ECOTYPES OF TRIFOLIUM PRATENSE L. IN PROGRAMMED CULTIVATION OF TETRAPLOID VARIETIES

tekst: Stanisław Góral

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XXI, 1977 — Stanisław Góral

strona 189

BEE RESEARCH COPIES V.XXI DECEMBER 1977

Stanisław Góral

IHAR Radzików, Poland

During the cultivation of Trifolium pratense L. in different locations and under various programmed procedures, by a process of natural selection a wide variety of forms came into being. Only cultivated forms however, with straight stems, growing flourishingly, are favoured in cultivation. Uncultivated populations, having undergone merely the process of natural selection in their own locale, differ from the cultivated forms in their morphology and physiological functions. Specimens of these trefoils are, as a rule, shorter, and of more or less procumbent type. Their thin stems are filled with stem core and the amount of leaves in the green mass of such forms is visibly smaller when compared to that of sowing clover.

The great majority of scientists Janossy 1966, Julen 1956, Łączyńska-Hulewicz 1957, Nuesch 1960, Polàk 1974 examining polyploid red clover maintain that its low fertility is due to too poor a genetic base of forms obtained from cultivated tetraploids. Attempts are being made therefore, to increase the genetic mutability of polyploids produced in the course of exchanging specimen seeds between cultivation centres as well as through the polyploidization of varieties and ecotypes coming from different parts of the world. In conjunction with this, attention was focused on the uncultivated forms of Trifolium pratense L. which may be a source of genes determining not only good seed setting but also cold resistance and hardiness. These

strona 190

plant properties can be grafted relatively easily into cultivated forms of Trifolium pratense L. var. sativum Schreb through cross-fertilization. These two forms cross-fertilize easily both on the dyploidic and tetraploidic levels; their hybrids showing full fertility.

Uncultivated ecotypes of red clover can be found in Poland in numerous natural ecvironments. However the acreage of natural meadows, pastures and waste land is continually decreasing. In the near future environments of this clover will disappear completely, due to the increase in agricultural production and the drainage of land. The destruction of wild forms of Trifolium pratense L. will lead to the loss of a number of genes, which in the future may appear indispensable in cultuvating and utilizing red clover.

MATERIALS AND MERHODS

The material used in the experiment was made up of wild red clover specimens Trifolium pratense L. var. spontaneum Willk. collected in natural meadows and pastures in the districts of Olsztyn, Warszawa, Białystok, Kraków, Rzeszów, Kielce as well as of cultivated tetraploids obtained from selected ecotypes.

The number of flowers and inflorescences on the plant and on a given area unit was determined, and the degree of seed setting and amount of seed yield defined. Biometric measurements of inflorescence were made and its nectaring was defined by Jabłońsky’s method. Jabłoński. 1965. The selffertilization of dyploid and tetraploid forms was examined.

RESULTS

The populations of Trifolium pratense L. var. examined differed considerably in the duration of the florescence period and the time of its occurence. A large number of ecotypes started to bloom as early as 50 days after spronting. Their bloom was abundant, usually in the first half of the florescence stage. After yielding seed, they died down, no rosette of leaves, characteristic of the clover however, was found. From the point of view of farming production these plants appear to have no practical value since they are, as a rule short and poorly leaved. When cut during the budding stage or at the beginning of the flowering period they died down or grew very weakly.

The last to bloom was winter clover, which did not undergo the florescence stage in the year of sowing. This form constituted only, a small part of the clover population; it could be found most abunalantly in the material collected in Białystok Region (Serwy: 8,2%, Rogale: 5,1%) and in the Mountains (Szczawnica).

strona 191

Table 1 Percentage of one year and winter plants in populations

populations grown in District one year plants (%) winter plants (%) Quantity of plants examined
Szczawnica Kraków — 6,7 105
Rytro Kraków 2,0 5,0 102
Staszów Kielce 5,8 — 104
Tłuszcz Warszawa 11,2 1,0 204
Chrzęsne Warszawa 8,9 — 124
Jaroty Olsztyn 3,3 — 186
Wadąg Olsztyn 2,7 2,1 188
Rogale Białystok 1,6 5,5 180
Serwy Białystok — 8,2 183
  • winter plants not flowering in the year of their sowing.

STRUCTURE OF FLOWERS. NECTARING.

The flowers of wild clover do not differ substantially in their morphological structure from the flowers of the cultivated vanieties. Their colour and size on the other hand, can vary flower to flower. In the whole population of ecotypes a wide spectrum of colours, ranging from fine white to dark bluish carmine, can be observed.

The main purpose of the experiment was to determine the size of the corolla, which in the red, both dyploid and polyploid clover, has an important influence on flower pollination by honeybees.

The length of the flower tubes of meadow clover ran in particular varieties, from 4,3 do 9,1 mm, that of the Gloria from 6,4 to 10,8 mm; the average length of Gloria tubes being 8,8 mm. The flowers of colchiploids (C2 and C3) obtained from the ecotypes were longer and wider than those of the primary forms. Those flowers (5,8—11,8 mm) were similar in proportions to the flowers of the Gloria but their size was always smaller than the tetraploid variety Wielkolistna (6,6—11,9 mm) (table 2).

The width of the flower tube may also play an important role during pollination by honey-bees. If the tube is wide enough, a bee can introduce not only its sucking-licking mouth parts into it but also the front part of its wedge-shaped head, which makes it possible for the insect to reach a drop of nectar placed deep inside the tube. A thin tube, on the other hand, anables a bee to introduce only the thinner part its licking-sucking mouth parts, which means the shortening of its „working length”.

Meadow ecotypes of clover varied markedly from cultivated forms

strona 192

Table 2 Flower tube lengths and nectar height

population flower tube: length (mm) flower tube: diameter (mm) nectar height (mm)
Tłuszcz 2× 7,93 1,62 1,14
Wadąg 2× 8,61 1,74 1,18
Serwy 2× 8,20 1,68 1,27
Gloria 2× 8,82 1,88 1,32
x̄ — 2× 8,39 1,73 1,23
Tłuszcz 4× 8,98 1,86 1,56
Wadąg 4× 9,12 1,92 1,62
Serwy 4× 9,43 2,03 1,60
Wielkolistana 4× 9,84 2,24 1,64
x̄ — 4× 9,34 2,01 1,60
The least difference recorded (0,05) 0,32 0,18 0,22

in respect of the diamexter of the flower tube. The tubes of the former were about 12,4% and 25% thinner than those of the Gloria and the Wielkolistna variety respectively.

After polyploidization in the generation C2 the diameter reached, on average 1,97 mm. It was greater, then, by 17,2% than the width of the tubes of the primary forms, and by 4,8% than the diameter of the Gloria (Table 2).

The height of the nectar level in the flowers of the ecotypes was generally less than that of the Gloria, and reached 1,19 mm (in the Gloria: 1,32 mm). Polyploidic forms of clover produced more nectar: the height of the nectar level reached 1,59 mm in colichiploid meadow clover and 1,64 mm in the variety Wielkolistna (table 2)

The inflorescence of meadow clover ecotypes do es not differ substantially in structure from the inflorescence of cultivated clover: it is, as a rule, smaller, which is due to the fact that its flower tubes are shorter (table 2). As regards the number of flowers in the inflorescence unicultivated forms differ markedly from cultivated ones. The number of flowers per head in the ecotypes ranged from 37 to 154 whereas in the standard specimen, Gloria, it ran from 63 to 138. Comparing the figures given in the tables 1—3, it can be observed that the number of flowers per head was bigger in populations blooming earlier.

The number of flowers per head in tetraploid populations (C2 and C3) was smaller than that found in the primary forms. In this case it was difficult to observe a regularity since considerable divergences

strona 193

between the different families of the same population were found. For instance, some tetraploid families obtained from the population growing in Wadog had a substantial number of flowers per head (127,3) whereas others of the same origin had 76,22 or 86,3 flowers. A similar variation in this feature was observed in tetraploids obtained from populations growing in Tłuszcz and Serwy. The average number of flowers for all tetraploid families reached 99,1 and was smaller than that found in primary dyploid forms (106,6) and in the variety Wielkolistna (104,2) (table 3).

In the majority of clover forms examined a decreasing number of flowers in the inflorescence in the second half of the flowering period was observed. All polyploids lowever, behaved a bit differently; it was observed that the drop in the number of flowers in later heads was slower. Presumably this was due to the fact that the primary polyploid forms were prior to the actual polyploids. By comparing the number of flowers per influorescence with the number of flowers on the plants, a negative correlation of these features was obtained (r = —0,31). Plants with a small number of flowers per head appeared to have more inflorescences. This could be easily observed, especially while comparing, thin-stemmed ecotypes, spreading abundantly, with the Wielkolistna variety characterized by having relatively fewer stems.

The number of flowers on a plot (definite unit) of clover sown in

Table 3 Number of flowers and seeds per head

population Ploidalality Number of flowers seed setting (%) Number of seeds
Tłuszcz 2× 108,2 62,3 67,4
Tłuszcz 4× (C3) 102,9 34,3 35,3
Chrzęsne 2× 123,8 72,7 90,0
Jaroty 2× 111,1 68,7 76,3
Wadąg 2× 120,4 53,1 64,0
Wadąg 4× (C3) 111,1 39,2 43,6
Bartoszyce 2× 95,1 66,3 63,1
Gierłoż 2× 94,3 59,3 55,9
Rogale 2× 100,3 71,9 71,8
Serwy 2× 91,0 66,3 60,3
Serwy 4× (C2) 83,2 35,1 29,2
Gloria * 2× 98,8 61,6 61,9
Wielkolistna * 4× 104,2 27,0 28,1
The least difference recorded — (0,05) 14,7 9,1 11,2
  • — cultivated varietes
strona 194

Table 4 Coefficient of correlation between clover features conditioning seed setting in ecotypes of meadow clover

features examined Number of flowers per head Number of heads per plant Number of stems per plant
Number of heads —0,31
Number of stems +0,07 +0,82 **
Number of heads per 1 m2 —0,14 +0,63 * +0,47 *
  • — important, given P = 0,05 ** — important, given P = 0,01

drills was largely conditioned by the degree of spreading of a particular population. In this case a positive correlation (r = +0,4*) (table 4) was observed.

SEED SETTING THROUGH SELFPOLLINATION AND OUT-POLLINATION

The average percentage of plants setting seeds under the insulator in the population of wild meadow clover was visibly lower than that in the standard variety „Gloria”. Meadow tetraploids, as a rule, set seeds belter under self-pollination than primary forms (table 5).

The Inbreeding to the level S1 and S2 usually caused a decrease in the number of seeds per head. A comparison of the dropin seed setting under self-pollination of the dyploid and tetraploid populations, showed that these latter were affected by inbreeding to a smaller degree: the generation S2 set on the average, 5,3 seeds per head, which made of 53%

Table 5 Self fertility of three ecotype generations and their tetraploids

Population Poliploidization Percentage of plants S0: selffertile Percentage of plants S0: Non selffertile Number of seeds per head in selfpollinating plants: S0 Number of seeds per head in selfpollinating plants: S1 Number of seeds per head in selfpollinating plants: S2
Meadowecotypes 2× 18,3 81,7 3,4 2,3 1,1
Ecotypes of the Kolchiploids 4× 43,0 57,0 10,0 7,2 5,3
„Gloria” 2× 31,7 68,3 4,4 — —
„Wielkolistna” 4× 55,0 45,0 6,7 — —
strona 195

Table 6 Seed weight per area unit

Varieties Quantity of seed (kg): 1967 Olsztyn Quantity of seed (kg): 1968 Olsztyn Quantity of seed (kg): 1970 Skrzeszowice Quantity of seed (kg): 1971 Skrzeszowice
Łąkowa 427 2× 3,28 1,74 2,82 1,07
Gloria 2× 2,63 1,31 — —
Łąkowa 402 4× 1,90 0,80 2,02 0,68
Wielkolistna 4× 1,12 0,53 — —
Mieszaniec (R-72) * 4× 1,62 0,91 1,74 0,63
The least difference recorded (0,05) 0,23 0,14 0,23 0,28
  • hybrid (R-27): meadow variety × „Wielkolistna”.

of the seed setting in So. In dyploids, on the other hand, the average fertility of the generation S2 dropped to 32% (table 5).

Among the meadow clover ecotypes examined many forms with good seed setting ability under free pollination were found. The aforementioned feature varied markedly from population to population. Beside the seminiferous individuals setting seeds in over 80% of flowers forms were found in which the number of seeds per head was not higher than in that tetraploid variety „Wielkolistna”. However seed setting was better in them than in the cultivated clover.

The polyploidization of meadow clover caused as was the case with other species, a dominution of fertility but in each case the degres of seed setting per 100 flowers was higher in this species than in the standard variety „Wielkolistna”. Meadow colchiploids set, on average, from 34,3 to 39,2% seeds, whereas the control „Wielkolistna” set only 27% seeds. The seed yield obtained from o plot of ground (defined unit of ground) was from 25% to 32% higher in the population of wild meadow clover than in the variety „Gloria” (table 6). Likewise, colchiploids of meadow clover yielded about a 50% higher seeds crop than the variety „Wielkolistna”.

CONCLUSIONS

  1. Wild ecotypes of Trifolium pratense L. var. spontanum Willk. found in Poland in natural surroundings display a great variation in physiological and morphological features. Forms blooming earlier and species of the procumbent type, which have a negligeable forming value constitute a great propartion of clover populations.
strona 196
  1. The great majority of ecotypes bloom more abundantly than cultivated species. Their flower tubes are shorter, and their nectar more easily accessible to pollinators. They yield more seed than the cultivated varieties.
  1. Wild meadow clover and its off-shoots show a smaller selffertilizing capacity than cultivated clover.
  1. Tetraploids obtained from meadow clover show gigantism and mutability of other morphological and anatomical features, very much like cultivated clover colichiploids. Their flowers, however are smaller in size; they set seeds better than the tetraploid variety „Wielkolistna”.

Summary

The paper presented some observations made on ecotypes of Trifolium pratense L. var. spontaneum Willk from various regions of Poland and on tetraploids obtained from them. It was observed that wild clover shows great variation in physiological and morphological features. Its flowers are smaller in size and its nectar is more easily accessible pollinator insects. This clover sets seeds more easily both on the dyploid and tetraploid levels, than the cultivated varieties of Trifolium pratense L. var. sativum Schreb. Its farming value then is high.

LITERATURE

Jabłoński B. (1965) — Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe 4, 81—92.

Jànossy A. (1966) — Agrobotanika 7, 11—19.

Julèn G. (1956) — 7-th Intern. Grassl. Congress, New Zealand, 471—478.

Łączyńska-Hulewicz T. (1957) — Roczniki Nauk Rolniczych, 75—A—3 291—338.

Nuesch B. (1960) — Landw. Jahrbuch der Schweiz. 4, 301—407.

Polàk J. (1974) — Acta F.R.N. Univ. Comen., Genetica, 5, 149—162.

EKOTYPY TRIFOLIUM PRATENSE L.

S. Góral, IHAR, Polska

Streszczenie

Badano ekotypy Trifolium pratense L. var spontaneum Willk. z różnych rejonów Polski oraz wyhodowane z nich tetraploidy. Stwierdzono, że dzikie koniczyny mają dużą zmienność cech morfologicznych i fizjologicznych. Kwitną obficiej i lepiej wiążą nasiona niż formy siewne. Ich kwiaty są mniejsze, a nektar łatwiej dostępny dla zapylaczy. Koniczyny te lepiej wiążą nasiona niż formy siewne Trifolium pratense L. var sativum Schreb., zarówno na poziomie di- jak i tetraploidalnym. Mają więc dużą wartość hodowlaną.


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 190: „ecvironments” → environments
  • s. 190: „cultuvating” → cultivating
  • s. 190: „MATERIALS AND MERHODS” → MATERIALS AND METHODS
  • s. 190: „Jabłońsky’s” → Jabłoński’s
  • s. 190: „occurence” → occurrence
  • s. 190: „spronting” → sprouting
  • s. 190: „abunalantly” → abundantly
  • s. 191: „vanieties” → varieties
  • s. 191: „from 4,3 do 9,1 mm” → from 4,3 to 9,1 mm
  • s. 191: „anables” → enables
  • s. 192, tab. 2: „Wielkolistana” → Wielkolistna
  • s. 192: „diamexter” → diameter
  • s. 192: „colichiploid meadow” → colchiploid meadow
  • s. 192: „do es not” → does not
  • s. 192: „unicultivated” → uncultivated
  • s. 193: „Wadog” → Wadąg
  • s. 193: „lowever” → however
  • s. 193: „influorescence” → inflorescence
  • s. 193, tab. 3: „Ploidalality” → Ploidality
  • s. 193, tab. 3: „cultivated varietes” → cultivated varieties
  • s. 194: „seeds belter” → seeds better
  • s. 194: „dropin” → drop in
  • s. 194, tab. 5: „Poliploidization” → Polyploidization
  • s. 194, tab. 5: „Meadowecotypes” → Meadow ecotypes
  • s. 194, tab. 5: „Kolchiploids” → Colchiploids
  • s. 195: „in So.” → in S0.
  • s. 195: „dominution” → diminution
  • s. 195: „the degres” → the degree
  • s. 195: „from o plot” → from a plot
  • s. 195: „spontanum” → spontaneum
  • s. 195: „negligeable” → negligible
  • s. 195: „propartion” → proportion
  • s. 196: „colichiploids” → colchiploids

Podobne wpisy