and weak colonies can produce propolis of either high or low activity. Thus there is no relationship between the two factors.

Antibacterial activity of propolis vs. rate of its contamination. There is no relationship between the antibacterial properties of contamination-free propolis solutions and the percentages of impurities in the crude material from which the solutions have been prepared (Table 5). Altho-

Table 4 Antibacterial activity of propolis vs. bee colony strength Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu a siła rodzin pszczelich

Activity / Aktywność Number of colonies / Liczba rodzin Estimated number of worker bees in a colony / Szacunkowa liczba pszczół robotnic w rodzinach
60—100 7 22 429 (17 500—31 000)
200 11 22 228 (14 000—31 000)
400 21 26 786 (10 500—45 000)
600 16 22 938 (14 000—45 000)
more, więcej 600 14 26 750 (10 0000—49 000)

Table 5 Antibacterial activity of propolis (µg/cm³ of medium) vs. percentage of impurities in investigated samples Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu (µg/cm³ pożywki) a udział zanieczyszczeń w badanych próbkach

Activity / Aktywność No. of colonies / Liczba rodzin Impurities (%) / Zanieczyszczenia w procentach: mechanical / mechaniczne Impurities (%) / Zanieczyszczenia w procentach: wax / woskowe
60—100 11 6,6 (3,1—13,5) 15,9 (7,9—28,5)
200 20 6,3 (1,5—15,4) 16,8 (6,1—39,6)
400 32 6,2 (2,0—17,5) 17,8 (3,7—35,2)
600 18 7,6 (1,7—13,9) 17,0 (6,2—31,7)
more, więcej 600 13 9,5 (4,3—17,0) 17,8 (9,1—29,2)
strona 52

ugh the average percentage of impurities rises slightly with decreasing propolis activity to each level of activity corresponds a similar range between the extreme values.

Antibacterial activity of propolis vs. propolis producingpotential of the colonies. Among the high-activity samples those from good producers i.e. colonies showing an output of more than 2 g over 10 days constitute a majority. However, it should be stressed that highly active propolis may, though less frequently, come from colonies that are poor propolis producers (Table 6).

Table 6 Antibacterial activity of propolis vs. productivity of bee colonies Antybakteryjna aktywność propolisu a produkcyjność rodzin pszczelich

Activity / Aktywność (µg/cm³ medium) No. of colonies / Liczba rodzin Average amount of propolis produced by a colony (an a 10 day basis) / Średnia ilość propolisu wg wytworzonego przez rodz. (10 dni) Percentage of colonies producing more than 2g/10 days / %-owy udział rodzin produkujących więcej niż 2g/10 dni
60—100 7 3,597 (0,733—4,839) 71,4
200 11 2,983 (0,217—4,839) 54,6
400 21 1,988 (0,012—5,634) 47,7
600 16 1,364 (0,217—3,578) 25,0
more, więcej 600 15 1,480 (0,490—3,438) 28,6

CONCLUSIONS

An average activity of propolis collected from a single site and from colonies of the same breed varies from year to year. The colonies of the same breed and from the same locations may yield propolis that differs in activity. Locations where deciduous species prevail especially those of poplars and birches seem to be especially suited to the production of highly active propolis. The activity of propolis produced by a single colony as a rule remains stable over the entire producing season (spring, summer and autumn). In the majority of studied cases high activity of propolis was associated with high yield of this product. Propolis activity is in no direct relationship to the content of impurities nor does it depend on the strength of the producer colony.

REFERENCES

d’Albore, R. (1979) L’origine géographique de la propolis. Apidologie, 10(3): 241—267

Ghisalberti, E. L. (1979) Propolis: A review. Bee World, 60(2):59—84

Konig, B. (1985) Plant sources of propolis. Bee World, 66(4):136—139.

strona 53

Muszyńska, J., Konopacka, Z., Rybak, H. (1983) Badania nad propolisem. I. Próba określenia warunków sprzyjających pozyskiwaniu propolisu. Pszczeln. Zesz. nauk. 27:59—70

Rybak-Chmielewska, H., Szczęsna, T. (1991) Wpływ różnych rozpuszczalników na aktywność biologiczną propolisu. Pszczeln. Zesz. nauk. 35:59—69

Szalai, Z., Szalay, L. (1987) Examination of polar species (Populus sp. L.) regarding propolis production. XXXI International Congress of Apiculture, programme and abstracts of papers. August 19—25, Warsaw, Poland :242

Warakomska, Z. (1985) Microscopic analysis of propolis. International symposium on apitherapy. 23—26 May, Kraków, Poland

ANTYBAKTERYJNE WŁASNOŚCI PROPOLISU A WARUNKI POZYSKIWANIA TEGO SUROWCA

Helena Rybak-Chmielewska, Janina Muszyńska, Zofia Konopacka

Streszczenie

Scharakteryzowano 129 prób propolisu zebranego w latach 1979—1981 oraz 1982, 1983 i 1985 w pasiekach Oddziału Pszczelnictwa ISK w Puławach, stosując powałki z kraty odgrodowej.

Zbiór propolisu prowadzono w trzech okresach sezonu: (wiosna) propolis gromadzony w okresie od 1.05 do 15.06, (latem) w okresie od 16.06 do 30.08 i (jesienią) w okresie od 1.09 do 15.10). Jedną próbę stanowił propolis uzyskany od jednej (szczegółowo opisanej) rodziny pszczelej w danym okresie sezonu. Każdą próbę charakteryzowano określając: ogólną ilość uzyskanego surowca, zawartość zanieczyszczeń mechanicznych i woskowych (w drodze estrakcji 96% etanolem i chloroformem) oraz stopień aktywności antybakteryjnej. Aktywność antybakteryjną oznaczano testem na przeżywalność Bacillus subtilis w statycznych hodowlach płynnych z dodatkiem 10% etanolowego (etanol 96%) roztworu propolisu w stężeniach od 60—600 µg/cm³ pożywki.

Przeprowadzone badania wykazały że:

Średnia aktywność propolisu uzyskanego na danym stanowisku w rodzinach tej samej rasy bywa w kolejnych latach różna.

W jednym roku i tym samym okresie sezonu rodziny tej samej rasy i z tego samego stanowiska dostarczały propolis o różnej aktywności.

Najbardziej aktywny propolis pochodził jednak ze stanowisk zasobnych w drzewa liściaste, wśród których znaczny udział miały topole i brzozy, co może sugerować, iż takie stanowiska są szczególnie przydatne do intensywnej produkcji tego surowca.

Aktywność propolisu wytworzonego przez określoną rodzinę pszczelą przeważnie utrzymywała się w ciągu całego sezonu produkcyjnego (wiosna, lato, jesień) na zbliżonym poziomie.

Wysoka aktywność propolisu w większości badanych przypadków była związana z wysokim zbiorem tego surowca. Aktywność propolisu nie pozostawała w prostej zależności od stopnia jego zanieczyszczenia i nie zależała od siły rodziny, z której go pozyskano.


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 47, streszczenie: „(decidou) trees” → (deciduous trees
  • s. 48: „boeards” → boards
  • s. 49: „percentag of” → percentage of
  • s. 49: „accomodating” → accommodating
  • s. 49: „same bread” → same breed
  • s. 49: „deciduous teres” → deciduous trees
  • s. 50, tab. 2: „antybakterynej” → antybakteryjnej
  • s. 50, tab. 3: „affceted” → affected
  • s. 51, tab. 4: „10 0000″ → 10 000
  • s. 52: „producingpotential” → producing potential
  • s. 52, tab. 6: „(an a 10 day basis)” → (on a 10 day basis)
  • s. 52, tab. 6, klasa więcej 600, liczba rodzin: „15″ → 14
  • s. 53, piśmiennictwo: „polar species” → poplar species
  • s. 53, streszczenie: „estrakcji” → ekstrakcji

Podobne wpisy