EFFECT OF VARIOUS FOOD INGREDIENTS ON PHYSIOLOGICAL CONDITION OF WORKER BEES KEPT IN AN INCUBATOR
tekst: Krystyna Tworek, Renata Grochowska
Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XL, 1996 — Krystyna Tworek, Renata Grochowska
strona 99PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XL, Nr 2 1996
Krystyna Tworek, Renata Grochowska
Bee Research Department, University of Agriculture, Al. 29 Listopada 52, 31-425 Cracow, POLAND
Summary
In our study we examined the effect of several food additives (fumagiline, lyophilised royal jelly, melissa and citric acid) administered in syrup on the life span and physiological condition of worker bees Apis mellifera carnica kept in cages, inside an incubator at 30°C.
It was recorded that 5-7 day-old worker bees, fed with syrup enriched with fumagiline could be kept in cages, without flying, for at least 20 days. The addition of royal jelly positively influences the condition of pharyngeal glands but at the same time favours the progress of Nosema apis. Melissa harmed worker bees but the addition of citric acid seemed to have no effect upon the investigated features.
Keywords: Apis mellifera, bees feeding, experimental diet, worker bees, isolation.
INTRODUCTION
After insemination, queen bees are often kept together with worker bees in an incubator. An advantage resulting therefrom is diminishing the loss due to injuries of queen bees occurring while keeping them in cages, in a nursing colony (Jasiński 1987, 1995). Keeping working bees in cages without the possibility of flying also has disadvantages. The isolation of bees favours a rapid progress of Nosema apis in their alimentary canals, which is dangerous for the queens they care for. Infecting queen bees with Nosema disease negatively influences both the final effect of insemination and further usage of them (Zawilski, Skonieczna-Zawilska 1995). According to Shimanuki (1973) queen bees become infected within four days following the first contact with sick worker bees. Loskotova et al. (1980) stated that, at the moment of dispatching to bee-keepers, 20% of queens are already infected with Nosema disease. Liu et al. (1987) found that 38% of queen bees were infected with this disease. To limit the progress of Nosema disease, fumagiline is added to food administered to worker bees raising queens (Farrar 1954; Shimanuki et al. 1973).
A standard method allows keeping queens in the same cage for the
strona 100period not exceeding ten days. After this period, the mortality rate among worker bees significantly increases. A ten day period of keeping queens is not always sufficient for the needs of breeding apiaries. A question arises if the addition of substances to syrup, other than those used so far, may have any influence on the span life of isolated worker bees. One decided to check lyophilised royal jelly, as a source of protein inhibiting the degeneration of pharyngeal glands (Crailsheim et al. 1992), melissa which has tranquillising qualities and citric acid used by bee-keepers for aciding syrup.
The investigations we conducted were aimed at checking the effect of fumigilina and other additives to syrup on physiological condition and the life span of working bees kept in incubators.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The investigations were conducted within two time spans: 10 May – 6 June (series A) and 9 June – 29 June 1995 (series B) in the Bee Research Department, University of Agriculture in Cracow. Worker bees Apis mellifera carnica, progeny of two queens which were sisters, were used in the experiment. Before the start of the experiment, queens were isolated on combs for three days. Combs with brood were placed for seven days onto an upper hive part, isolated from a strong bee colony with a dense net. Young, 5-7 day- old worker bees were collected from combs with a pipe used for catching a queen and placed in numbers of 50 into wooden cages (4 x 6.5 x 9 cm), equipped with small combs and a feeding tube. Five experimental groups were separated. Worker bees from group no. I were administered only syrup made in weight ratio water : sugar 3:2. Worker bees from other groups were administered syrup enriched as follows: group no. II – fumagiline additive (6.6 g /1 l syrup); group no. III – lyophilised royal jelly (6.6 g – 7.0 g/1 l syrup); group no. IV – Melissa officinalis infusion addition (18 g herb/1 l water); group no. V – addition of citric acid (2 g/1 l syrup).
The worker bees were kept in an incubator at 30°C and relative humidity of 40%. In series A, observations were made upon worker bees in 50 cages, 10 in each group, in series B – in 30 cages, 6 in each group. The experiment was stopped when the death rate of worker bees in the first cage being observed (regardless of the group) reached 50%. During the experiment the amount of food taken by bees from each cage during the consecutive 24 hours was calculated. Every day dead bees were removed and counted. That enabled the calculation of an average amount of food taken by bees from each group during 24 hours and an average number of dead bees in a group, for the whole time of the experiment.
On the day of terminating the experiment, all worker bees which were still alive were put to sleep with CO2. Then their fresh body weight,
strona 101fresh rectum weight and also development of pharyngeal glands and number of N. apis spores were investigated. Each feature was investigated on 5 worker bees, taken from each cage. Altogether, to mark one feature in series A 50 worker bees from each feeding group were investigated and in series B thirty worker bees from each group.
Infection degree with spores N. apis was investigated with the help of the hemocitometric method. Rectum was ground in 1 ml of distilled water. Spores were counted in 100 small squares of Büerker chamber of a joined capacity of 0.025 mm³. When the number of spores was smaller than 50, they were counted in fifty big squares of a capacity of 0.2 mm³. The obtained values were converted to the capacity of 1 mm³.
Pharyngeal glands were prepared in a 0.85% solution of NaCl (Sasagawa et al. 1989). The degree of their development was calculated on the basis of a bonitatic scale, according to Maurizio (1954), modified by Sasagawa et al. (1989).
The results were statistically worked out with the help of non-parametric test of Kruskal-Wallis (Sokal and Rohlf 1981). The significance of differences on the level P < 0.05 was marked in tables with different small letters of the alphabet.
RESULTS
Mortality rate of worker bees. The first investigation series was completed after 28 days when worker bees reached the age of 33-35 days. The second series was ended after 20 days, when worker bees reached the age of 25-27 days. In series A no differences were found in the mortality rate of different feeding groups. In series B the highest mortality rate, significantly higher than in the remaining groups, was recorded in group IV (Tables 1, 2).
Food taking. In series A the worker bees from group III – royal jelly – took significantly more food. The worker bees from group II – fumagiline – took significantly less food. (Table 1) In series B the most intensive food intake characterised the worker bees from group IV – M. officinalis. Similarly to series A, less food was taken by the bees of group II, who were administered fumagiline (Table 2). It was also recorded that in both series the worker bees from groups I and III had willingly stored food in small combs. The worker bees from groups IV and V had stored food only sporadically. The worker bees from group II did not store food at all.
strona 102T a b l e 2
Average values of the features under investigation and the extreme values (in brackets) in different food groups. Series B, 10.VI.-29.VI.1995 Średnie wartości badanych cech i wartości graniczne (w nawiasach) w różnych grupach pokarmowych. Seria B, 10.VI.-29.VI.1995 r.
| Feature investigated / Badana cecha | Reference test / Próba zerowa | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: I | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: II | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: III | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: IV | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: V |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of dead worker bees / Liczba martwych robotnic (szt.) | – | 1.8 a (2-8) | 3.3 a (0-14) | 3.2 a (2-10) | 14.0 b (8-44) | 2,3 a (0-18) |
| Amount of food taken (ml/cage/24 h) / Ilość pobieranego pokarmu (ml/1 klateczkę/24 h) | – | 0.96 b (0.7-1.2) | 0.64 a (0.5-1.1) | 0.76 ab (0.5-1.1) | 1.28 c (1.1-1.5) | 0.94 b (0.9-1.1) |
| Worker bee body weight in mg / Masa ciała robotnicy w mg | 137.5 (110-168) | 117.3 b (86-162) | 102.5 a (74-136) | 116.4 b (92-169) | 111.0 ab (84-146) | 107.4 a (78-129) |
| Rectum weight in mg / Masa jelita prostego w mg | 13.1 (5.6-21.9) | 29.4 bc (15.8-46.3) | 24.0 a (11.2-44.5) | 27.8 ab (12.3-40.5) | 32.7 c (21.1-56.0) | 31.2 bc (15.3-43.6) |
| Development of pharynegal glands (scale 1-6) / Rozwój gruczołów gardzielowych (w skali 1-6) | 2.4 (1-4) | 1.6 a (1-3) | 1.9 a (1-3) | 2.5 b (1-4) | 1.6 a (1-2) | 1.8 a (1-3) |
| Number of spores N. apis per worker / Liczba spor N. apis na 1 robotnicę | 6 (0-60) | 32 a (0-700) | 0.0 a (0-0) | 140 a (0-1140) | 18084 b (0-326080) | 19365 b (0-346560) |
T a b l e 1
Average values of the features under investigation and the extreme values (in brackets) in different food groups. Series A, 10.V.-6.VI.1995 Średnie wartości badanych cech i wartości graniczne (w nawiasach) w różnych grupach pokarmowych. Seria A, 10.V.-6.VI.1995 r.
| Feature investigated / Badana cecha | Reference test / Próba zerowa | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: I | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: II | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: III | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: IV | Food group – Grupa pokarmowa: V |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of dead worker bees / Liczba martwych robotnic (szt.) | – | 5.7 a (0-30) | 3.0 a (0-16) | 5.0 a (2-24) | 5.4 a (2-20) | 4.3 a (2-18) |
| Amount of food taken (ml/cage/24 h) / Ilość pobieranego pokarmu (ml/1 klateczkę/24 h) | – | 1.32 bcd (0.9-2.0) | 0.81 a (0.7-0.9) | 1.51 d (1.1-1.9) | 1.25 bc (1.0-1.5) | 0.91 b (0.6-1.3) |
| Worker bee body weight in mg / Masa ciała robotnicy w mg | 124.4 (90.0-176.5) | 119.6 a (83.0-185.0) | 111.7 a (84.5-157.5) | 120.5 a (98.5-171.5) | 115.6 a (85.0-173.5) | 117.6 a (91.5-153.0) |
| Rectum weight in mg / Masa jelita prostego w mg | 27.9 (6.7-43.5) | 28.5 a (14.0-70.0) | 28.7 a (14.6-60.0) | 32.0 b (15.6-55.0) | 33.9 b (16.2-57.0) | 31.0 ab (10.9-56.0) |
| Development of pharynegal glands (scale 1-6) / Rozwój gruczołów gardzielowych (w skali 1-6) | 1.2 (1-2) | 1.9 a (1-4) | 1.9 a (1-3) | 2.7 b (1-4) | 1.7 a (1-3) | 2.4 b (1-4) |
| Number of spores N. apis per worker / Liczba spor N. apis na 1 robotnicę | 14 (0-20) | 18476 c (0-225440) | 0.0 a (0-0) | 30555 c (0-273120) | 24784 c (0-244320) | 14575 b (0-198720) |
Values followed by different small letters differ significantly at a level of P<0.05 Różne litery obok liczb oznaczają, że średnie różnią się między sobą istotnie na poziomie P<0,05 Group I – syrup, group II – syrup with fumagiline, group III – syrup with royal jelly, group IV – syrup with M. officinalis, group V – syrup with citric acid Grupa I – czysty syrop cukrowy, grupa II – syrop cukrowy z dodatkiem fumagailiny, grupa III – syrop z dodatkiem mleczka pszczelego, grupa IV – syrop z melisą, grupa V – syrop z kwaskiem cytrynowym
strona 104Body mass. On the day of completing the investigation of series A and B, a decrease in the body weight of the worker bees in relation to the body weight recorded on the day of commencing the experiment was noted. It should be stressed here that in series A, this decrease was less significant than in series B, and could be contained within the limits of 3.9-12.7 mg and 20.2-35.0 mg respectively.
While comparing the feeding groups, it becomes clear that in series A no significant differences in the fresh body weight of the working bees were recorded (Table 1). They were recorded in series B, the worker bees of groups II and III had the highest fresh body weight while those of groups II and V the lowest (Table 2).
Rectum mass. At the termination of both series, an increase in the rectum weight of the worker bees was recorded in relation to the said weight recorded on the day of commencing the investigation (Tables 1, 2). In series A the bees from groups IV (M. officinalis) and III (royal jelly) had the highest rectum weight (Table 1). In series B rectum mass of worker bees from groups III, I, and V was similar. The highest rectum weight was recorded in group IV (Table 2).
An important relation between the amount of food taken during 24 hours and rectum weight was recorded only in series B (r = 0.42; df = 28; P < 0.05). In series A, the increase of rectum weight was accompanied by the death rate of worker bees (r = 0.29; df = 48; P < 0.05).
Development of pharyngeal glands. In series A, the development of pharyngeal gland of worker bees from group 0 corresponded to 1.2 points, in series B to 2.4 points on the average. After the termination of the investigation, most developed pharyngeal glands were recorded in both series at worker bees from group III (royal jelly). It should be stressed here that in series A, in each group, pharyngeal glands of worker bees were more developed than at the beginning of the investigation (Table 1). In four feeding groups of series B, a degeneration of pharyngeal glands was recorded and only in case of worker bees from group III (royal jelly) pharyngeal glands were preserved in the state comparable to the original one (Table 2).
Presence of Nosema apis spores. In zero tests of both series, few spores of N. apis were found. However, during the experiment, the number of spores significantly increased in several cases. Differences were noted between series as to the degree of parasite infection of worker bees (Tables 1 and 2). The kind of food administered to worker bees also influenced the degree of infection with spores N. apis. It was not similarly distinct in both series. In series A most spores were detected in the worker bees from groups III (royal jelly), IV (M. officinalis) and I (syrup) (Table 1). In series B most spores were found in worker bees from group IV (M. officinalis) and V (citric acid) (Table 2).
In both series, an important relation between the amount of food
strona 105taken and the degree of infection with spores N. apis was noted: Series A – r = 0.44; df = 48; P < 0.05; Series B – r = 0.40; df = 28, P < 0.05. However, no effect of the infection level upon the higher mortality rate of the worker bees was found.
DISCUSSION
The results recorded confirmed the opinions of other authors (Szczepański, Gromiszowa 1979), concerning the variability of the bees’ reactions to various factors, observed also when worker bees in consecutive series were chosen from the same colonies within short periods of time.
Regardless of the noted variability it was proved that worker bees can be kept in cages for at least 20 days till they reach the age of minimum 25 days, which corresponds to the life span of worker bees from productive colonies (Woyke 1980). It can be supposed that the presence of the queen in each observed cage could positively influence the worker bees and additionally prolong the period of their safe keeping (Nahas-Zahreddine, Pain 1981). The results achieved let us assume that the lack of flying is not the only reason of the high mortality rate of worker bees closed in cages. It may be assumed that one of the main reasons is taking to a cage 10-15 day – old bees, who reach the age of 25 days, but the period of their isolation is then maximum 10 days.
The next reason of a high mortality rate of worker bees is the unfavourable effect of carbon dioxide used as an anaesthetic while placing bees in cages (Skowronek, Jaycox 1974). In this investigation 5-7 day- old worker bees were placed in cages and no anaesthetics were used.
The body mass of worker bees changes with their age. Bees older than 20 days have a smaller body weight than those that are 7-9 days old (Konopacka et al. 1975; Bornus et al. 1977). In our investigation the loss was least clear in group I – sugar syrup and III – syrup with royal jelly. The most distinct loss in body weight was found in group II – fumagilline. The loss in the fresh weight was connected not only with the gradual process of worker bees’ getting old (Konopacka et al. 1975). It may be supposed that the additive of fumagilina in an experimental diet caused disturbances in the metabolic process which in effect caused the deterioration of the worker bees’ condition.
The physiological state of a bee can be estimated, among other ways, by examining the condition of pharyngeal glands (Maurizio 1954). This feature is especially important in the case of worker bees accompanying the queen. A noted positive effect of lyophilised royal jelly on the condition of pharyngeal glands is a confirmation of data provided by other authors
strona 106(Crailsheim et al. 1992), concerning the importance of protein for their development. At the same time, the administration of royal jelly favours the development of N. apis spores, which was observed in series A. According to Gray (1968), the development of N. apis spores is correlated with the amount of protein taken. This opinion is confirmed by the results obtained in series A but in series B the presence of protein in diet did not have such a significant effect upon the development of this sickness. To avoid this sickness one should check the reaction of bees to a simultaneous administration of fumagiline and royal jelly in syrup.
The additive of M. officinalis to syrup is harmful for bees being closed in cages whereas the additive of citric acid does not have any significant influence as the results obtained with groups I and V do not differ significantly in relation to almost all investigated ratios (Tables 1, 2).
CONCLUSIONS
Settling young, 5-7 day-old worker bees in cages and feeding them with syrup enriched with fumagiline makes it possible to keep them in an incubator for at least 20 days without being infected with spores N. apis.
The administration of syrup with royal jelly has a positive effect upon the development of pharyngeal glands of worker bees but favours the degree of infection with spores N. apis.
The addition of Melissa officinalis infusion causes a faster filling of rectum which in consequence leads to the increase of the death rate among worker bees.
The administration of syrup enriched with citric acid to worker bees has a similar effect as in the case of clear syrup.
REFERENCES
Bornus L., Muszyńska J., Konopacka Z. (1977) – Zależność między kondycją pszczół robotnic a chorobą zarodnikowcową (Nosema apis Z.). Pszczeln. Zesz.Nauk., 21:29-145.
Crailsheim K., Schneider L., Hrassnigg N., Buhlmann G., Brosch U., Gmeinbauer R., Schoffmann B. (1992) – Pollen consumption and utilization in worker honeybees (Apis mellifera carnica) dependence on individual age and function. J.Insect Physiol., 38(6):409-419.
Farrar C. L. (1953) – Fumagillin for Nosema control in package bees. Amer.Bee J., 94:52.
Gray F. H. (1968) – Infection of honeybee, Apis mellifera L. (Insecta, Hymenoptera) by Nosema apis (Protozoa, Enidospora) and its relation to endocrine function. Fac. Ent. Ohio State Univ. Columbus, Ohio.
Jasiński Z. (1987) – Uszkodzenie matek przetrzymywanych w rodzinie pszczelej i poza rodziną. XXXI Międzynarodowy Kongres Pszczelarski. Warszawa, Apimondia, 34-35
strona 107s.
Jasiński Z., Fliszkiewicz C. (1995) – Uszkodzenia matek pszczelich przechowywanych w osieroconych rodzinach w klateczkach z pszczołami i bez nich. Pszczeln.Zesz.Nauk., 39(2): 7-13.
Konopacka Z., Muszyńska J., Szczepański K. (1975) – Ocena przydatności cech fizykochemicznych i anatomicznych dla charakterystyki kondycji robotnic pszczoły miodnej. Pszczeln.Zesz.Nauk., 19:39-52.
Laskotova J., Peroutka M., Vesely V. (1980) – Nosema disease of honeybee queens (Apis mellifica L.). Apidologie, 11(2):153-161.
Liu T.P., Nelson D.L., Collins M.M. (1987) – Amoeba- and nosema- infected queen honeybees and worker attendants shipped in mailing cages to western Canada. J. apic. Res., 26(1):56-58.
Maurizio A. (1954) – Pollenernährung und Lebensvorgänge bei der Honigbiene (Apis mellifera L.). Landw.Jrb.Schweiz., 62:115-183.
Nahas-Zahreddine G, Pain J. (1981) – Effet de l’acide céto-9 decene 2 trans oique (pheromone de la reine d’abeille Apis mellifera L.) sur le taux de mortalité d’auvrieres engagées. Apidologie, 12(3):269-288.
Sasagawa H., Sasaki M., Okada J. (1989) – Hormonal control of the division of labour in adult Honeybees (Apis mellifera L.). 1. Effect of methoprene on corpora allata and hypopharyngeal gland and its α-glukosidase activity. Appl. Ent. Zool., 24(1):66-77.
Shimanuki H., Lehnert T., Knox D. (1973) – Transmission of Nosema Disease from infected honey bee workers to queens in mating nuclei. J.Econ.Ent., 66(3):777-778.
Skowronek W., Jaycox E. R. (1974) – Wpływ dwutlenku węgla na pszczoły robotnice. Pszczeln.Zesz.Nauk., 18:107-117.
Sokal R. R., Rohlf F. J. (1981) – Biometry. W.H.Freemam and company. N. York.
Szczepański K., Gromiszowa Z. (1979) – Wielkość i jakość próby pszczół w badaniach toksyczności pestycydów. Pszczeln.Zesz.Nauk., 23:5-13.
Woyke J. (1980) – Siła rodzin pszczelich i średnia produkcyjna długość życia pszczół. Pszczelarstwo, 4:2-5.
Zawilski A., Skonieczna-Zawilska Ł. (1995) – Negatywny wpływ Nosema apis Z. na efektywność przenikania plemników do zbiorniczków sztucznie unasienianych matek pszczelich. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 39(2):71-77.
WPŁYW RÓŻNYCH KOMPONENTÓW POKARMOWYCH NA STAN FIZJOLOGICZNY ROBOTNIC PRZETRZYMYWANYCH W INKUBATORZE
K. Tworek, R. Grochowska
Streszczenie
Badania prowadzono w roku 1995 w dwóch seriach: 10.V-6.VI. oraz 9.VI.-29.VI. na robotnicach rasy kraińskiej (Apis mellifera carnica) pochodzących od dwóch matek sióstr.
Celem badań była ocena wpływu podawania syropu cukrowego wraz z określonymi dodatkami na długość życia i stan fizjologiczny robotnic przetrzymywanych w inkubatorze.
W klateczkach hodowlanych, zaopatrzonych w mały plaster woszczyny oraz probówkę na pokarm umieszczono po 50 robotnic (5-7 dniowych) i przetrzymywano w
strona 108inkubatorze w temp. 30°C, wilgotności względnej 40%. Utworzono 5 grup pokarmowych: I – syrop cukrowy (3:2), grupa II – syrop z dodatkiem fumagiliny, III – syrop z liofilizowanym mleczkiem pszczelim, grupa IV – syrop z naparem z melisy, V – syrop z kwaskiem cytrynowym. Na każdą grupę pokarmową przypadało w serii A – 10 klateczek, serii B – 6 klateczek.
Uzyskane wyniki wskazują, że fumagilina, obok swoich właściwości hamujących rozwój choroby sporowcowej, ogranicza spożycie podawanego pokarmu i wpływa na obniżenie masy ciała robotnic. Nie wykazuje natomiast wyraźnego wpływu na stan gruczołów gardzielowych. Syrop z dodatkiem mleczka pszczelego wpływa korzystnie na rozwój gruczołów gardzielowych robotnic jednak sprzyja wysokiemu porażeniu sporami N. apis. Stwierdzono ponadto, że dodatek melisy negatywnie odziaływuje na robotnice a kwasek cytrynowy nie wykazuje wyraźnego szkodliwego działania na robotnice.
Słowa kluczowe: Apis mellifera, żywienie pszczół, dieta eksperymentalna, robotnice, izolacja.
Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji
- s. 100: „span life” → life span
- s. 100: „fumigilina” → fumagilina
- s. 101: „Büerker” → Bürker
- s. 102, tab. 2: „pharynegal” → pharyngeal
- s. 103, tab. 1: „pharynegal” → pharyngeal
- s. 103, tab. 1: „fumagailiny” → fumagiliny
- s. 104: „groups II and III” → groups I and III
- s. 106, piśmiennictwo: „Enidospora” → Cnidospora
- s. 107, piśmiennictwo: „d’auvrieres” → d’ouvrières
- s. 107, piśmiennictwo: „Freemam” → Freeman
- s. 108, streszczenie: „odziaływuje” → oddziaływuje
