SEARCHING FOR THE NEW METHODS OF BREAKING A SWARMING MOOD IN PRODUCTIVE HONEYBEE COLONIES

tekst: Jerzy Marcinkowski, Piotr Skubida, Janina Muszyńska

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XLII, 1998 — Jerzy Marcinkowski, Piotr Skubida, Janina Muszyńska

strona 85

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XLII, Nr 1 1998

Jerzy Marcinkowski, Piotr Skubida, Janina Muszyńska

Reaserch Institute of Pomology and Floriculture, Apiculture Division, Kazimierska 2 Str., 24-100 Puławy, POLAND, e-mail: opisik@man.pulawy

Summary

The research was being conducted in the years 1995 and 1996 on the total number of 118 bee colonies placed in „wielkopolski” hives. 39 of them put in a swarming mood.

The purpose of the research was finding simple and effective methods of breaking a swarming mood. This means methods, which will not lead to decrease of total colony productivity. Three such methods were proposed.

Keywords: swarming mood, anti-swarming procedures, productivity.

INTRODUCTION

A swarming of honey-bee colonies consists in their division into two new populations, from which one stays in an old nest and the other leaves it and settles in a new place. In natural conditions thanks to swarms, in spite of downfalls following as a result of different accidents and also due to different kinds of diseases, year in year out the number of honey-bee colonies does not limit drastically but on the contrary in some years increases. A swarming mood in bee colonies is a sign of their readiness to use a nectar, honeydew and pollen flow well, as well as to divide (Gromisz, Bownik 1969, Gromisz 1975; Muszyńska 1979).

Nowadays it is common knowledge that division of the colony into two new one is not accidental. The young specimen, which have a wide spectrum of productive abilities and which are in clearly good shape, come out together with a swarm (Muszyńska 1976; Muszyńska 1979; Getz et al. 1982). This is the reason why swarms pose a serious problem in trade apiaries disposed towards using a few flows. In such apiaries the colonies, easily put in a swarming mood and swarms if they have difficulty with using a nectar flow (for example due to long-lasting rains).

strona 86

There is a number of verified methods which help with effective breaking a swarming mood in a bee colony (Crane 1965). However, such methods cause crucial changes in the structure of a bee colony and their productivity decreases. Therefore, the new methods of preventing swarms are still looking for.

Two different ways of assuming an attitude towards this problem should be singled out. The first one concerns methods thanks to which there is no swarming mood in colonies, even though their structure is conducive to it. In such research the main emphasis is put on levelling the disturbances of transferring the queen substance. The results of these research have not been clear so far (Selivanova 1981, 1983; Winston et al. 1990, 1991; Naumann, Laflamme 1993). The second approach consists in searching for such methods, which help with effective keeping colonies being in a swarming mood from giving out a swarm, without making long-lasting changes in their structure. The first research concerning that problem gave encouraging results (Guderska 1956; Muszyńska 1982; Gubina 1982; Delaplane 1992; Thrasyvou et al. 1992).

The purpose of the present research was searching for the new methods of breaking a swarming mood without permanent changing the structure of bee colony. The methods, which are especially helpful in apiaries managing in storey hives.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The results presented in this publication, were obtained during the research conducted in the year 1995 and 1996 at apiaries of Division of Apiculture Institute of Pomology and Floriculture in Pulawy. The apiaries were described in the prior publication (Marcinkowski et al. 1998).

In both years of research anti-swarming operations were applied in all colonies being in a swarming mood from mid-June till mid-July. Honey, pollen and constructed comb foundation were gained from all colonies both those, which were not in a swarming mood and those, in which such a mood came into being. A term „swarming mood” was linked with colonies, in which sealed queen cups were carefully cared for till the moment of appearance of queen cells. A term „working mood” was linked with colonies, in which during whole observation queen cells did not appear.

The following methods were used for breaking a swarming mood in bee colonies.

I^st method consisted in creating a nucleus with an old queen (in its back entrance) in the same hive, in its top storey. In the parental colony one queen

strona 87

cup and most of brood were left. About 3-4 weeks after the operation a nucleus was combined with the parental colony again.

II^nd method consisted in moving all combs with brood to the top storey, which was separated from the lower one by the queen excluder. The queen was left in the lower storey, in which foundations and empty combs were added to. This methods reminds that one suggested by Delaplane (1992). The second union of both parts of colony happened after about 3-4 weeks.

III^rd method consisted in moving all combs with brood, old queen and bees, which were gathering them, to top storeys. One comb with uncapped brood, one queen cup and bees gathering in it were left in the lower storey, which was completely separated from the top storeys. A location of the entrance in the lower storey was not changed. The top entrance was turned around for 360 degrees in relation to the previous position.

IV^th method consisted in moving combs in the nest for about 180 degrees, after destroy of all sealed queen cups and queen cells. That method is propagated by Thrasyvou et al. 1992.

V^th method consisted in spraying combs in the nest together with bees gathering in it with a 0.2% water suspension of melissa oil, after the destroy of all sealed queen cups and queen cells and after increasing the nest with comb and foundation.

The I^st, II^nd and III^rd operation was applied in both years of research. The IV^th operation was applied in 1995 but it did not come to good results. Therefore, in 1996 the new method (V) was brought in research.

The operation of breaking a swarming mood was applied in each case just after affirming that a mood such as this occurred and after the estimation of a strength of colony, an area of worker bee brood, an area of drone brood, a free space on combs with worker bee brood, a total number of queen cups and queen cells and also a number of sealed queen cups. The method of estimation of these features was detailed presented in the previous publication (Marcinkowski et al. 1998).

Bee colonies for the determined combinations were selected at random. However, the situation when each combination do not differ from others as regards an average valued of coefficients characterizing each of all mentioned features, was tried to gained.

For the estimation of usefulness of described methods of breaking a swarming mood in bee colonies the following questions were considered:

  1. Effectiveness of the method.
  1. Influence of applied operation on results of bee colonies’ productivity. It should be stressed that productivity of only those colonies was estimated which had a swarming mood and then that mood was effectively broken by one of the above-mentioned methods. Furthermore, productivity of colonies,
strona 88

in which a swarming mood was effectively broken, was compared with productivity of those colonies, which were not in a mood for swarming at all (zero group).

  1. Laboriousness of the operation was determined by the time, which was required for applying a given method (what was expressed in the ratio of minutes to bee colony). That estimation in III^rd and IV^th combination was not applied to all colonies, in which the operation of breaking a swarming mood took place.

The significance of differences between comparable groups of bee colonies, for each of features were valued with a help from Duncan Test at a significance level = 0,05.

RESULTS

The characterization of condition during research. The significant differences in penchant for being in a swarming mood between consecutive years of research and also between apiaries occurred. In the apiary A, in both years of the research 38% of bee colonies began swarming preparations. However, in 1995 in apiary B 42% of bee colonies put in a swarming mood while in 1996 only 5% of them (Marcinkowski et al. 1998).

The characterization of colonies, in which operations of breaking a swarming mood were applied. Datas presented in 1st table show that colonies belonging to the V^th group were weaker than others and had crucial less worker bee brood than colonies from reminded combinations.

Table 1

Estimation of the quality of colonies numbered among consecutive combinations, made directly before the operation of breaking a swarming mood Wyniki oceny jakości rodzin zaliczanych do kolejnych kombinacji, przeprowadzonej bezpośrednio przed wykonaniem zabiegu przerywania nastroju rojowego

Combination Kombinacja Average strangth of colony Średnia siła rodziny Average area of worker bee brood Średnia powierzchnia czerwiu pszczelego Average area of drone brood Średnia powierzchnia czerwiu trutowego Average number of queen cups in total Średnia liczba miseczek ogółem Average number of sealed queen cups Średnia liczba miseczek zaczerwionych
I 15,11 b 33,24 b 3,27 b 8,89 a 5,56 a
II 13,78 b 31,72 b 2,67 ab 8,69 a 8,33 a
III 14,33 b 34,58 b 1,68 a 8,59 a 5,67 a
IV 13,79 b 33,63 b 2,83 ab 5,67 a 7,64 a
V 10,44 a 24,04 a 2,00 a 6,84 a 5,00 a

The numbers which have the same letters mean that they do not differ significantly. Cyfry przy których umieszczono te same litery nie różnią się między sobą w sposób istotny.

strona 89

Effectiveness and laboriousness of proposed methods for breaking a swarming mood in bee colonies. The research revealed that complete effectiveness of the applied operation was obtained using first tree methods (tab. 2).

Table 2

Effectiveness of the applied anti-swarming operations (1995 and 1996) Skuteczność stosowanych zabiegów przeciwrojowych (lata 1995 i 1996)

Combination. Kombinacja A number of colonies, in which the operation was applied / Liczba rodzin w których wykonano zabieg: (Apiary) (Pasieka) A … B … Total Ogółem A number of colonies, in which the operation turned out to be effective / Liczba rodzin w których zabieg okazał się skuteczny: (Apiary) (Pasieka) A … B … Total Ogółem Percentage of colonies in which the operation was effective Procent rodzin w których zabieg był skuteczny
I 7 2 9 7 2 9 100%
II 7 4 11 7 4 11 100%
III 6 2 8 6 2 8 100%
IV 3 4 7 2 1 3 43%
V 3 – 3 2 – 2 66%
Total Ogółem 26 12 38 24 9 33

It was shown that between methods: I, II, III, a significant difference in the laboriousness does not occur. However, the second method turned out to be more laborious than method IV and V (tab. 3).

Table 3

Estimation of laboriousness of comparable methods using in breaking a swarming mood. Ocena pracochłonności porównywanych metod stosowanych do przerywania nastroju rojowego.

Combination – Kombinacja: I II III IV V
Number of colonies, in which the operation was applied. Liczba rodzin w których prowadzono zabieg 9 11 7 3 2
Time required to apply the method (min / colony) Czas potrzebny na zastosowanie metody (min / rodzinę) 9,6 ab 15,3 b 10,3 ab 8,7 a 8,0 a

Productivity of bee colonies, in which a swarming mood was effectively broken. It was affirmed that essentially more honey was gained from colonies from combination I, II, III and IV than from colony from combination V. The differences between combinations I, II, III and IV in honey production were not proved.

strona 90

Datas presented in table 4 show that the average production of honey in bee colonies, which did not begin a swarming preparations is similar to the average production of colonies being in a swarming mood, which was effectively broken by methods from I to IV.

Table 4

The effect of a method of breaking a swarming mood on a productivity of bee colonies (colonies from both apiaries in 1995 and 1996) Metoda przerywania nastroju rojowego a produkcyjność rodzin pszczelich (lata 1995 i 1996 rodziny z obu pasiek)

Honey (kg/colony) – Miód (kg/rodz.)

Combination Kombinacja Number of colonies Liczba rodzin (n) kg
0 66 18,6 b
I 11 19,2 b
II 9 11,4 ab
III 8 19,0 b
IV 3 23,9 b
V 2 1,8 a

Pollen (kg/colony) – Pyłek (kg/rodz.)

0 47 1,3 a
I 10 1,09 a
II 7 0,77 a
III 8 0,51 a
IV 3 1,00 a
V 2 0,43 a

Foundation (number of sheets/colony) – Węza (liczba arkuszy/rodz.)

Combination Kombinacja Number of colonies Liczba rodzin (n) Number of added sheets of founda tion Liczba dodanych arkuszy węzy
0 72 7,00 a
I 10 6,10 a
II 9 6,33 a
III 8 7,12 a
IV 3 6,25 a
V 3 6,67 a

Zero combination – the colonies not being in a swarming mood Kombinacja 0 – rodziny nie wykazujące nastroju rojowego.

The connection between a method of breaking a swarming mood and an amount of pollen and between a number of foundation rebuilded by the colonies from comparable combinations during a production season was not found.

strona 91

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS

That research did not prove the opinion about usefulness of the method consisting in turning around all combs in the nest for 180 degrees after destroy of all sealed queen cups and queen cells (IV^th method) just to break a swarming mood in the bee colonies. In conditions of the presented experiment that method was effective only in 43% of all cases.

The operation consisting in spraying combs with a water suspension of melissa oil (V^th method) had a low effectiveness, too. However, in further research usefulness of that operation should be tested using suspensions with a higher concentration of melissa oil. The operation itself is a little laborious, easy to make and cheap. The influence of applying an oil on the productivity of colony still remains an open question because the obtained results do not authorize to a generalization for the sake of a small number of repetitions.

It seems that three proposed in present research methods, which in each case turned out to be effective deserve a special attention. It concerns I^st, II^nd and III^rd method. It seems that the common feature for these methods is a sudden separation of a significant amount of worker bees from a bee colony and a modification of their employment. The meaning of that kind of operation for breaking a mood in a bee colony was raised earlier (Muszyńska 1982). The described methods are not only effective but also easy to apply in apiary with storey hives, which do not require the additional equipment and do not decrease a production of honey, pollen and beeswax. Furthermore, they are a little laborious, considerably less than the method, which is proposed by Gubina (1982).

The I^st method is some kind of a modification of commonly applied method of breaking a swarming mood with a help from creatina nucleus with an old queen. However, the localization of a new colony in the same hive makes the second combination of the newcreated colonies simple. Thanks to it controlling the structure of a colony and creation such a structure, which is the most adjusted to current climate and conditions of flow do not encounter difficulties.

The II^nd and III^rd method are the result of the research presented in that publication. The II^nd consists in moving all combs with brood to the top storey, which was separated from the lower one by the queen excluder. In the lower storey, to which a foundation and empty combs were added to a queen is left. The top storeys in the III^rd method are tightly separated from the lower one and there are combs with a brood and a previous queen in them. In the lower storey there is one comb with an open brood and bees gathering it and also empty combs and a foundation. These methods like the 1st one help with changing the structure of a bee colony without using the additional equipment. However, it should be stressed that it is necessary to check their effectiveness by means of a significant number of repetition in different types of hives.

strona 92

REFERENCES

Crane E. (1965)- Beekeeping techniques. Recent research on swarm control. Bee Wld. 49(2):41-44

Delaplane K.S. (1992)- Swarm Control Without Increasing Colony Numbers. Am. Bee J., 132(3):146-147

Getz W.M., Bruckner D., Parisian T.R.(1982) Kin structure and swarming behavior of honey bee Apis mellifera. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 10:265-270

Gromisz M., Bownik K. (1969)- Warunki przyrodniczo-pożytkowe i osiagnięcia produkcyjne pasiek w Polsce w latach 1946- 1966. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 13(1-3):1-55

Gromisz M. (1975)- Rójka i wykorzystanie pszczoły rojowej w pasiekach polskich. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk.,19:131-150

Gubina T. (1982)- Sposob prekrasčenia rojenia. Pčelovodstvo, (3):30-31

Guderska J. (1956)- Przywracanie stanu roboczego w rodzinach przygotowujących się do rójki. Pszczelarstwo, 7(8):19

Marcinkowski J., Muszyńska J., Skubida P. (1998)- Poszukiwanie nowych cech wskazujących na potencjalne skłonności rodzin pszczelich do wejścia w nastrój rojowy. – Pszczln. Zesz. Nauk., 41:33-43

Muszyńska J. (1976)- Porównanie pszczół z roju i macierzaka. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 20:191-201

Muszyńska J. (1979)- Próba określenia składu rodziny pszczelej wchodzącej w nastrój rojowy i wydającej rój. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk. 23:209-226

Muszyńska J. (1982)- Poszukiwanie metod zapobiegania wychodzeniu rojów. Pszczelarstwo, (4):2-4

Naumann K., Laflamme P.H. (1993)- Honey Bee Oueen Mandibular Pheromone Does Not Increase Rate of Sugar Syrup and Pollen Supplement Uptake. Am. Bee J. 133(11):797-798

Selivanova N.M. (1981)- Feromony matki i rojenie. Pčelovodstvo (4-5):18-19

Selivanova N.M. (1983)- Podkormka pčel syropom s feromonami. Pčelovodstvo (6):10-18

Thrasyvou A.,Sakellari D.,Spatherki E.,Pimenidis G. (1992)- Depression of Swarming by Colony Inversion. Am. Bee J. 132(2):115-116

Winston M.L.,Higo H.A.,Slessor K.N. (1990)- Effect of Various Dosages of Queen Mandibular Gland Pheromone on the Inhibition of Queen rearing in the Honey Bee (Hymenoptera: Apidae) Ann.Entomol.Soc.Am. 83(2):234-238

strona 93

Winston M.L.,H.A.,Colley S.J.,Pankiw T. Slessor K.N.(1991) – The role of queen mandibular pheromone and colony congestion in honey bee (Apis mellifera L.) reproductive swarming (Hymenoptera: Apidae). J.Ins.Behav. 4(5):649-660

POSZUKIWANIE NOWYCH METOD PRZERYWANIA NASTROJU ROJOWEGO W PRODUKCYJNYCH RODZINACH PSZCZELICH

Jerzy Marcinkowski, Piotr Skubida, Janina Muszyńska

Streszczenie

Celem badań było opracowanie prostych i skutecznych metod przerywania nastroju rojowego. Metod, które nie prowadzą do obniżenia produkcyjności rodzin.

Badania prowadzono w latach 1995 i 1996 na ogólnej liczbie 118 rodzin pszczelich osadzonych w ulach wielkopolskich, z których 39 weszło w nastrój rojowy.

Dla przerwania nastroju rojowego w rodzinach pszczelich posługiwano się następującymi metodami:

Metoda I – polegała na utworzeniu w tym samym ulu, w górnym korpusie, odkładu ze starą matką (na tylny wylot). W rodzinie macierzystej pozostawiano mateczniki i większość czerwiu. Około 3-4 tygodnie po zabiegu odkład łączono ponownie z rodziną macierzystą.

Metoda II – polegała na przeniesieniu wszystkich plastrów z czerwiem do górnego korpusu, od dolnego oddzielonego kratą odgrodową. W korpusie dolnym, do którego dano węzę i susz pozostawiono matkę. Ta metoda przypomina zaproponowaną przez Delaplane (1992).

Metoda III – polegała na przeniesieniu do górnych korpusów wszystkich plastrów z czerwiem i obsiadającymi je pszczołami oraz z dotychczasową matką. W dolnym korpusie, który odizolowano całkowicie od górnych, pozostawiono jeden plaster z czerwiem otwartym, matecznikiem oraz obsiadającymi je pszczołami. Położenie dolnego wylotka nie uległo zmianie. Górny wylot został odwrócony o 180 stopni. Dzięki temu zabiegowi w dolnym korpusie przeprowadzono „nalot na matecznik”. Powtórne łączenie obu części rodziny następowało po 3-4 tygodniach.

Metoda IV – Polegała na przestawieniu plastrów w gnieździe o 180 stopni, po zniszczeniu wszystkich zaczerwionych miseczek matecznikowych. Tę metodę propaguje Thrasyvou i wsp. (1992)

Metoda V – polegała na opryskiwaniu plastrów w gnieździe wraz z obsiadającymi je pszczołami 0,2% wodną zawiesiną olejku melisowego, po zniszczeniu wszystkich mateczników oraz po poszerzeniu gniazda suszem.

Oceny przydatności opisanych metod do zwalczania nastroju rojowego w rodzinach pszczelich przeprowadzono na podstawie następujących kryteriów. 1) Skuteczność metody. 2) Wpływ zastosowanego wyniku na zabiegi produkcyjne rodzin pszczelich, porównano produkcyjność rodzin, które weszły w nastrój rojowy, a następnie nastrój ten został skutecznie przerwany za pomocą jednej z wyżej opisanych metod z produkcyjnością tych, w których w ogóle nastrój rojowy nie wystąpił. 3) Pracochłonność zabiegu.

strona 94

Wydaje się, że na szczególną uwagę zasługują zaproponowane w niniejszych badaniach metody I, II i III, które w każdym przypadku okazały się skuteczne (tab.2). Cechą wspólną dla tych metod jest gwałtowne wydzielanie z rodziny pszczelej znacznej liczby robotnic i zmodyfikowanie ich zatrudnienia. Znaczenie tego zabiegu dla przerwania nastroju rojowego w rodzinie pszczelej było podnoszone wcześniej (Muszyńska 1982). Te metody są nie tylko skuteczne ale także łatwe do wykonania w pasiece prowadzonej w ulach korpusowych (nie wymagają dodatkowego sprzętu i nie obniżają produkcji miodu, pyłku i wosku – tab. 4). Są ponadto mało pracochłonne, znacznie mniej niż metoda, którą proponuje Gubina (1982). Metoda I stanowi pewną modyfikację powszechnie stosowanej metody przerywania nastroju rojowego za pomocą tworzenia odkładów. Jednak lokalizacja odkładu w tym samym ulu, w którym znajduje się rodzina wykazująca nastrój rojowy czyni prostym powtórne łączenie nowoutworzonych rodzin. Metoda II i III stanowią wynik badań prezentowanych w niniejszej pracy. Obie, podobnie jak metoda I – pozwalają na dokonanie szybkiej zmiany w strukturze rodziny bez konieczności stosowania dodatkowego sprzętu.

Słowa kluczowe: nastrój rojowy, zabiegi przeciwrojowe, produkcyjność


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 85: „Reaserch” → Research
  • s. 87: „360 degrees” → 180 degrees
  • s. 87: „average valued” → average value
  • s. 88, tab. 1: „strangth” → strength
  • s. 89: „first tree methods” → first three methods
  • s. 91: „creatina” → creating a
  • s. 92, literatura: „osiagnięcia” → osiągnięcia
  • s. 92, literatura: „Pszczln.” → Pszczeln.
  • s. 92, literatura: „Oueen” → Queen
  • s. 93, literatura: „Winston M.L.,H.A.,” → Winston M.L.,Higo H.A.,

Podobne wpisy