AN EVALUATION OF THE PRODUCTION METHODS OF BEE PACKAGES

tekst: Jerzy Wilde, Janusz Bratkowski, Maciej Siuda

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XL, 1996 — Jerzy Wilde, Janusz Bratkowski, Maciej Siuda

strona 17

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XL, Nr 2 1996

Jerzy Wilde, Janusz Bratkowski,Maciej Siuda

Apiculture Department, University of Agriculture and Technology in Olsztyn, ul. Oczapowskiego 5, 10-957 Olsztyn, POLAND, e-mail: jurwild@moskit.art. olsztyn.pl

Summary

In Poland, little attention has been given so far to the production of bees at an apiary in order to either make bee packages or to improve colonies working on late honey flow. In our experiment, twenty-four colonies were examined in 1995 and twenty-seven a year later. In the first year of the experiment four methods were tested: weak nucleus formation (NW), strong nucleus formation (NS), capped brood removal at 9 (CB9) and 14 (CB14) days’ interval. In 1996, three groups were compared: CB14 and NS, as well as a new group, DR, in which nuclei were made by dividing each colony into 3 or 4 parts after the flowering of winter rape. In the first year of the experiment, the groups produced from 5.0 to 6.7 kg of bees. No statistical difference was observed among them. In the following year the formation of strong nuclei (NS – 8.1 kg) proved to be most effective. This result was significantly better than that of the CB14 group (2.6 kg), in which brood was removed every 14 days. The highest values indicate that bee colonies could potentially produce more bees, providing optimal conditions for their development.

Key words: bee packages, brood, bees, apiculture technology

INTRODUCTION

Numerous attempts have been made in order to raise the profitability of Polish apiaries and, thus, to overcome the regression they have suffered (Marzec 1992, Pidek 1990). For Polish beekeepers, honey production is the principal source of income, while other products remain marginal. In other words, the production potential of a bee colony is not fully realised. Many authors recommend a more versatile production profile, which would eventually raise profi t (Bobrzecki, Wilde 1991, Wilde, Cichoń 1990). Polish beekeepers, however, are unfamiliar with technologies of producing bees for sale in packages. Such packaged bees are in demand in the world market, to the extent that some apiaries purchase and use packages seasonally instead of wintering their colonies. Each package contains one queen and some bees (usually 1.5 to 2.5 kg). In time, a package grows into a valuable bee colony, whose productivity is, by no means, inferior to that of traditional colonies

strona 18

(Mc Donald, Mann- er 1984). Mc Cutcheon (1987) believes that 6 kg of bees, or else three packages, could be obtained from one colony at an apiary, which mainly produces honey. Such production is economical at the minimum of 100 hives. In Poland this has not been done in practice yet. Theoretical calculations indicate that 10 to 14 kg of bees could be produced by a colony kept in the conditions typical for Poland (Wilde 1995). However, if bees for packages are removed at the end of the honey flow season, they cannot be used until the next season. Their wintering would incur additional costs and risk. It seems more advisable to package them during the season and add them to colonies working on late honey flow, which are expected to produce 5 kg of honey per 1 kg of bees. Marcinkowski (1991) revealed a detrimental effect of multiple removal of bees on the future development of their colony. His studies indicate that a single removal of bees is not harmful, provided that no more than 40% of bees are removed and the colony receives supplementary feeding of protein and sugar. However, negative consequences of a single collection, aggravated by the removal of brood and insufficient feeding, occur for 40 to 50 days afterwards.

Is it feasible then, in our weather conditions, to improve the profitability of apiaries by promoting the production of packaged bees? To a large extent, it depends on the total number of bees produced as well as on the price offered. The aim of our study has been to estimate how many bees could be produced in Polish weather conditions and honey flow, as well as to compare production methods.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The experiment was carried out at the apiary of the Apiculture Institute, at the University of Agriculture and Technology in Olsztyn, on 24 bee colonies in 1995 and on 27 in 1996. Four experimental groups were formed in the first year of the experiment: NW – weak nuclei, NS – strong nuclei, CB14 – capped brood removed every 14 days, CB9 – capped brood removed every 9 days. Weak nuclei were made from 30 dm2 capped brood and 0.6 kg of bees; strong nuclei required 50 dm2 of capped brood and 1 kg of bees. No CB9 group was tested in 1996, whereas the NW group was slightly modified. After the flowering of winter rape, each colony, at its maximum strength, was partitioned into 3 or 4 nuclei. The other two groups were unaltered. Brood was collected and nuclei were formed from 5.06 to 27.06.1995 and from 5.06 to 16.07.1996. Every year, all capped brood was taken away in order to form the maximum number of nuclei from each colony. In both years, Carniolan virgin queens were introduced to new nuclei formed until mid June, afterwards nuclei received egg-laying queens. Removed brood combs were transferred to incubation colonies and put over

strona 19

a queen excluder. In that time they were kept in a 435×230 mm frame, in one hive chamber. In early September, bees in incubating colonies and nuclei were counted on the basis of the number of combs with bees that had emerged from the incubated brood and from the eggs laid by the queens that had been introduced to the nuclei. In the case of the nucleus groups, their brood was also added, assuming that 1 dm2 of brood included 412 bee cells. We assumed that there were 350 bees per 1 dm2 of a two-sided comb. This figure was estimated empirically, by weighing bees that were shaken off 5 colonies. After the flowering of winter rape in 1995, each colony was fed 4 kg of sugar and yeast dough. In 1996 honey was not produced. All the colonies present at the apiary received 0.25 litre of sugar syrup (1:1) on the days when a daily weight gain in the control hive was below 0.5 kg. Each colony was fed 31 times and an average of 3.7 kg of sugar was used in the period of 42 days when brood was taken and nuclei formed (5.06 – 16.07). Nests were extended with a comb foundation.

All numerical data collected during the experiment were processed with the Statigrafics programme (Dąbkowski 1992). Significance of differences was determined by variance analysis (ANOVA) and multiple range test with least significant difference range (LSD). Values that differed significantly at 0.05 are marked with small letters. Those were significant differences were at 0.01 are indicated with capitals.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

WEATHER AND HONEY FLOW

In 1994/1995 the winter was mild. Snow cover appeared rarely and did not last long. The air temperatures were relatively high. Such favourable weather allowed bees to make their first flight on 15 February. Early spring was wet, windy and cold, so it retarded plant vegetation and growth. Late spring was drastically different, with temperatures reaching 30°C. High temperatures, together with thoroughly drenched soil, caused a rapid growth of plants. Therefore, despite the initial delay, winter rape came to bloom on 6 May and was well utilised by bees. High weight gains, up to 5.8 kg per hive, were recorded. No honey flow was available after winter rape, so bees were fed with sugar and yeast dough. In mid July lime trees flowered and other sources of honey flow, typical for that period, appeared.

Hot, sunny days, with temperatures over 30°C, predominated in the late season. Little precipitation occurred. Honey weight gains in the control hive were highly volatile. Weather and honey flow conditions favoured high production of honey, but not an intensive development of bee colonies. The early spring – long, cold and rainy – defected their strength, and the spells of hot weather, which followed, caused a very intensive development and

strona 20

early swarming.

The winter of 1995/1996 was extremely long and freezing (one of the most severe winters in this century). It caused a high loss in bee colonies, up to 50% in some areas of Poland. In Warmia, the winter loss ranged at approximately 30%. Bees made their first flight on 5 April. The vegetation of plants was delayed. In the north-east of Poland, most winter rape froze and had to be ploughed in, bringing no honey flow. Therefore, bee colonies had to be fed with sugar syrup (1;1), as feeding them with sugar and yeast dough was ineffective and no significant weight gains were observed in the control hive. It was only from 8 to 19 July that supplementary feeding could be stopped, due to sufficient weight gain achieved from spring rape and first flowering lime trees. Experimental treatments on bee colonies were resumed rather late in 1996, as new colonies had to be purchased and transferred to multichamber hives. Despite regular feeding and the removal of bees, the bees bought in that year tended to swarm, which, in extreme cases, made their queens cease oviposition.

PRODUCTIVITY OF BEE COLONIES

In 1995 the smallest amount of brood was obtained by the weak nucleus formation (NW – 6.42 m2 tab.1). Significantly more brood was removed from the CB9 group (127.2 dm2). In the other two groups over 100 dm2 of brood was collected, at no significant difference. In both NW and NS groups less than 2 kg of bees was removed prior to the formation of nuclei, and the differences between these groups were insignificant. By the end of the production season the colonies produced 5 to 6.7 kg of bees, and differences among them showed no statistical variation.

T a b l e 1 Removed brood (in dcm2) and bees (in kg) and total bees producted (in kg) of the end of season 1995 Odebrany czerw (w dm2) i pszczoły (w kg) oraz pszczoły ogółem (w kg) uzyskane w końcu sezonu w 1995 roku

Group Grupa Brood Czerw: x̄ Brood Czerw: zakres Bees Pszczoły: x̄ Bees Pszczoły: zakres Total bees Pszczoły ogółem: x̄ Total bees Pszczoły ogółem: zakres
NW 64.2^a 31 – 117 1.3 0.6 – 2.4 5.5 2.9 – 6.7
NS 100.7 52.5 – 147 1.9 1 – 2.8 6.7 4 – 9.2
CB9 127.2^b 97.6 – 187.9 – – 5.2 4.0 – 7.7
CB14 120.3 62 – 183 – – 5.0 2.6 – 7.5
strona 21

Explanations to Table 1 – Objaśnienia do Tabeli 1 NW – weak neuclei – odkłady słabe NS – strong nuclei – odkłady silne CB9 – removed capped brood every 9. day – odbieranie czerwiu krytego co 9 dni CB14 – removed capped brood every 14. day – odbieranie czerwiu krytego co 14 dni Different letters indicates significant differences at p=0.05 Różne litery oznaczają różnice dla p=0.05

T a b l e 2 Removed brood (in dcm2) and bees (in kg) and total bees producted (in kg) of the end of season 1996 Odebrany czerw (w dm2) i pszczoły (w kg) oraz pszczoły ogółem (w kg) uzyskane w końcu sezonu w 1996 roku

Group Grupa Brood Czerw: x̄ Brood Czerw: zakres Bees Pszczoły: x̄ Bees Pszczoły: zakres Total bees Pszczoły ogółem: x̄ Total bees Pszczoły ogółem: zakres
DR 122.5^b 114.8-137.8 2.4 2.3-2.8 4.8 4.6-5.2
CB14 64^a 40-81.5 – – 2.6^a 1.6-3.4
NS 89.9 65.6-136.6 1.8 2.0-3.6 8.1^b 4.1-16.1

Explanations – Objaśnienia: DR – partition of colonies – dzielenie rodzin CB14 – removed capped brood every 14. day – odbieranie czerwiu krytego co 14 dni NS – strong nuclei – odkłady silne Different letters indicates significant differences at p=0.05 Różne litery oznaczają różnice dla p=0.05

The removal of brood at 9 days’ intervals seemed to be a very promising method. However, it involved regular visits to the apiary. Moreover, a bee colony would eventually deteriorate towards the end of the season due to such frequent and prolonged brood removal. No such deterioration happened when brood was removed every 14 days.

The CB14 group, in which brood was removed every fortnight, was least productive in the whole season. It produced significantly less brood (64 dm2) than the DR group (122.5 dm2), in which colonies were partitioned after the flowering of winter rape. This relation lasted unchanged to the end of the production season. The CB14 produced total of 2.6 kg of bees. Significantly more bees were collected from strong nuclei (NS – 8.1 kg). Bees, whose brood was removed, belonged to a local population and were purchased before the season, which may account for their low productivity. Those bees failed to rebuild the comb foundation they had been given, and that may have been another impulse to stop oviposition. The observations reported by Marcinkowski (1991) and Pidek (1989) confirm such behaviour. The latter author noticed that colonies that had to rebuild a whole nest were rapidly losing their strength and some of them dropped

strona 22

during the overwintering. Rebuilt combs, used exclusively, would very likely be more effective.

The results from the best colonies of bees (range values) in each group indicate that, potentially, more brood could be removed and, therefore, more bees produced. Best colonies produced nearly 200 dm2 of brood in 1995. This figure could yet be higher, should the removal of brood and bees be carried out longer. The same is true about the total number of bees produced at the end of the season. Best colonies produced from 7.5 to 9.2 kg bees in 1995, and, in the following season, one NS colony (strong nuclei) produced 16.1 kg of bees. The results obtained in the DR and NS groups in 1996 are consistent with the data reported by Pidek (1984), who proved that strong nuclei reared their brood 1.5 times more effectively than weak nuclei. It is worthwhile noticing that in the latter example 8 out 30 nuclei had to be terminated as queens were not well accepted. Such high loss was not recorded for the strong nucleus group, where only 3 out of 14 nuclei formed were terminated. Another important factor is a sufficient supply of pollen and carbohydrate feed. Food shortages, which occurred during the 1995 season, were balanced out by feeding bees with yeast and sugar dough. In the next year, each colony was fed with approximately 3.1 kg of sugar in form of sugar syrup (1:1). More carbohydrate feed and, according to the recommendations made by Marcinkowski (1991), an appropriate supply of pollen offered to weak colonies, would increase the number of bees produced seasonally.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the experiment support the following conclusions:

  1. All the examined methods allow production of bees for packages, but none of them could be considered the most effective. They all yielded 5 to 6 kg of bees on average, although in 1996, a record amount of 8.1 kg of bees was produced by the method of strong nucleus formation.
  2. An analysis of extreme values indicates a high production potential of bee colonies, which could be realised through an improvement of conditions, a more intensive development of bee colonies, and a supplementary feed of sugar syrup.
  3. An effort to rebuild a comb foundation discourages bees from developing their colonies faster. Therefore, nests should rather be extended with rebuilt combs exclusively.
strona 23

REFERENCES

Bobrzecki J., Wilde J. (1991) – Wpływ pozyskiwania obnóży trzema rodzajami poławiaczy pyłku na rozwój i produkcyjność rodzin pszczelich. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 35: 19-27.

Dąbkowski J. (1992) – Statgrafics – System statystycznego opracowania danych. Komputerowa Oficyna Wydawnicza „Help”: 1-240.

Marcinkowski J. (1991) – Wpływ gwałtownego osłabienia rodzin pszczelich na ich rozwój i efekty produkcyjne. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 35: 29-38.

Marcinkow ski J. (1994) – Możliwości poprawy efektywności prowadzenia pasiek przez wzbogacanie wyboru produktów pasiecznych. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 38: 91-99.

Mc Cutcheon D. (1987) – Queen, package bee and nucleus production in B.C., Apiculture program Ministry of Agriculture and Food British Columbia: 17-24.

Mc Donald D., Monner G. (1984) – An economic comparison of wintering and package bees in the Peace River region. Alberta Agriculture. 821: 19.

Marzec J. (1992) – Ocena warunków ekonomicznych produkcji pasiecznej na podstawie relacji cen w latach 1984-1990. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 36: 26-31.

Pidek A. (1984) – Efekty rozmnażania rodzin pszczelich poprzez tworzenie odkładów różnej siły. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 28: 141-151.

Pidek A. (1989) – Efekty ograniczania czerwienia matek pszczelich przed pożytkiem głównym oraz całkowitej odbudowy gniazd po jego zakończeniu. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 33: 121-131.

Pidek A. (1990) – Uwarunkowania efektywności pasiek w gospodarce rynkowej. Ogólnopolska Konferencja Naukowa: Współczesne problemy pszczelarstwa w Polsce. ART Olsztyn. Materiały konferencyjne. Olsztyn.: 97-106.

Wilde J. (1995) – Produkcja pakietów w Polsce – rzeczywistość czy fantazja? Pszczelarstwo, 46 (6): 8-9.

Wilde J., Cichoń J. (1990) – Pozyskiwanie obnóży pyłkowych jako sposób na poprawę opłacalności produkcji pasiecznej. Ogólnopolska Konferencja Naukowa: Współczesne problemy pszczelarstwa w Polsce. ART Olsztyn. Materiały konferencyjne. Olsztyn: 141-148.

OCENA METOD PRODUKCJI PSZCZÓŁ W FORMIE PAKIETÓW

J. Wilde, J. Bratkowski, M. Siuda

Streszczenie

Głównym źródłem dochodu dla pszczelarzy w naszym kraju jest miód, zaleca się jednak wprowadzenie wielokierunkowej produkcji w pasiekach (Bobrzecki, Wilde 1991, Marcinkowski 1994, Wilde, Cichoń 1990). Możliwości związane z technologiami produkcji pszczół i sprzedaży ich w formie pakietów pszczelich są nieznane polskim pszczelarzom.

Celem przedstawionej pracy było określenie ilości pszczół możliwych do uzyskania w sezonie pasiecznym oraz porównanie metod pasiecznych, intensyfikujących ten kierunek produkcji.

Doświadczenie przeprowadzono w 1995 i 1996 roku na 51 rodzinach pszczelich. W 1995 roku utworzono 4 grupy doświadczalne: NW – odkłady słabe, NS – odkłady silne, CB14 –

strona 24

odbieranie czerwiu krytego co 14 dni, CB9 – odbieranie czerwiu krytego co 9 dni. W 1996 roku utworzono trzy grupy doświadczalne, rezygnując z odbierania czerwiu co 9 dni, a w grupie NW każdą rodzinę dzielono na 3-4 odkłady, po przekwitnięciu rzepaku ozimego. W dwóch pozostałych grupach postępowano, tak jak w roku poprzednim. W 1995 roku rodzinom po przekwitnięciu rzepaku ozimego podano po 4 kg ciasta cukrowo-drożdżowego. W następnym roku zrezygnowano z produkcji miodu, a w okresach, kiedy przybytki masy ula kontrolnego nie przekraczały 0,5 kg/dzień rodzinom podawano rzadki syrop cukrowy (1:1).

W 1995 roku w grupie CB9 (127,2 dm2) odebrano istotnie więcej czerwiu w porównaniu z grupą NW (64,2 dm2- tabela 1). W końcu sezonu uzyskano od rodzin od 5 do 6,7 kg pszczół, jednakże różnice te nie były statystycznie zróżnicowane. W 1996 roku najsłabszą grupą okazała się ta, w której odbierano czerw co 14 dni (CB14 – 64 dm2). Odebrano go istotnie mniej w porównaniu z grupą DR (122,5 dm2). W końcu sezonu dała także najmniej pszczół ogółem – 2,6kg. Najwięcej uzyskano ich w grupie NS (8,1 kg) i tylko pomiędzy tymi grupami była istotna. Bardzo słabe wyniki produkcyjne rodzin grupy CB14 można tłumaczyć niską wartością hodowlaną pszczół, które wywodziły się z nieselekcjonowanej, miejscowej populacji. Zdarzało się także, iż matki w tej grupie zaprzestawały czerwienia. Takie zachowanie pszczół potwierdzałoby wyniki uzyskane przez Marcinkowskiego (1991) oraz Pidka (1989). Ten ostatni obserwował gwałtowne osłabnięcie rodzin odbudowujących całe gniazdo oraz osypywanie się części z nich w czasie zimowli.

Wyniki najlepszych rodzin w grupach wskazują, iż można pozyskać więcej pszczół. W 1995 roku od najlepszych rodzin odebrano blisko 200 dm2 czerwiu, a w 1996 roku od jednej rodziny w grupie NS (odkłady silne) uzyskano 16,1 kg pszczół. Uzyskane wyniki w 1996 roku potwierdzają badania Pidka (1984), twierdzącego, iż odkłady silne efektywniej o 1,5 raza wychowują czerw niż odkłady słabe. Zwiększenie ilości pokarmu węglowodanowego, ale także właściwie zaopatrzenie rodzin w pyłek, tak jak zaleca Marcinkowski (1991) w przypadku rodzin osłabianych, może zwiększyć ilość wyprodukowanych pszczół w sezonie.

Stosowane metody umożliwiły wyprodukowanie średnio 5-6 kg pszczół, a jedynie w 1996 roku wykonywanie odkładów silnych – 8,1 kg. Uzyskane wartości skrajne pozwalają przypuszczać, iż istnieją duże możliwości produkcyjne rodzin pszczelich, które można wykorzystać stwarzając rodzinom pszczelim lepsze warunki do intensywnego rozwoju np. poszerzać gniazda odbudowanymi plastrami.

Słowa kluczowe: pakiety pszczół, czerw, pszczoły, technologie pasieczne


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 17: „profi t” → profit
  • s. 19: „Statigrafics” → Statgraphics
  • s. 20: „6.42 m2″ → 64.2 dm2
  • s. 20, 21: „producted” → produced
  • s. 21: „neuclei” → nuclei
  • s. 23, piśmiennictwo: „Statgrafics” → Statgraphics
  • s. 23, piśmiennictwo: „Marcinkow ski” → Marcinkowski

Podobne wpisy