CHARACTERIZATION OF ROBBER BEES

tekst: Janina Muszyńska

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XXXVII, 1993 — Janina Muszyńska

strona 3

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XXXVII 1993

Janina Muszyńska

Research Institute of Pomology and Floriculture, Bee Division, Kazimierska 2, 24-100 Puławy

Summary

The aim of the study was to find traits that distingush the body of worker bees which enter alien nests to get food from that of other flying bees.

The study was conducted in the apiary of the Research Institute of Pomology and Floriculture, Bee Division in Puławy from the beginning of July trought September over the years 1987-1990.

Robber bees were compared with other flying bees i.e.: a) scouts, b) pollen gatherers returning from flowers, c) bees from the powder sugar feeder, d) bees from the syrup feeder, e) bees staying at the last honey comb.

The results obtained point to a similarity between robbers and scouts. The simillarity lies in their physiological condition in their honey sacs being completely empty.

The condition of the rectum of robbing bees suggests that they may be affected by a disease. It is probable that the acquisition of food trought robbing is the only chance of survival for those individuals which may be unable to make extended foraging flights.

Keywords: robber bees, bee physiology.

INTRODUCTION

At the time of foraging breaks during the productive season some worker bees are known to invade alien nests. Such bees, their appearance and behaviour have been repeatedly described (Free 1954, Delaplane 1991). However, no attempt has been made to characterize their physiological state and general condition. No account has been given of the traits that distinguish those bees from other flying bees. However, such information may prove to be very useful since robbing events are always preceded by the appearance in the apiary of a certain small number of bees that look and behave in a peculiar way. They are robber bees. A comprehensive characterization of those individuals should contribute to more efficient prevention of robbing in the apiary and once robbing has already started may facilitate its discontinuation.

The aim of this study was to find traits that distinguish bees that enter alien nests in order to acquire food from other flying bees.

strona 4

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The investigations were conducted in the years 1987 – 1990 from the beginning of July to the end of September in the apiary run by the Bee Division of the Pomology and Floriculture Institute at Puławy.

Robber bees were compared to the following flying bees: a) scout bees, b) pollen gatherers returning from foraging trips, c) bees staying in feeders with sugar powder, d) bees staying in feeders with syrup, e) bees staying in the outermost comb with a store. As was proved earlier (Muszyńska et al. 1975) the latter group of worker bees is the most characteristic of the average worker bee in a given bee colony.

Those bees that were making attempts to get into the hive otherwise that through the entrance early in the morning before the peak flights were assumed to be robbers. As scouts were recognized those bees which flew in the apiary laboratory during the preparation of syrup when no robberies were observed.

The following traits were compared: a) fresh body weight (after the digestive tracts have been removed). The trait is a good indicator of workers’ condition (Szczepański et al. 1975), b) the fresh weight of digestive tracts, c) the extent to which the honey sac and the rectum were filled, d) the pH of the content of bee rectum which bears relationship to the living conditions of the worker bee (Muszyńska, Leźnicka 1992), e) the condition of the pharyngeal glands and the fat body which are good indicators of bee physiological state and are not related to the condition of worker bees (Szczepański et al. 1975).

Fresh body weight and fresh digestive tract weight were measured in the same individuals. The appearance of the digestive tracts and the degree of the filling of the honey sac and the rectum were rated descriptively. The pH of the rectum was measured using the method described earlier (Muszyńska, Leźnicka 1992). The pharyngeal glands and the fat bodies were rated on a five-grade scale (Muszyńska et al. 1975).

A total of 15000 individuals were examined. Robber bees and scouts were collected as they made their appearance in the apiary. As the productive season was advancing the worker bees belonging to the remaining groups were sampled simultaneously from several colonies and freezed (Harbo 1983). They were hybrids of the Apis mellifera carnica.

The data were analyzed statistically and subjected to Duncan’s test at α = 0,05.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Fresh body weight. Robber bees were found to be characterized by low fresh body weight comparable only to the fresh weight of scout bees (Table 1).

strona 5

Therefore, the bees from both the groups were in a condition that was inferior to that found in the remaining groups. It is remarkable that there was a relatively small variation among the bees within each group under comparison as the value of the variation coefficient (V%) usually did not exceed 15 (Table 1).

Table 1 Average fresh digestive tract weight of worker bees from compared groups (mg/bee) Świeża masa tkanek pszczół robotnic z porównywanych grup (mg/pszczołę)

Group of bees Grupa pszczół No. of bees Liczba powtórzeń Average of fresh body weight Średnia świeża masa From – to Przedział V%
robber bees – pszczoły rabujące 62 65,4 a 54,0 – 77,6 14,2
scout bees – pszczoły zwiadowczynie 37 64,8 a 54,5 – 77,9 14,4
pollen gatherers – zbieraczki pyłku 27 70,4 b 57,4 – 101,5 13,2
bees from sugar powder – pszczoły z cukru pudru 47 75,9 c 62,0 – 107,9 12,3
bees from sugar syrup – pszczoły z syropu 42 79,8 d 69,8 – 108,0 11,7
bees from last comb – pszczoły z ostatniego plastra 42 80,4 d 59,0 – 109,0 11,6

Fresh body weight and the condition of digestive tracts. Robber bees like the scout bees were characterized by a low fresh weight of digestive tracts (Table 2). One of the factors behind this observation may be the differences that occur between robber bees and worker bees from the remaining groups in the extent of filling of the honey sac. The honey sac of robber bees and scout bees was always empty at the time of their capture whereas it was always filled, though to a varying extent, in the worker bees from the remaining groups. Even the pollen gatherers returning to the nest did not have an empty honey sac. It can be supposed that both robber bees and scout bees are kept away from the stores in the nest by their fellow worker bees. Drum and Rothenbuhler (1984 and 1985) and also Levcenko and Moskalenko (1985), Evers and Seeley (1986) indicated that some bees were discriminated against by other bees from the same nest. It should be stressed that within each group there was also a substantial variation among bees for

strona 6

their digestive tract weight (Table 2). It was not only the result of the differences in the extent of filling of the honey sac but was also due to sharp differences in the extent to which the rectum was filled. It is noteworthy that the rectum of robber bees was dark and brittle something that was not found in the workers from the remaining groups.

Table 2 Average fresh digestive tract weight of worker bees from compared groups (mg/bee) Świeża masa przewodów pokarmowych pszczół robotnic należących do porównywanych grup (mg/pszczołę)

Group of bees Grupa pszczół No. of bees Liczba powtórzeń Average of fresh body weight Średnia świeża masa From – to Przedział V%
robber bees – pszczoły rabujące 62 14,6 a 4,3 – 26,9 56,9
scout bees – pszczoły zwiadowczynie 37 15,8 a 4,0 – 27,5 52,6
pollen gatherers – zbieraczki pyłku 27 18,9 ab 8,6 – 32,0 43,8
bees from sugar powder – pszczoły z cukru pudru 47 22,3 b 14,0 – 49,3 37,2
bees from sugar syrup – pszczoły z syropu 42 28,5 c 10,5 – 45,5 29,2
bees from last comb – pszczoły z ostatniego plastra 48 29,0 c 9,1 – 60,0 54,7

The pH of the rectum content in robber bees. The study showed that an average acidity (pH) of the rectum of robber bees generally corresponded to that characterizing bees of the active season that are capable of making cleansing flights (Muszyńska, Leźnicka 1992). In addition, statistical analysis revealed that the pH of the rectum of robber bees was not significantly different from that found in bees staying at the outermost comb with stores (Table 3).

The condition of the pharyngeal glands and the fat body in robber bees. No significant differences were found between the degree of development of the pharyngeal glands and the fat body among worker bees that belonged to the five groups of bees listed in the method part under items (a) to (c). Both organs in those bees were atrophied which is typical of bees older than 20 days during the season (Konopacka et al. 1975).

strona 7

Table 3 Average values of the pH rectum bees from compared groups Odczyn (pH) treści jelita prostego pszczół robotnic należących do porównywanych grup

Group of bees Grupa pszczół No. of bees Liczba powtórzeń Average pH Średnia wartość pH From – to Przedział V%
robber bees – pszczoły rabujące 63 5,5 b 4,4 – 8,0 14,8
scout bees – pszczoły zwiadowczynie 60 5,8 c 4,5 – 8,5 14,2
pollen gatherers – zbieraczki pyłku – – – –
bees from sugar powder – pszczoły z cukru pudru 254 5,0 a 3,5 – 7,5 16,5
bees from last comb – pszczoły z ostatniego plastra 246 4,4 b 4,4 – 8,0 15,8

Bees collected from the outermost storage comb were demonstrated to have better developed pharyngeal glands than the worker bees from the remaining groups. The difference seems to be attributable to the fact that at the outermost comb, along with flying bees, there are also young individuals characterized by strong development of pharyngeal glands.

CONCLUSIONS

The results give evidence that there is a similarity between robber bees and scout bees. What makes them similar is their condition and the fact that individuals from both groups have empty honey sacs. It suggests that both groups may be made up of bees which for some reason had a difficulty in accessing the food in the nest. As a result, they failed to ingest food in their honey sacs before leaving the nest.

The condition of the rectum in robber bees makes them distinct from the scout bees and allows to suspect them to be diseased individuals. However, a separate study is required to verify this hypothesis.

It is plausible that the acquisition of food through robbing is the only chance to get food by the individuals which because of the total lack of food in the honey sac are unable to make more distant foraging flights.

strona 8

REFERENCES

Delaplane K. (1991): Robbing. Am.Bee J. 131(8):487-488.

Drum N.H., Rothenbuhler W.C. (1984): Effect of temperature on non-stinging aggressive responses of worker honeybees to diseased and healthy bees. J.Apic.Res. 23(2):82-87.

Drum N.H., Rothenbuhler W.C. (1985): Differences in non-stinging aggressive responses of worker honeybees to diseased and healthy bees in May and July. J.Apic.Res. 24(3):184-187.

Evers C.A., Seely T.D. (1986): Kin discrimination and aggression in honey bee colonies with laying workers. Anim.Behav. 34:224-225.

Free J.B. (1954): The behaviour of robber honeybees. Behaviour 7(2-3):233-240.

Harbo J. (1983): Effect of population size on worker survival and honey loss in broodless colonies of honey bees Apis mellifera. Env.Ent. 12(5):1559-1563.

Konopacka Z., Muszyńska J., Szczepański K. (1975): Ocena przydatności niektórych cech fizyko-chemicznych i anatomicznych dla charakterystyki kondycji robotnic pszczoły miodnej. Pszczeln.Zesz.Nauk. 19:65-73.

Levcenko J.A., Moskalenko P.G. (1985): Markirovka mołodych pceł vzrosłymi. Pčelovodstvo 4:7-8.

Muszyńska J., Szczepański K., Konopacka Z. (1975): Przydatność prób z różnych części gniazda dla charakterystyki rodziny pszczelej w okresie letnim. Pszczeln.Zesz.Nauk. 19:53-64.

Muszyńska J., Leźnicka B. (1992): Acidity of the rectum content in worker bees. Pszczeln.Zesz.Nauk. 36:109-114.

Szczepański K., Konopacka Z., Muszyńska J. (1975): Ocena związku między niektórymi cechami służącymi do charakteryzowania kondycji i stanu fizjologicznego pszczół robotnic. Pszczeln.Zesz.Nauk. 19:65-73.

CHARAKTERYSTYKA PSZCZÓŁ RABUJĄCYCH

Janina Muszyńska

Streszczenie

Badania prowadzono w latach 1987-1990 w okresie od początku lipca do końca września w pasiece Oddziału Pszczelnictwa ISK w Puławach.

Pszczoły rabujące porównano z następującymi pszczołami lotnymi: zwiadowczynie, zbieraczki pyłku powracające z pożytku, pszczoły z podkarmiaczki z cukrem pudrem, pszczoły z podkarmiaczki z syropem, pszczoły przebywające na skrajnym plastrze z zapasem. Za rabujące uznano te, które w godzinach porannych, przed nasileniem głównych lotów, usiłowały się dostać do ula inaczej niż przez wylotek. Zwiadowczyniami nazwano te, które dostawały się do pracowni pasiecznej w czasie przygotowywania syropu, w okresie gdy w pasiece nie obserwowano rabunków.

Porównanie dotyczyło następujących cech: świeżej masy ciała pszczół po usunięciu przewodów pokarmowych, świeżej masy przewodów pokarmowych, stopnia wypełnienia wola miodowego i jelita prostego, oceny odczynu treści jelita prostego oraz stanu gruczołów gardzielowych i ciała tłuszczowego pszczół. Świeżą masę ciała robotnic i przewodów pokarmowych określano wagowo u tych samych pojedynczych osobników. Wygląd przewodów pokarmowych oraz stopień wypełnienia wola miodowego i jelita prostego oceniano metodą

strona 9

opisową. Odczyn treści jelita prostego pszczół oznaczano w sposób opisany wcześniej (Muszyńska, Leźnicka 1992). Gruczoły gardzielowe i ciało tłuszczowe oceniano metodą bonitacyjną, stosując skalę pięciostopniową (Muszyńska i wsp. 1975). Ogółem badaniami objęto 1500 osobników. Pszczoły rabujące i zwiadowczynie pobierano w miarę jak pojawiały się w pasiece. Robotnice z pozostałych grup pobierano z kilku rodzin równocześnie, sukcesywnie w ciągu całego okresu badań. Były to mieszańce pszczoły kraińskiej.

Uzyskane wyniki świadczą o istnieniu podobieństwa między pszczołami rabującymi a zwiadowczyniami. Upodabnia je kondycja oraz fakt, że osobniki z tych grup mają wole całkowicie puste. Sugeruje to, że do obu grup należą pszczoły, które miały jakieś trudności z dostępem do pokarmu w gnieździe. Stan jelita prostego pszczół rabujących wyróżnia je natomiast od wszystkich pozostałych robotnic i pozwala zakładać, że są to osobniki chore. Można przypuszczać, że zdobywanie pokarmu w drodze rabowania obcych gniazd stanowi jedyną szansę zdobycia pokarmu przez te osobniki, gdyż nie są one zdolne do odbywania bardziej odległych lotów zbieraczych.

Słowa kluczowe: pszczoły rabujące, fizjologia pszczół.


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 3, streszczenie: „distingush” → distinguish
  • s. 3, streszczenie, 2×: „trought” → through
  • s. 3, streszczenie: „simillarity” → similarity
  • s. 4: „otherwise that through” → otherwise than through
  • s. 8, piśmiennictwo: „Seely T.D.” → Seeley T.D.

Podobne wpisy