FURTHER RESEARCH ON HONEYBEE BREEDING WITH SHORT POST-CAPPING PERIODS

tekst: Maciej Siuda, Jerzy Wilde, Nikolaus Koeniger

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XL, 1996 — Maciej Siuda, Jerzy Wilde, Nikolaus Koeniger

strona 135

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XL, Nr 2 1996

Maciej Siuda, Jerzy Wilde, Nikolaus Koeniger*

Apiculture Department, University of Agriculture and Technology in Olsztyn, ul. Oczapowskiego 5, 10-957 Olsztyn, POLAND, e-mail: jurwild@moskit.art.olsztyn.pl

  • Institut für Bienenkunde Karl von Friesch Weg 2 61440 Oberursel GERMANY

Summary

The breeding of bees selected for short PCP within the Carniolan bee race has been conducted since 1991 at our Department and also, in co-operation with the Apiculture Institute of Oberursel, within hybrids of A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica, re-crossing them with Carniolan drones.

In all new generations, insignificant breeding advancement between 0.2 to 4.2 hours has been observed. The largest percentage of emerging workers within 276 hours was observed from queens of generation F4 and equalled 43.4%. These queens were inseminated with drones following the generation F3 queen. After such cross-breeding, the best queen was one whose workers emerged 85.3 % during the above mentioned time. The average estimated post-capping period equalled 269.2 hours and differed significantly from post-capping periods of the best queens of other groups. In order to unify the bee breeding line, further research is being planned.

Key words: post-capping period, breeding, selection, resistance, Varroa jacobsoni, Apis mellifera carnica, Apis mellifera capensis

INTRODUCTION

The Apiculture Department of the Olsztyn University of Agriculture and Technology has been working on bees with short post-capping period breeding since 1991 (Wilde and Koeniger 1992, Wilde and Siuda 1992). The breeding of such bees forms a part of the research towards developing bee colonies resistant to Varroa jacobsoni (Wilde 1994a). This kind of resistance to a parasite invasion was observed in the case of the South-African bees Apis mellifera capensis. Their workers emerge as early as after 10-11 days of PCP, and the still immature Varroa progeny die (Moritz and Mautz 1990). It is supposed that shortening the PCP would restrain the mites’ reproduction and therefore would limit or completely eliminate the introduction of acaricides into the brood nest


¹This work was supported by KBN grant Nr 5 S3110107

strona 136

environment (Büchler 1990, Moritz 1985, Siuda and Wilde 1995, Wilde 1994a).

The breeding of bees selected for the short PCP within the Carniolan bee race has been conducted at our Department and also, in co-operation with the Apiculture Institute of Oberursel, within hybrids of A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica, re-crossing them with Carniolan drones. The research goal is to obtain a bee line with a short post-capping period (PCP), characteristic of the South-African bee and, at the same time, possessing features of the Carniolan bee.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In April 1996 the post-capping periods of workers from generation F₃ queens of South-African bees re-crossed with Carniolan drones and the F₆ generation of pure Carniolan bees were evaluated. To evaluate the duration of PCP for workers, the Langenbach method (1991) with our own modification was used. The operculation moment was estimated for two days three times a day at 8, 14 and 20 hours. The recently-sealed brood were marked on plastic foil stuck to the honeycomb. The above allowed the definition of three time periods – from 252 to 300 hours with a 6-hour interval for emerging of workers. The queens of workers that emerged in the largest percentage within 276 hours were selected for further research. Additionally, the best queen of the hybrid generation F₄ was used, along with her best non-inseminated daughter (the PCP of the worker progeny of this queen was evaluated in 1995). 20 queen-daughters from each best queen was bred. The queens were reared by means of a continuous method in queenless rearing colonies. When capped, the queen cells were transferred to an incubator. After the emergence of queens, they were introduced to the newly-started mating nuclei which were then placed in a cellar for two days before exposing them in an apiary. On the 7th day of the queens’ life, they were anaesthetised with CO₂ for 5 minutes and on the following day, artificially inseminated with a single dose of 8 mm³ of semen. Half of the queens, except queen-daughters from the hybrid generation F₄ queen, were inseminated with drone semen from the non-inseminated queen-daughter of hybrid generation F₄. Another half and all queens of hybrid generation F₄ were inseminated with semen from Carniolan drones imported from the Apiculture Institute in Oberursel (Germany). This method lead to achieving five breeding lines with a different Apis mellifera capensis gene contribution (Table 1). 7 days after insemination, the mating nuclei were revised and the queens that did not start egg laying were again exposed to a CO₂ narcosis for 2 minutes. The workers’ PCP in the mating hives was determined with the use of the above-described method. 10 queen-daughters were gained from the best queens. The queens were inseminated with the Carniolan

strona 137

drones from the Institute’s own breeding and introduced into commercial colonies. These bees will be the subject of further research.

Table 1 Tested materials Testowany materiał

Group Grupa Generation Pokolenie Estimated part of genes A.m. capensis in worker bees (in %) Szacowany udział genów A.m .capensis u robotnic (w %)
1 F₇ A.m.carnica x A.m.carnica 0.00
2 hybrid of F₅ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 1.65
3 hybrid of F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 3.13
4 hybrid of F₇ A.m.carnica x F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 6.25
5 hybrid of F₄ A.m.capensis x F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 9.38

All numerical data collected during the experiment were processed with the Statigrafics programme (Dąbkowski 1992). Significance of differences was determined by variance analysis (ANOVA) and multiple range test with least significant difference range (LSD). Values that differed significantly at 0.05 and 0.01 are marked with small and capital letters, respectively.

RESULTS

In the initial generations, workers were emerging in all the determined time periods. The pure Carniolan workers from generation F₆, on average, were emerging in the lowest percentage within 276 hours (17.5% Table 2). The largest number of workers emerging within 276 hours (43.3%) was observed in the case of generation F₃ of hybrid bees, whereas the number of workers emerging in case of hybrid generation F₄ was only average (28.7%). The worker-progeny of the selected queens of generation F₆ and F₃ had a narrower range of PCP workers emerging in comparison to other queens: from 264 to 288 hours and from 252 to 288 hours respectively (Table 2).

strona 138

Table 2 Percentage of worker bees that emerged within 276 hours in the initial generations (in %) Udział robotnic wygryzających się do 276 godzin w pokoleniach wyjściowych (w %)

Generation Pokolenie n Average Średnio Min – max % From best queens Po najlepszych matkach
F₆ A.m. carnica 3 17.5 3.6 – 24.9 24.9
hybrid of F₃ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 8 43.3 23.4 – 80.1 80.1
hybrid of F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 18 28.7 0.0 – 62.1 62.1

The examined bee breeding lines had a similar average worker PCP. The lowest worker PCP value was obtained in bees from the hybrid generation F₃ and equalled 280.4 hours. The bees from generation F₆ emerged on average after 282.9 hours and showed the lowest differences between the average values of this feature in workers from each queen of the tested generations (Table 3). Generation F₄ was identified by an average worker PCP that equalled 283.2 hours, as well as the broadest difference equalling 14.3 hours. The average worker PCPs of the best queens of generation F₃ and F₄ were similar and equalled 275.8 and 275.7 respectively. It significantly differed from worker PCP from the best queen of generation F₆ and equalled 281.2 (Table 3).

Table 3 Estimated average of PCP worker bees in the initial generations (in h) Szacowana średnia długość OCZ robotnic w pokoleniach wyjściowych (w godz.)

Generation Pokolenie n Average Średnio Min – max From best queens Po najlepszych matkach Min – max (in h) (w godz.)
F₆ A.m. carnica 3 282.9 281.2 – 284.0 281.2^b 264 – 288
hybrid of F₃ A.m.capensis x A.m. carnica 8 280.4 275.8 – 285.3 275.8^a 252 – 288
hybrid of F₄ A.m. capensis x A.m. carnica 18 283.2 275.7 – 290.0 275.7^a 252 – 300

Different letters indicate significant defferences at p=0.05 Różne litery oznaczają różnice istotne na poziomie p=0,05

strona 139

In generation F₇ of Carniolan bees, 10.3 to 59.5% of workers emerged within 276 hours – averaging 28.9% (Table 4). In the generation F₄ and F₅ within 276 hours emerged on average 36.7% and 39.7% of workers respectively. The largest percentage of emerged workers within 276 hours was observed in queens of the hybrid generation F₄ that were inseminated with drone semen bred from the queen of generation F₄ and the emergence was between 22.2% and 85.3%, which on average equalled 43.4%. From such cross-breeding additionally, the best queen was obtained since 85.3% of her worker progeny emerged during the same period (Table 4). The lowest percentage of workers emerging during the same PCP was observed from those bred from queens of generation F₇, inseminated with drones produced by a non-inseminated queen-daughter from the hybrid generation F₄.

Table 4 Emerging of worker bees within 276 hours in all generations (in %) Wygryzanie się robotnic do 276 godzin w poszczególnych pokoleniach (w %)

Group Grupa Generation Pokolenie Average średni From best queens Po najlepszych matkach Min – max
1 F₇ A.m.carnica x A.m.carnica 28.9 59.5 10.3 – 59.5
2 hybrid of F₅ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 39.7 62.6 27.4 – 62.6
3 hybrid of F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 36.7 37.2 27.6 – 37.2
4 hybrid of F₇ A.m.carnica x F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 24.6 34.3 8.2 – 34.3
5 hybrid of F₄ A.m.capensis x F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 43.4 85.3 22.2 – 85.3
strona 140

Table 5 Estimated average of PCP worker bees in all generations (in h) Szacowana średnia długość OCZ robotnic w poszczególnych pokoleniach (w godz.)

Group Grupa Generation Pokolenie Average Średnio Min – max From best queens Po najlepszych matkach Min – max
1 F₇ A.m.carnica x A.m.carnica 281.0 277.6-285.6 277.6^Bb 252 – 294
2 hybrid of F₅ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 280.2 274.5-283.2 274.5^ABb 252 – 294
3 hybrid of F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 279.5 278.8-285.2 278.8^Bb 258 – 300
4 hybrid of F₇ A.m.carnica x F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 282.8 280.6-288.6 280.6^Bbc 258 – 300
5 hybrid of F₄ A.m.capensis x F₄ A.m.capensis x A.m.carnica 279.0 269.2-282.6 269.2^Aa 252 – 300

Different small and capital letters indicate significant defferences at p=0.05 and p=0.01, respectively Różne małe litery oznaczają różnice istotne na poziomie p=0,05, duże zaś – na poziomie p=0,01

The cross-breeding lines of bees had similar worker average PCPs. The shortest worker PCP average was observed in the hybrids of generations F₄ crossed with F₄ – equalling 279.0 hours. In this generation one queen was found who’s worker progeny had an average PCP of 269.2 hours and differed significantly from queens of other groups (Table 5). The longest worker PCP average in a generation, as well as bred by the best queen, was observed in generation F₇ – A.m.carnica – that were inseminated with hybrid drones and equalled om average 282.8 and 280.6 hours respectively. The latter number is significantly higher than an average worker PCP from the best queen of the hybrid generation F₅ which was 274.5 hours (Table 5). On average, workers from this generation emerged after 280.2 hours. The best queens of generations F₇ and F₄ had similar worker PCP averages and it equalled 277.6 and 278.8 hours respectively, as well as a similar worker PCP average for all generations, which equalled 281.0 and 279.5 hours respectively.

strona 141

DISCUSSION

The determination of emerging worker percentage instead of the strict determination of worker PCP did not influence the selection efficiency. In all newly-obtained generations, insignificant breeding progress was observed – equalling from 0.2 to 4.2 hours. In comparison to recent years, a worker PCP average extension was observed within the Carniolan bee line by about 3 hours (Siuda and Wilde 1995). According to the observations of Wilde (1994a) and Büchler (1990) many factors, mainly climatic, make comparison of the results difficult over different seasons and years. The cause of such regression is difficult to pinpoint. Perhaps a significant queen loss in generation F₅ during the last cold winter was the problem. Within hybrid bees from generations F₄ and F₅, the worker PCP average was shorter by 4 and 7 hours, respectively, in comparison to analogous generations from 1993 (Siuda and Wilde 1995).

In 1995, the number of queens in the following generations increased. Those queen workers emerged 50% or more by 276 hours (Siuda et al. 1996). In 1996, a stable 20% share of such queens in each generation was observed. In 1996, in generations F₇ and F₅ an increase of worker percentage emerging by 276 hours by about 10% was observed, whereas in hybrid generation F₄ (group 3) a decrease of such feature was observed by about 7%. According to the suggestions of Moritz and Jordan (1992) and Wilde (1994b), the A.m. capensis hybrid drones used to inseminate queens should additionally shorten worker PCP. Perhaps the unfavourable weather conditions during PCP determination resulted in the failure to shorten the worker PCP bred from queens inseminated by such drones. The queens of the hybrid generation F₄ (group 5) had the shortest worker PCP, thus perhaps the maternal effect in unfavourable weather conditions were the most significant factor (Bienefeld and Stroh 1992). The results obtained from the above generation demonstrate the future opportunities to shorten worker PCP through cross-breeding the obtained bee lines.

CONCLUSIONS

  1. The determination of emerging workers percentage, instead of the strict determination of workers PCP emerging within 276 hours, did not influence the selection efficiency.
  2. It seems possible to advance worker PCP shortening through cross-breeding the obtained bee lines.
strona 142

REFERENCES

Bienefeld K., Stroh A. M. (1992) – Einflüsse der mütterlichen Abstammung der Bienenbrut (Apis mellifera) auf die Reproduktoin von Varroa jacobsoni. Ann UMCS. Sectio DD, 47: 123-125.

Büchler R. (1990) – Genetisch bedingte Unterschiede in der Anfälligkeit vov Bienenvölker (Apis mellifera L.) gegenüber der Varroamilbe (Varroa jacobsoni Oud.) als Grundlage einer Zucht auf erhöhte Wiederstandfähigkeit. Ph.D. Thesis. Rheinische Friedich Wilheims Universität. Bonn.

Dąbkowski J. (1992) – Statgrafics – System statystycznego opracowania danych. Komputerowa Oficyna Wydawnicza „Help”: 1-240.

Langenbach K. 1991: Bestimmung der Zellverdeckelungsdauer verschiedener Bienenherkünfte. Apidologie 22: 448-450.

Moritz R. F. A. (1985) – Heritability of the postcaping stage in Apis mellifera and its ralation to varroatosis resis tence. J. Hered., 76: 267-270.

Moritz R. F. A., Jordan M. (1992) – Selection of resistance against Varroa jacobsoni across caste and sex in the honeybee (Apis mellifica L., Hymenoptera: Apidae). Exp. Appl. Acarol., 16: 345-353

Moritz R. F. A., Mautz D. (1990) – Development of Varroa jacobsoni in colonies of Apis mellifera capensis and Apis mellifera carnica. Apidologie, 21: 53-58.

Siuda M., Koeniger N., Wilde J. (1996) – Nowe linie pszczół Apis mellifera o krótkim okresie czerwiu zasklepionego. 33. Naukowa Konferencja Pszczelarska. Puławy. Materiały z konferencji: 67-69.

Siuda, M., Wilde J. (1995) – Selekcja pszczół (Apis mellifera carnica) o krótkim okresie postlarwalnym. Pszczeln. Zeszyt. Nauk. 39 (1): 79-86.

Wilde J., (1994a) – Hodowla pszczół o skróconym okresie postlarwalnym, odpornych na Varroa jacobsoni. Acta Acad. Agricult. Tech. Olst., Zootechnica, 39 B: 1-43.

Wilde J., (1994b) – Einfluß der Zellverdeckelungsdauer von Königinnen und Drohnen auf die ihrer Nachkommen bei Apis melifera carnica. Apidologie, 25 (4): 38-39.

Wilde J., Koeniger N. (1992) – Fortschritte bei der Verkürzung der Zellverdeckelungsdauer der Arbeiterinnenbrut von Apis mellifera carnica. Ann. UMCS. Sectio DD, 47: 133-136.

Wilde J., Siuda M., (1992) – Próba selekcji na skrócenie stadium czerwia zasklepionego u pszczoły miodnej Apis mellifera carnica. Ann, UMCS. Sectio DD, 47: 137-140.

DALSZE PRACE NAD WYHODOWANIEM LINII PSZCZÓŁ O KRÓTKIM OKRESIE CZERWIU ZASKLEPIONEGO

M. Siuda, J. Wilde, N. Koeniger

Streszczenie

W 1995 roku wyhodowano dwie nowe linie pszczół o krótkim okresie czerwiu zasklepionego (OCZ). Wyhodowany materiał przekrzyżowano miedzy sobą oraz z linią pszczół hodowanych w 1994 roku. Otrzymane krzyżówki wykorzystano do tworzenia trzech linii pszczół, o krótkim OCZ, przy różnym udziale genów Apis mellifera capensis. Po rozpoczęciu czerwienia obserwowano moment zasklepiania komórek czerwiu przez dwie doby,

strona 143

trzy razy dziennie o godzinie 8, 14 i 20. Zasklepione w tym czasie komórki oznaczano na przykładanej do plastra folii zgodnie z metodyką podaną przez Langenbach (1991). Po dziesięciu dniach obserwowano wygryzanie się pszczół również o godzinie 8, 14 i 20 przez trzy doby. Pozwoliło to wyznaczyć 9 przedziałów czasowych od 252 do 300 godzin z interwałem 6 godzinnym w których mieściły się wygryzające robotnice. W doświadczeniu określano procent wygryzionych robotnic w poszczególnych przedziałach. Od matek charakteryzujących się najwyższym procentem robotnic wygryzających się do 276 godzin hodowano następne pokolenia.

Pokolenie wyjściowe F6 krainek charakteryzowało się najniższym średnim procentem robotnic wygryzających się do 276 godzin (17,5% tab.2). Najwięcej robotnic wygryzających się do 276 godzin, bo aż 43,3% stwierdzono w pokoleniu F3 pszczół mieszańców. Najwyższy procent pszczół wygryzających się do 276 godzin stwierdzono u robotnic po matce z pokolenia F3 mieszańców (80,1%), nieco niższy bo wynoszący 62,1% u robotnic po matce F4 a najniższy w pokoleniu F6 pszczół kraińskich 24,95 (tab. 2).

W pokoleniu potomnym F7 pszczół kraińskich udział robotnic o OCZ 276 godzin wynosił od 10,3 do 59,5 – średnio 28,9% (tab. 4). Udział robotnic wygryzających się do 276 godzin w pokoleniu F4 i F5 mieszańców, wynosił odpowiednio od 27,6 do 37,2 i od 27,4 do 62,6%. Najwyższy procent robotnic wygryzających się do 276 godzin stwierdzono u matek mieszańców pokolenia F4 unasienionymi trutniami mieszańcami pokolenia F4 – średnio 43,4%. Przy tym kojarzeniu otrzymano również najlepszą matkę, której robotnice aż w 85,3 procentach wygryzały się w tym czasie (tab. 4). Najmniej robotnic średnio 24,6% wygryzało się po matkach pokolenia F7 unasienionych trutniami mieszańcami F4.

Najniższy średni OCZ robotnic stwierdzono u krzyżówki pokolenia F4 (grupa 5) 279,0 godzin. W pokoleniu tym uzyskano matkę o średnim OCZ robotnic wynoszącym 269,2 godzin i różniącą się istotnie od najlepszych matek z pozostałych grup (tab.5). Najdłuższy średni OCZ robotnic w całym pokoleniu oraz po najlepszej matce stwierdzono w pokoleniu F7 A.m.carnica unasienianych trutniami mieszańcami odpowiednio 282,8 godz. oraz 280,6 godz. Ten ostatni wynik był istotnie wyższy od średniego OCZ robotnic od najlepszej matki pokolenia F5 mieszańców 274,5 godz. (tab.5). Średnio w pokoleniu tym robotnice wygryzały się po 280,2 godz. Najlepsze matki pokolenia F7 oraz F4 miały zbliżony średni OCZ robotnic wynoszący 277,6 i 278,8 godz. oraz podobny średni OCZ robotnic dla całych pokoleń odpowiednio 281,0 oraz 279,5 godz. Zrezygnowanie z ścisłego określania OCZ robotnic na rzecz określania procentu robotnic wygryzających się do 276 godzin nie wpłynęło na skuteczność prowadzonej selekcji. We wszystkich nowo uzyskanych pokoleniach stwierdzono niewielki bo wynoszący od 0,2 do 4,2 godzin postęp hodowlany.

W celu dalszego ujednolicania pogłowia pszczół zamierza się kontynuować dalsze prace w bliskim pokrewieństwie.

Słowa kluczowe: okres czerwiu zasklepionego, hodowla, selekcja, odporność, Varroa jacobsoni, Apis mellifera carnica, Apis mellifera capensis


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 135, streszczenie: „generation F3 queen” → generation F4 queen
  • s. 135: „Karl von Friesch” → Karl von Frisch
  • s. 136: „three time periods” → nine time periods
  • s. 137: „Statigrafics” → Statgrafics
  • s. 137: „respectively (Table 2)” → respectively (Table 3)
  • s. 138, tab. 3: „defferences” → differences
  • s. 140, tab. 5: „defferences” → differences
  • s. 140: „who’s worker progeny” → whose worker progeny
  • s. 140: „om average” → on average
  • s. 142, piśmiennictwo: „Reproduktoin” → Reproduktion
  • s. 142, piśmiennictwo: „vov Bienenvölker” → von Bienenvölker
  • s. 142, piśmiennictwo: „Wiederstandfähigkeit” → Widerstandsfähigkeit
  • s. 142, piśmiennictwo: „Friedich Wilheims” → Friedrich Wilhelms
  • s. 142, piśmiennictwo: „postcaping” → postcapping
  • s. 142, piśmiennictwo: „ralation” → relation
  • s. 142, piśmiennictwo: „resis tence” → resistance
  • s. 142, piśmiennictwo: „melifera” → mellifera
  • s. 142, streszczenie: „miedzy” → między
  • s. 143, streszczenie: „24,95″ → 24,9%
  • s. 143, streszczenie: „unasienionymi trutniami” → unasienionych trutniami

Podobne wpisy