DOES HONEY BEE (APIS MELLIFERA) SWARMING BEHAVIOUR PROTECT THE COLONY FROM SOCIAL PARASITES ?
tekst: Adam Tofilski, Jan Kozłowski, Michał Woyciechowski
Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XXXIX, 1995 — Adam Tofilski, Jan Kozłowski, Michał Woyciechowski
strona 31PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XXXIX, Nr 1 1995
Adam Tofilski, Jan Kozłowski*, Michał Woyciechowski
Bee Research Department, Agricultural University Al. 29 Listopada 52, 31-425 Kraków, POLAND
- Institute of Environmental Biology, Jagiellonian University ul. Ingardena 6, 30-060 Kraków, POLAND
Summary
The swarming of a honey bee colony creates a high risk of queenlessness when only one virgin queen remains in the original colony, and, often, in the swarm. A hypothesis has been tested whether bees avoid the presence of two or more queens in the colony during swarming, which could protect it from the intrusion of a foreign queen functioning as a social parasite. Two experiments have been carried out to check whether the number of young, virgin queens in a colony determines the acceptance of a foreign one, a potential parasite. The results have not confirmed the hypothesis as the acceptance of a foreign queen did not depend upon the number of native ones.
Keywords: Apis mellifera, swarming, social parasitism, honey bee.
INTRODUCTION
In eusocial Hymenoptera, young queens are usually reared in the presence of a mother queen. The species of the Apis genus are an exception to this rule. During honey bee (Apis mellifera) swarming, an old queen departs from a colony, in which unemerged queens remain in queencells. The later afterswarms of the same colony will contain young, virgin queens. This behaviour induces a high risk of queenlessness (Woyciechowski 1989). It is quite possible that young queens might die in their queen cells. Also, after the swarming, only one virgin remains in the original colony and she might not mate in prolonged bad weather. Furthermore, even if young queens do begin mating, up to 20% of them might die in its course (Seeley 1978). A colony deprived of the last, young queen will die, as the colony has at that time no eggs or young larvae, from which new queens could be reared. Another harmful factor associated with the swarming is the about one-month interval, during which there is no laying queen in the original colony. This limits the potential growth of the colony, thus decreasing its reproductive success. Taking into account the low survival of colonies founded from swarms (24%) relative to that of at least one-year old colonies (45-78%) (Seeley 1978,
strona 32Winston 1987), it is to be expected that an old queen would remain in the original colony and the young ones will depart with the swarms. This results from the fact that workers achieve a higher fitness by helping to rear offspring of their mother, and not sister, queens. Workers are about 1.8 times closer related to the mother’s offspring than to that of a sister (Seeley 1985). If an old queen did not leave her original colony and continued to lay eggs, and young, mated queens departed with the swarms, the colony could produce more swarms. Such kind of swarming occurs in stingless bees (Wilson 1971). If swarming presently observed in the honey bee has not been eliminated through natural selection, one should expect it to yield benefits compensating for the costs.
Social parasitism is one of the major risks for a eusocial insect colony. It consists in adopting queens of their own or foreign species by the colonies. Parasitic females avoid then the costs connected with founding their own colony. Such parasitism occurs in many species of bees, wasps and ants (Wilson 1971, Heinrich 1979).
The present study aimed at an experimental confirmation of the hypothesis that social parasitism has played an important part in the evolution of the honey bee swarming behaviour. This is why bees avoid having two or more adult queens in a colony. According to our hypothesis, the presence of more than one queen might make it more difficult for the workers to recognize a foreign queen, which could enter the colony as a social parasite. Two independent experiments checked whether workers recognize a foreign, potentially parasitic queen in the presence of many of their sister queens.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The experiments were carried out in the vicinity of Kraków, Poland, on Apis mellifera carnica. In the first experiment, 24 colonies were dequeened and divided into 4 groups. One, two, three and four virgin queens were reared into each of the colonies of group 1, 2, 3, and 4, respectively. The number of hives in each group was unequal due to unexpected queen mortality during rearing. Queens were in each case sisters of workers from a given colony. They were kept in small cages made of queen excluder, thus preventing queen fights. Two days later, a foreign virgin queen was introduced into each colony also in a small cage. Mortality of those queens was assessed the following day.
In the second experiment, 7 colonies were dequeened; each was divided into two equal parts, thus creating two genetically-identical groups. One virgin queen was introduced into each of group 1 colonies; six of them were introduced into each of the colonies of group 2. The queens were sisters of workers from each of the colony. However, queens could move freely around the nest in this experiment. Mortal fights between queens were prevented by cutting the extremities of their stings and accustoming them to each other for
strona 33two days in small cages, where they could contact only head to head. Three days after freeing the native queens, a foreign virgin queen was introduced into all colonies through the hive entrances. These queens, unlike those of the colony, had stings. Queen mortality was assessed on the next day by searching for dead individuals removed from the hive or by searching the whole nest. Foreign queens could be distinguished from native ones thanks to individual markings.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In the first experiment, the differences in foreign queen mortality between the groups with one, two, three and four queens in each colony (Tab. 1) were not significant statistically (R × C test of independence using G-test; G = 0.63; 0.9 > P > 0.8; Sokal and Rohlf 1981). In the second experiment, foreign queen mortality was identical in both groups (Tab 1.). It is interesting to note that acceptance of foreign queen was high in both experiments even in colonies with only one native queen. The result obtained is contrary to expectations, as higher mortality of foreign queen was not found in colonies with one native queen, as compared to those with two or more queens.
Table 1 The number of foreign queens dead or alive after introduction into colonies with different numbers of native queens Liczba obcych matek, które przeżyły lub zostały zabite na dzień po ich wprowadzeniu do rodzin o różnej liczbie matek własnych
| Experiment / Doświadczenie | Number of native queens / Liczba matek własnych | Number of foreign queens / Liczba obcych matek: alive / żywych | Number of foreign queens / Liczba obcych matek: dead / martwych |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | 1 | 5 | 3 |
| 2 | 3 | 1 | |
| 3 | 4 | 2 | |
| 4 | 3 | 3 | |
| II | 1 | 4 | 3 |
| 6 | 4 | 3 |
The only hypothesis on honey bee swarming behaviour has been so far presented by Ribbands (1953). According to it, the presently observed
strona 34colony division has evolved through a change in absconding behaviour: it could happen that a part of an absconding colony remained in its original nest with brood, thus giving rise to a new colony. However, the absconding presently observed in African races never results in swarming, thus contradicting Ribbands’ hypothesis (Kerr and Laidlaw 1956). The hypothesis presented in this paper explains honey bee swarming behaviour as acquired through an adaptation protecting the colony from social parasite intrusion. According to the hypothesis, the colony prevents the presence of two or more queens at the same time – in which case the workers could lose the ability to recognize foreign queens, a potential social parasite. As it has not been shown that the probability of accepting a foreign queen depends on the number of queens already present in a colony, the results of the experiments presented here do not confirm the hypothesis.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank J. Woyke for helpful comments on earlier drafts. The paper was supported by the Committee for Scientific Research grant KBN 4-1609-91-01.
REFERENCES
Heinrich B. (1979) – Bumblebee economics. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard Univ. Press.
Kerr W. E., Laidlaw H. H. (1956) – General genetics of bees. Advances in genetics 8:109-153.
Ribbands C. R. (1953) – The behaviour and social life of honeybees. London, Bee Res. Assn. Ltd.
Seeley T. D. (1978) – Life history strategy of the honey bee, Apis mellifera. Oecologia 32:109-118.
Seeley T. D. (1985) – Honeybee ecology. Princeton, Princeton Univ. Press.
Sokal R. S., Rohlf F. J. (1981) – Biometry. New York, Freeman and Company.
Wilson E. O. (1971) – The insect societies. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard Univ. Press.
Winston M. L. (1987) – The biology of the honey bee. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard Univ. Press.
Woyciechowski M. (1989) – Ewolucja zachowań społecznych błonkówek. Kosmos 38:429-452.
strona 35CZY RÓJKA PSZCZOŁY MIODNEJ (APIS MELLIFERA) ZABEZPIECZA KOLONIĘ PRZED PASOŻYTNICTWEM SPOŁECZNYM ?
A. Tofilski, J. Kozłowski, M. Woyciechowski
Streszczenie
W gniazdach eusocjalnych Hymenoptera jest regułą, że młode królowe (matki) są wychowywane w obecności starej królowej. Wyjątkiem pod tym względem są gatunki z rodzaju Apis. U pszczoły miodnej (A. mellifera) stara matka opuszcza z rojem gniazdo zanim wylęgnie się pierwsza młoda matka. Taki sposób rójki wydaje się ewolucyjnie nieuzasadniony, gdyż stwarza duże ryzyko osierocenia rodziny. Weryfikowano hipotezę, zgodnie z którą rodzina unika w czasie rójki obecności w gnieździe dwu lub większej liczby dorosłych matek, co mogłoby utrudniać robotnicom rozpoznanie obcej matki funkcjonującej jako pasożyt społeczny. Przeprowadzono dwa doświadczenia w których sprawdzano, czy liczba młodych nieunasienionych matek pszczelich w gnieździe ma wpływ na przyjmowanie obcej matki – potencjalnego pasożyta. Uzyskane wyniki nie potwierdziły testowanej hipotezy, ponieważ nie stwierdzono, aby akceptacja obcej matki zależała od liczby dziewiczych matek przebywających w gnieździe.
Słowa kluczowe: Apis mellifera, rójka, pasożytnictwo społeczne, pszczoła miodna.
Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji
- s. 34, piśmiennictwo: „Sokal R. S.” → Sokal R. R.
