SPECIFIC COMBINATION OF CARNICA LINES TO IMPROVE PRODUCTIVITY AND VARROATOLERANCE

tekst: Ralph Büchler

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XL, 1996 — Ralph Büchler

strona 119

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XL, Nr 2 1996

Ralph Büchler

Hessische Landesanstalt für Tierzucht, Abteilung für Bienenzucht, Erlenstraße 9, 35274 Kirchhain, GERMANY

Summary

Queens and drones of the breeding line of the institute in Kirchhain (K) and from the Carnica lines Troiseck-07 (7), Troiseck-Celle (C). and Peschetz (P) were used to form the combinations: K*K, K*7, 7*K, K*C, C*K, P*K and K*P. 14-17 queens of each group and a total of 110 colonies were tested in 1993 and 1994 for honey production, defense behaviour, swarming and several characters of varroa tolerance.

Significant differences in the honey production and the defense behaviour were observed between the groups. Maternal effects clearly influence the productivity. Line K is better qualified for drone than for queen production. In tendency, the pure mating K*K showed the lowest mite infestation. Line C differed significantly from lines 7 and P by a lower defense behaviour and a lower rate of damaged mites.

Keywords: Varroa jacobsoni, tolerance, Apis mellifera carnica, productivity

INTRODUCTION

Breeding programs with honey bees usually focus on the improvement by additive genetic effects. Apart from these, heterosis and maternal effects can considerably contribute to the genetic predisposition of an organism.

In general, maternal effects may be based on genetic factors located in the cell plasma or on the environmental influence of the mother on the development of the organism. For the performance of honey bee colonies, an additional maternal component can be distinguished due to the direct influence of the queen on many colony traits within the two-generation structure of this social organism (Bienefeld & Pirchner 1990).

A basic investigation on the impact of heterosis and maternal effects of crossbreds within the Carnica race has been carried out cooperatively by several bee research institutes in Germany within the last years. Maternal effects showed a clear influence on the Varroa development and the postcapping stage duration of the test population and highly significant differences were found between the maternal qualities of the lines (Hoffmann, 1995; Hoffmann et al 1995).

strona 120

By the following investigation, the maternal qualities of the breeding line of our institute, the “Kirchhain Population“, in relation to other Carnica breeding lines and, furthermore, the impact of heterosis on perfomance and varroa infestation should be tested.

METHODS

Queens were bred from 5-7 and drones from 3-5 breeder colonies for each of the 4 Carnica lines: Kirchhain (K), Troiseck-07 (7), Troiseck-Celle (C). and Peschetz (P). The reciprocal crosses: 7*K, K*7, K*C, C*K, K*P and P*K as well as a reference group K*K were produced by artificial insemination and the use of the sperm mixing technique.

In 1992, 14-17 queens of each group were introduced into a total of 110 test colonies in two beeyards of the institute near Kirchhain and three external beeyards in northern Germany. For each beeyard, the maximum difference in the number of queens per group was one. In 1993 and 1994, the colonies were tested for honey production, defense behaviour, swarming tendency and characters of varroatolerance according to the recommendations of the German beekeepers association (Büchler, 1996; Deutscher Imkerbund, 1992). The honey yield was measured separately for the spring (until 15.06.) and the summer period. Defense behaviour and swarming tendency were valued in points from 1 (negative) to 4 (positive). An initial standardization of the infestation level by introducing about 90 mites per colony in December had been achieved for all colonies of the first testing year and the colonies in the two beeyards near Kirchhain in the second year. The final infestation rate of all testcolonies was determined by treatments with Bayvarol or formic acid in the following August/September respectively. For the Bayvarol treated colonies, the mites killed within the first 24 hours of treatment were collected separately to distinguish between the rates of mites on adult bees and in the broodcells. The brood hygienic behavior was checked by 2-3 pin tests (Büchler, 1994) throughout the season. As an indication for grooming activities, the rate of damaged mites was checked for a part of the colonies during several weeks in June/July. On average, 76 mites/colony were checked and only samples with at least 20 mites were used for the evaluation.

The percentage values of the pin test were logit transformed (logit p = ln p/(1-p)); for the other characters, the original data were used in the statistical analysis. The data of both years were handled as independent observations. The number of evaluated observations is mentioned with the results for each character.

strona 121

T a b l e 1 Mean values of the different combinations for the testet characters

Character n^1) Combination: K x K Combination: K x 7 Combination: 7 x K Combination: K x C Combination: C x K Combination: K x P Combination: P x K Combination: p^4)
Spring honey [kg] 118 x^2) 28,7 22,9 33,5 31,6 25,1 28,3 33,8 0,012
s^3) 3,2 3,0 2,3 2,5 2,4 2,2 2,4
Summer honey [kg] 109 x 12,7 11,1 18,2 15,8 16,7 19,9 20,6 0,110
s 3,3 3,0 2,3 2,6 2,4 2,2 2,4
Total honey [kg] 113 x 41,2 34,7 49,1 47,3 41,3 49,2 54,2 0,023
s 4,8 4,7 3,4 3,9 3,8 3,5 3,9
Def. behav. [points] 114 x 2,76 2,54 2,48 2,89 3,00 2,49 2,71 0,008
s 0,15 0,16 0,11 0,12 0,12 0,11 0,12
Swarming [points] 114 x 2,99 2,88 2,84 2,85 2,76 3,05 2,45 0,838
s 0,35 0,38 0,26 0,30 0,29 0,26 0,30
Varroa infest. [mites] 103 x 428 437 667 912 943 753 1028 0,407
s 237 305 182 202 204 182 222
Rate of bee inf. [%] 68 x 36,4 28,1 26,1 26,4 27,6 25,7 24,8 0,379
s 3,9 6,7 3,3 3,1 3,4 3,8 4,1
Brood hyg. [logit %] 88 x 3,28 2,99 2,25 2,74 3,04 3,42 3,21 0,548
s 0,54 0,70 0,47 0,47 0,48 0,42 0,45
Damaged mites [%] 23 x 55,7 53,0 59,6 45,9 50,4 59,9 61,1 0,332
s 6,9 9,8 4,2 5,2 6,2 4,8 5,7

Remarks: ^1) evaluated observations, ^2) ls-mean, ^3)standard error, ^4)probability, that no differences between the combinations exist

The data were analysed with an ANOVA function (SAS, 1989). The model regarded the effects of season, beeyard and group. Least square means and its standard errors, corrected for enviromental effects, were estimated for the combinations and lines. Differences between pure K*K and the other combinations were tested by linear contrasts.

strona 122

RESULTS

In Table 1 the ls-mean values of the different combinations are presented. Significant differences were observed for the spring honey, the total honey production and for the defense behaviour. The honey yield during spring of the groups 7*K and P*K was higher (p ≤ 0,05) compared to the groups K*7 and C*K and also from group K*C compared to K*7; the total honey yields of the combinations 7*K, K*C, K*P and P*K were higher than of group K*7 and combination P*K surpassed the combinations C*K and K*K. Group C*K showed a lower (p ≤ 0,05) defense behaviour than 7*K, K*7 and K*P and group K*C had a significantly lower defense behaviour than 7*K and K*P.

There were great differences in the varroa infestation noted, but they were not significant (p ≤ 0,05) due to great standard errors. The lowest infestation was observed for the reference group K*K.

Regarding the maternal qualities of line K, a general inferiority of combinations with K in maternal position compared to combinations with K in paternal position can be stated for the spring honey production (p = 0,1).

A general difference between the pure line K and the average of all its combinations with other lines, which might indicate an influence of heterosis, was only found for the rate of bee infestation. Group K*K showed a significantly (p ≤ 0,05) higher rate of the total mite infestation located on the adult bees.

To compare the additive genetic effects of the different mating partners, ls-means of the reciprocal crosses with K are presented in table 2. Line C transmitted a lower defense behaviour than the lines 7 and P (p ≤ 0,01) as well as a lower rate of damaged mites (p ≤ 0,05). In tendency, the honey productivity of line P surpassed the other lines.

DISCUSSION

The results confirm the importance of specific combinations to improve the productivity of honeybees. While the average honey yield of all crossbreds does not significantly differ from the pure line K, the combination of P*K clearly surpasses the productivity of K*K.

Specific crossing effects can be explained by heterosis and maternal effects. Since comparable groups of pure 7*7, C*C and P*P matings could not be included in this investigation, the effect of heterosis cannot be estimated in this investigation. However, an influence of maternal effects is clearly proven. The honey yield of the reciprocal crossings 7*K and K*7 is significantly different, and for the average of all crossings a general advantage of crossings with K in paternal position is shown on a low

strona 123

significant level.

T a b l e 2 Mean values of different mating partners in combination with line K

Character n^1) Mating partner: 7 Mating partner: C Mating partner: P Mating partner: p^4)
Spring honey [kg] 107 x^2) 30,4 28,7 31,2 0,598
s^3) 2,0 2,0 1,8
Summer honey [kg] 99 x 15,8 16,3 20,3 0,127
s 2,0 2,0 1,8
Total honey [kg] 102 x 45,0 44,9 52,0 0,102
s 3,0 3,0 2,8
Def. behav. [points] 102 x 2,50 2,97 2,60 0,001
s 0,09 0,09 0,09
Swarming [points] 102 x 2,82 2,75 2,74 0,956
s 0,22 0,22 0,20
Varroa infest. [mites] 91 x 619,6 912,5 872,0 0,361
s 164,1 157,2 149,3
Rate of bee inf. [%] 59 x 26,5 27,0 25,6 0,919
s 2,8 2,2 2,7
Brood hyg. [logit %] 77 x 2,44 2,92 3,32 0,173
s 0,41 0,38 0,33
Damaged mites [%] 21 x 58,6 47,5 59,7 0,045
s 3,7 4,1 3,8

Remarks: ^1) evaluated observations, ^2) ls-mean, ^3) standard error, ^4) probability, that no differences between the mating partners exist

Bienefeld & Pirchner (1990) found highly negativ genetic correlations between queen and worker effects on several colony traits. On the colony level, queen effects are expressed as maternal. The

strona 124

negative maternal effects of the “Kirchhain population“ can therefore be interpreted as the reverse side of positve worker effects. In crossbreeding, the K line may favourably be used as drone donator. Obviously, line 7 has contrary qualities and may preferably be used for queen production.

For the characters of varroatolerance, no such combing effects can be outlined from this investigation. The high standard errors for the mean varroa infestation of the groups point out a basic methodical problem: the infestation of colonies is influenced by many internal and external factors and is a very complex genetical trait of bee colonies. Nevertheless, this character plays a central role in selection programs towards varroatolerance, unless the rate or duration of colony survival without any treatments can be used.

It can be noted, that the pure K*K mating has the lowest mite infestation and differs significantly from the average of all combinations for the infestation ratio between brood and adult bees. This may be explained by a given inbreeding effect within the population or a negative heterosis effect of all the crossbreds, but could also indicate a genetic advantage of this line, which was selected on low mite infestation for two generations.

The significant differences between the mating partners tested in combination with line K demonstrate the selectability of defense behaviour and the occurence of damaged mites. For both characters, line C shows an extreme position. It´s relativ low defense behaviour was also found in other investigations (Bienefeld, 1995) and is probably a result of consequent selection. The rate of damaged mites, on the other hand, has not been a direct selection criterion up to now, and it would be interesting to study whether genetic correlations with selected traits do exist.

CONSEQUENCES

In general, breeding lines should be selected either for queen characters and be used for queen production or for worker characters and be used for drone production. Specific for the “Kirchhain population“, its productivity should be improved by combination with other lines, preferably as a drone donator. As for its varroatolerance, no advantages of crossbreeding have been shown up to now and the most promising strategy for the moment appears to be further pure line breeding aiming at an additiv genetic improvement of certain charcters, for example the grooming behavior of the bees.

strona 125

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

I would like to thank H.D Fehling, Tostedt, Dr. H. Schmidt-Uhlenkamp, Bremen and G. Staemmler, Bad Segeberg who ran the perfomance tests at the external beeyards in northern Germany.

REFERENCES

Bienefeld K. (1995) – Auswertung des Carnica-Hybridversuches, vorläufige Ergebnisse zu Leistung und Verhalten. Die Biene 131 (4): 6-7.

Bienefeld K., Pirchner F. (1990) – Heritabilities for several colony traits in the honeybee (Apis mellifera carnica). Apidologie 21: 175-183.

Büchler R. (1996) – Empfehlungen zur Varroatoleranzprüfung. Imkerfreund 51 (6):12-14.

Büchler R. (1994) – Varroa tolerance in honey bees – occurence, characters and breeding. Bee World 75 (2): 54-70.

Deutscher Imkerbund (1992) – Empfehlungen für die Leistungsprüfung von Bienenvölkern auf Prüfständen. Deutscher Imkerbund, Wachtberg.

Hoffmann S. (1995) – Genetic effects on the duration of post capping stage in combinations of three Carnioan strains. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 39 (1): 203.

Hoffmann S., Büchler R., Bienefeld K., Urfer W. (1995) – Genetische Effekte auf den Varroabefall innerhalb der Carnica-Population. Proc. 34. Intern. Apimondia Congress, Lausanne, Apimondia Publishing House, Bukarest.

S A S (1989) – Statistical analysis system. SAS Institute, Cary NC, USA.

WZROST PRODUKCYJNOŚCI I ODPORNOŚCI NA WARROZĘ WYBRANYCH KOJARZEŃ LINII PSZCZOŁY KRAIŃSKIEJ

R. Büchler

Streszczenie

W doświadczeniu podstawowym na rodach pszczoły kraińskiej, uzyskanych w wyniku naprzemiennego, wsobnego kojarzenia, wykazano mateczne efekty w stosunku do wydajności miodowej i odporności na V. jacobsoni. Były one często powiązane negatywnie z dodatnim efektem odziedziczalności. Stąd wyprowadzić można ogólne zalecenie testowania przydatności linii hodowlanych, zarówno jako ojcowskich, jak i matecznych, a dopiero potem celowego kojarzenia.

Tego rodzaju analizę przeprowadzono dla populacji z Kirchhain w porównaniu z północnoniemieckimi liniami: C-P, C-TCelle i C-T07. Przetestowano łącznie przez dwa lata 110 rodzin pszczelich w sześciu pasiekach, analizując: produkcję miodu, siłę rodzin, łagodność, rojliwość i porażenie V. jacobsoni. Przy porównaniu naprzemiennie, wsobnie kojarzonych par, ujawniła się tendencja (p<0,1) przewagi zastosowania linii z Kirchhain jako strony ojcowskiej dla: miodności, siły rodziny i jej łagodności. W przypadku rojliwości i porażenia roztoczami uzyskane efekty były niejednolite i nieznaczne.

Key words: Varroa jacobsoni, tolerance, Apis mellifera carnica, productivity

Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 120: „perfomance” → performance
  • s. 121, tab. 1: „testet” → tested
  • s. 121: „enviromental” → environmental
  • s. 123: „negativ genetic” → negative genetic
  • s. 124: „positve” → positive
  • s. 124: „occurence” → occurrence
  • s. 124: „additiv genetic” → additive genetic
  • s. 124: „charcters” → characters
  • s. 125: „perfomance” → performance
  • s. 125, piśmiennictwo: „occurence” → occurrence
  • s. 125, piśmiennictwo: „Carnioan” → Carniolan

Podobne wpisy