SEARCHING FOR THE NEW FEATURES POINTING AT POTENTIAL PENCHANTS OF BEE COLONIES FOR PUTTING IN A SWARMING MOOD

tekst: Jerzy Marcinkowski, Janina Muszyńska, Piotr Skubida

Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XLII, 1998 — Jerzy Marcinkowski, Janina Muszyńska, Piotr Skubida

strona 75

PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XLII, Nr 1 1998

Jerzy Marcinkowski, Janina Muszyńska, Piotr Skubida

Reaserch Institute of Pomology and Floriculture, Apiculture Division, Kazimierska 2 Str., 24-100 Puławy, POLAND, e-mail: opisik@man.pulawy

Summary

Research, which took place in the year 1995 and 1996, was being conducted on 118 bee colonies (placed in hives called wielkopolski). 39 of them began swarming preparations.

The purpose of research was searching for the features, that in the beginning of production season differentiate those colonies, which later on put in a swarming mood, from colonies that do not reveal this kind of a mood for the whole season.

The obtained results indicate that those colonies, which in the beginning of production season are characterized by significant strength and penchant for breeding a great number of brood, put in a swarming mood. In comparison with control colonies, it was also affirmed that in such colonies there is essentially bigger number of queen cell cups and correlation between the area of drone brood and a number of queen cell cups.

Keywords: swarming mood, penchant for a swarm, coefficients

INTRODUCTION

In the temperate climate swarms occur within whole apiarian season, however, they maximalize in the end of May and June (Fell et al.). In Poland first swarms take place about 29 days after winter rape starts to bloom (Gromisz 1975).

The appearance of sealed queen cups and their breeding by bees are taken as a first sign of a swarming mood. A swarming mood ends along with giving out a swarm. However, there are cases when bee colonies stops rearing queens and there is no swarming. The reasons for which it happens are still not explained, however, it can undoubtedly be after a sudden appearance of a flow or a strong disturbance with poison of worker bees (Muszyńska 1982). It is not a rarity that a swarming mood lasts till first queen starts to emerge, however, it is not a swarm but only supersedure of queen.

strona 76

During the pre-swarming periods, apart from a persistent rearing queens also a significant limitation of flights’ intensity and a decrease of penchant for building combs and rearing brood is a typical feature for bee colonies (Severson 1984). During 10 days prior to swarming the worker bees tend to engorge with honey (Combs 1972). Differences between an amount of hormone in mandibular glands of worker bees from colonies with a swarming mood and those under control were not shown (Seeley, Fell 1981).

There are some theories concerning a initiation of the swarming processes in bee colonies. Severson talks it over (1984). The crowding of bees in a brood nest (Napier 1973, Simpson 1966) and on combs with brood (Lensky, Seifert 1981) and also an intensity of replacement of bees being a winter generation by bees being a summer generation are also taken as a crucial factor for arising a swarming mood (Muszyńska 1979). The meaning of food abundance and type of flow which occurs in the early spring and its influence on the structure of bee colony during that time, is often taken into consideration (Gromisz 1975; Muszyńska 1979; Lee Winston 1987; Thoenes et al. 1991). Some other circumstances, that are conducive to make such processes, are furthermore mentioned. A genetic factor for bees’ penchant for putting in a swarming mood (Woyciechowski 1992; Getz et al., 1982) and also a connection between an age of a queen and a swarming is emphasised as well (Hauser, Lensky 1994; Simpson 1966, Muszyńska 1979). Nowadays it is admitted that the direct reason why bee colonies begin a swarming preparations is a decrease of queen substance, which appears in them. It means a decrease, which rather results from disturbance of an exchange of queen substance between worker bees, than from an actual decrease (Morse, Boch 1971; Baird, Seeley 1983; Seeley, Fell 1981).

It should be expected that early detected changes in a bee colony, which can lead to uprising of a swarming mood in it, can help with effective prevention of a swarming.

The purpose of present research was searching for the features, which differentiate colonies starting swarming preparation from those that do not reveal this kind of a mood at all. The features, which differentiate those two groups of colonies already in the beginning of productive season, still before and just after appearing sealed queen cells in them, were searched for.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Research, which took place in the year 1995 and 1996, was being conducted at the apiary of Division of Apiculture Institute of Pomology and Floriculture. During that research experimental colonies, which were placed in

strona 77

hives called „wielkopolski”, stood in two places significantly differing from each other.

The place called „A” was exposed and characterized by mid-early flow (acacia, lime). The place called „B”, situated in mixed woods with advantage of hornbeam trees, was shadowy and not very warm. It was characterized by late flow (lime, ruderal plants). In both years of research, all colonies had maited queens – the carniolan race in place A and the caucasian race in place B.

In the year 1995 in place A, the apiary numbered 37 bee colonies, and in the year 1996 – 34.

In the year 1995 in place B, the apiary numbered 26 bee colonies, and in the year 1996 – 21.

In both years and in both place, colonies were conducted in the same way, applying the method of moderate extension of nests and keeping in colonies a state of congestion till first covered queen cell appeared. Each year in the spring, after elimination of colonies, which during the winter lost their queens and after compensation of strength of those which lasted the winter, a detailed inspections of both experiment apiaries were started. In 1995 the first inspection was made on May 5^th (apiary A) and May 8^th (apiary B), in 1996 appropriately May 8^th and 9^th. Next inspections were made at 10-day intervals, till mid-July.

In both years and in both apiaries in three set dates of May, in all colonies the following features were estimated:

a) A total area of worker bee brood – dm^2,

b) A total area of drone brood – dm^2,

c) A free space on combs with brood – dm^2,

d) A total number of constructed queen cups,

e) A total number of sealed queen cups,

f) A strength of colonies – expressed by the number of combs.

The methods of measurement of worker bee brood’s area, drone brood and a free space on combs with brood was described by Gromisz et al. (1978). The number of empty queen cups and those which were sealed was counted separately. A strength of a colony was determined on the basis of number of combs covered by bees.

In both years of research after finishing an apiarian season, two groups of results were specified. These are the findings, which were gained for colonies of control group not being in a swarming mood and findings gained for colonies that revealed a swarming mood.

For each of the studied features, datas concerning colonies belonging to the determined group and obtained in consecutive terms of research were added and than an average value of coefficient, characterizing each feature with reference to one term and bee colony, was obtained.

strona 78

Values obtained in this way were statistically calculated using an analysis of variance method and an estimation of difference of significance was made using the Duncan Test. For estimation of correlation between examined features a multiple regression method was used and for estimation of significance of correlation coefficient it was an analysis of variance in regression method. All calculations were made at significance level = 0.05.

RESULTS

The characterization of conditions during experiment.

In apiary B, consecutive years of research differed from each other with regard to penchant of bee colonies for putting in a swarming mood. With reference to the apiary A, such penchant was not affirmed. (tab. 1)

Table 1

The characterization of conditions in consecutive years of research (Charakterystyka warunków doświadczenia w kolejnych latach badań)

Year of research
Rok badań
Place
Stanowisko
Total
Ogólna
Which began a swarming preperations
Które weszły w nastrój rojowy
Colonies, which began a swarming preperations (%)
Rodziny które weszły w nastrój rojowy (%)
1995 A 37 14 38
1995 B 26 11 42
1996 A 34 13 38
1996 B 21 1 5
Total (Ogółem) 118 39 33

The comparison of indexes set for colonies, which put in a swarming mood to those, which kept a working mood.

The table presents values of estimated indexes characterizing colonies which belong to comparable groups – control and swarming.

Presented above results show that those colonies put in a swarming mood, which in the beginning of productive season are characterized by essentially bigger strength and tendency to breed greater amount of brood and drone brood. It was also affirmed that in comparison with control colonies, colonies which put in a swarming mood have statistically confirmed greater amount of sealed queen cell cups (tab. 2).

strona 79

Table 2

Coefficients characterizing colonies from comparable groups – Wskaźniki charakteryzujące rodziny z porównywalnych grup

Place
Stanowisko
Year of research
Rok badań
Group of colonies
Grupa rodzin
Number of colonies
Liczba rodzin
Strength of colony (a number of combs)
Siła rodziny (liczba plastrów)
Worker bee brood
Czerw pszczeli
Drone brood
Czerw trutowy
Free spaces (on combs with worker bee brood)
Wolne przestrzenie (na plastrach z czerwiem pszczelim)
Total
Ogółem
Sealed
Zaczerwione
A 1995 Control (Kontrolne) 23 10,96 26,41 2,32 6,37 7,48 0
A 1995 Swarming (Rojowe) 14 13,18 30,71 2,86 9,60 6,90 1,47
A 1996 Control (Kontrolne) 21 11,76 23,6 0,74 11,96 3,11 0,30
A 1996 Swarming (Rojowe) 13 13,48 29,05 1,16 12,56 2,27 0,73
Average value for both years together (Średnia dla dwóch lat łącznie) Control (Kontrolne) 44 11,33 a 25,15 a 1,65 a 8,98 a 4,70 a 0,15 a
Average value for both years together (Średnia dla dwóch lat łącznie) Swarming (Rojowe) 27 13,01 b 29,35 b 2,01 b 11,57 a 5,35 a 0,61 b
B 1995 Control (Kontrolne) 15 13,81 33,03 3,2 10,44 3,67 0,12
B 1995 Swarming (Rojowe) 11 14,76 33,13 3,59 13,67 7,17 1,33
B 1996 Control (Kontrolne) 20 11,27 20,42 0,51 19,24 1,22 0
B 1996 Swarming (Rojowe) 1 12,67 32,83 2,42 13,83 3,33 1,0
Average value for both years together (Średnia dla dwóch lat łącznie) Control (Kontrolne) 35 12,37 a 25,82 a 1,58 a 15,46 a 2,39 a 0,6 a
Average value for both years together (Średnia dla dwóch lat łącznie) Swarming (Rojowe) 12 14,58 b 33,11 b 3,49 b 13,69 a 6,83 b 1,27 b

The mumbers which have the same letters mean that they do not differ significantly – Wartości przy których są te same litery nie różnią się od siebie istotnie

strona 80

Estimation of relation between examined coefficients in colonies from the control group and the swarming one. Estimation of relation between examined indexes was made in the following combinations:

between X~1 (area of worker bee brood) and: X~2 (area of drone brood); X3 (area of free space); X~4 (total number of queen cups); X~6 (strength of bee colony);

between X~2 (area of drone brood) and: X~3 (area of free space); X~4 (total amount of queen cups); X~5 (number of sealed queen cups); X~6 (strength of bee colony);

between X~3 (area of free space) and: X~4 (total amount of queen cups); X~5 (number of sealed queen cups); X~6 (strength of bee colony);

between X~4 (total amount of queen cups) and: X~5 (number of sealed queen cups); X~6 (strength of bee colony);

between X~5 (number of sealed queen cups) and X~6 (strength of bee colony).

The following correlation between features for colonies from both group was not affirmed: X~1 and X~3; X~2 and X~3; X~2 and X~4; X~3 and X~4; X~4 and X~5; X~3 and X~6.

Crucial connections between the following coefficients were affirmed: X~4 and X~5; X~5 and X~6. Yet they are in a strict connection with a year of doing research. Therefore, these are not relations, which should be treated as good indication of changes occuring in bee colonies as they develop. However, it seems that as good expression of those changes should be taken those correlations, which turned out to be crucial in most terms for colonies of both groups. It concerns the correlation between an area of brood (X~1) and a total amount of queen cell cups (X~4) and a strength of bee colony (X~6) and also between an area of drone brood (X~2) and a strength of colony (X~6) and also between a total amount of queen cell cups (X~4) and a strength of colony (tab. 3).

Datas from table number 4 suggest, that in the beginning of productive season (it is in May) in colonies willing to put in a swarming mood, there is a correlation between an area of drone brood and a total amount of queen cell cups. In control colonies such a correlation did not become the rule.

It seems that during searching for the features distinguishing bee colonies willing to put in a swarming mood from those being in a working mood for the whole season, this correlation should be paid attention to.

strona 81

Table 3

A coefficient of correlation and determination between those features, which characterize comparable groups of bee colonies (Współczynnik korelacji i determinacji pomiędzy cechami charakteryzującymi porównywane grupy rodzin pszczelich)

Correlation
Korelacja
Place
Stanowisko
Year
Rok
Correlation coefficient
Współczynnik korelacji
Determination coefficient
Współczynnik determinacji
X~1 and X~2 Control A 1995 0.0865 0.75
X~1 and X~2 Control A 1996 0.6373xx 40.62
X~1 and X~2 Control B 1995 0.5714xx 32.65
X~1 and X~2 Control B 1996 0.4204xx 17.67
X~1 and X~2 Swarming A 1995 0.2006 6.79
X~1 and X~2 Swarming A 1996 0.5337xx 28.48
X~1 and X~2 Swarming B 1995 0.4778xx 22.83
X~1 and X~4 Control A 1995 0.4710xx 22.19
X~1 and X~4 Control A 1996 0.7118xx 50.67
X~1 and X~4 Control B 1995 -0.0175 0.03
X~1 and X~4 Control B 1996 0.3915xx 15.33
X~1 and X~4 Swarming A 1995 0.6141xx 37.71
X~1 and X~4 Swarming A 1996 0.4865xx 23.66
X~1 and X~4 Swarming B 1995 0.0166 0.03
X~1 and X~6 Control A 1995 0.7375xx 54.41
X~1 and X~6 Control A 1996 0.8275xx 68.48
X~1 and X~6 Control B 1995 0.6138xx 37.68
X~1 and X~6 Control B 1996 0.7369xx 54.31
X~1 and X~6 Swarming A 1995 0.6208xx 38.54
X~1 and X~6 Swarming A 1996 0.6965xx 48.51
X~1 and X~6 Swarming B 1995 0.2314 5.35
X~2 and X~6 Control A 1995 0.4556xx 20.76
X~2 and X~6 Control A 1996 0.6180xx 38.19
X~2 and X~6 Control B 1995 0.3858xx 14.88
X~2 and X~6 Control B 1996 0.5689xx 32.36
X~2 and X~6 Swarming A 1995 0.3635x 13.21
X~2 and X~6 Swarming A 1996 0.6997x 36.09
X~2 and X~6 Swarming B 1995 0.3862x 14.91
X~4 and X~6 Control A 1995 0.6205xx 38.51
X~4 and X~6 Control A 1996 0.6672xx 44.52
X~4 and X~6 Control B 1995 0.2315 5.36
X~4 and X~6 Control B 1996 0.3267x 10.67
X~4 and X~6 Swarming A 1995 0.5608xx 31.45
X~4 and X~6 Swarming A 1996 0.5348xx 28.60
X~4 and X~6 Swarming B 1995 0.5448xx 29.69

X – significant differences at level = 0.05 – różnica istotna przy poziomie p = 0.05 XX – significant differences at level = 0.01 – różnica istotna przy poziomie p = 0.01

strona 82

Table 4

A coefficient of correlation and determination between those features, which differ comparable groups of bee colonies Współczynnik korelacji i determinacji pomiędzy cechami różnicującymi porównywane grupy rodzin

Correlation
Korelacja
Place
Stanowisko
Year
Rok
Correlation coefficient
Współczynnik korelacji
Determination coefficient
Współczynnik determinacji
X~1 and X~4 Control A 1995 0.3905xx 15.25
X~1 and X~4 Control A 1996 0.7263xx 52.75
X~1 and X~4 Control B 1995 0.2355 5.55
X~1 and X~4 Control B 1996 0.2509 6.30
X~1 and X~4 Swarming A 1995 0.3612x 13.04
X~1 and X~4 Swarming A 1996 0.4714xx 22.22
X~1 and X~4 Swarming B 1995 0.4478xx 20.06
X~1 and X~4 Swarming B – – –

X – significant differences at level = 0.05 – różnica istotna przy poziomie p = 0.05 XX – significant differences at level = 0.01 – różnica istotna przy poziomie p = 0.01

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS

Searching for the features distinguishing bee colonies willing to put in a swarming mood from those, which do not do that resulted in a practical conclusion. Colonies potentially willing to put in a swarming mood are characterized by a significantly strength, a significantly amount of worker bee and drone brood and also significantly tendency to build queen cups. A simultaneousness of appearance of these features deserves a special attention, which has not been emphasized so far. Moreover, a strict connection between an amount of drone brood and a number of queen cups, which seems to be one of the earliest signs of a pre-swarming mood, requires an emphasis. Therefore, it seems that strong colonies, which in the first weeks of apiary season breed a significant amount of drone brood in which queen cell cups appear, should be under special control. In this case, the appearance of a swarming mood and a swarming is most likely in them.

REFERENCES

Baird D.H., Seeley T.D. (1983)- An equlibrium theory of queen production in honeybee colonies preparing to swarm. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 13:221-228

strona 83

Combs G.F. (1972)- The engorgement of swarming worker honeybees. J. apic. Res. 11(3):121-128

Fell R.D. Ambrose J.T., Burgett D.M., De Jong D., Morse R.A., Seeley T.D. (1977)- The seasonal cycle of swarming in honeybees. *J. apic .Res.*16(4):170-173

Getz W.M., Bruckner D., Parisian T.R. (1982)- Kin structure and swarming behavior of honey bee Apis mellifera. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 10:265-270

Gromisz M (1975)- Rójka i wykorzystanie pszczoły rojowej w pasiekach polskich. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk., 19:131-150

Gromisz M., Bornus L., Bobrzecki J., Cieśla L., Kaczmarek S., Kalinowski J., Król A., Nowakowski J., Woźnica J., Zaremba J. (1978) -Produktywność mieszańców międzyliniowych pszczoły miodnej w różnych regionach Polski. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk. 22:3-19

Hauser H., Lensky Y. (1994)- The effect of the age of the honey bee (Apis mellifera L) queen on worker population, swarming and honey yields in a subtropical climate. Apidologie. 25:566-578

Lee P.C., Winston M.L. (1987)- Effects of reproductive timing and colony size on the survival, offspring colony size and drone production in the honey bee (Apis mellifera). Ecol. Entomol. 12:187-195

Lensky Y., Seifert H. (1981)- The effect of volume ventilation and overheating of bee colonies on the construction of swarming queen cups and cells Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 67A:97-101

Morse R.A., Boch R. (1971)- Pheromone Concert in Swarming Honey Bees (Hymenoptera:Apidae) Annal. Entomol. Soc. Am. 64(6):1414- 1417

Muszyńska J.(1979)- Próba określenia składu rodziny pszczelej wchodzącej w nastrój rojowy i wydającej rój. Pszczeln. Zesz. Nauk. 23:109-226

Muszyńska J. (1982)- Poszukiwanie metod zapobiegania wychodzeniu rojów. Pszczelarstwo, (4):2-4

Napier J. (1973)- Boost strength colony and cut down on swarming. Am. Bee J. 113(2):56-57

Seeley T.D., Fell R.D. (1981)- Queen substace production in honey bee (Apis mellifera) colonies preparing to swarm (Hymenoptera: Apidae). J. Kansas Ent. Soc. 54(1):192-196

Severson D.W. (1984) Swarming Behaviour of the honey Bee. Am. Bee J. 123(3):204-210;230-232

Simpson J. (1966)- Congestion of adult honeybees with and without adequate hive space. J. apic. Res. 5(1):59-61

Thoenes S.C., Schmidt J.O., Buchmann S.L. (1991)- How diet affects honey bee reproductive swarming. Am. Bee J. 131(12):784

Woyciechowski M. (1990)- Do Honey Bee, Apis mellifera L., Workers Favour Sibling Eggs and Larvae in Queen Rearing? Anim.Behav. 39(10):52-53

strona 84

POSZUKIWANIE NOWYCH CECH WSKAZUJĄCYCH NA POTENCJALNE SKŁONNOŚCI RODZIN PSZCZELICH DO WEJŚCIA W NASTRÓJ ROJOWY

Marcinkowski J., Muszyńska J., Skubida P.

Streszczenie

Celem badań było poszukiwanie cech, które w początku sezonu produkcyjnego wyróżniają rodziny wchodzące w późniejszym okresie w nastrój rojowy od rodzin nie wskazujących tego nastroju przez cały sezon.

Badania prowadzono w latach 1995 i 1996 na ogólnej liczbie 118 rodzin pszczelich (osadzonych w ulach wielkopolskich) z których 39 weszło w nastrój rojowy.

W pasiekach doświadczalnych, w obu latach, w trzech terminach maja, we wszystkich rodzinach oceniano następujące cechy:

a) Ogólną powierzchnię czerwiu pszczelego – dm^2

b) Ogólną powierzchnię czerwiu trutowego – dm^2

c) Powierzchnię wolną na plastrach z czerwiem pszczelim dm^2

d) Ogólną liczbę odbudowanych miseczek matecznikowych

e) Ogólną liczbę miseczek zaczerwionych i z larwami w różnych stadiach rozwoju

f) Siłę rodzin

Pomiary powierzchni: czerwiu pszczelego, czerwiu trutowego i powierzchni wolnej na plastrach z czerwiem pszczelim dokonywano w sposób opisany przez Gromisza i wsp.(1978). Miseczki matecznikowe liczono zaznaczając oddzielnie liczbę miseczek pustych i zaczerwionych. Siłę rodziny określono na podstawie liczby plastrów obsiadanych przez pszczoły.

Dla opracowania uzyskanych wyników, w obu latach badań, po zakończeniu sezonu pszczelarskiego, wyodrębniono dwie grupy danych. Dane uzyskane w rodzinach, które nie weszły w nastrój rojowy (grupa kontrolna) oraz uzyskane w rodzinach wykazujących nastrój rojowy (grupa rojowa).

Dla każdej z badanych cech, dane dotyczące rodzin zaliczanych do określonej grupy uzyskane w kolejnych terminach badań sumowano, a następnie wyliczano średnią wartość wskaźnika charakteryzującego tą cechę w odniesieniu do jednego terminu i jednej rodziny pszczelej.

Tak uzyskane wartości opracowano statystycznie metodą analizy wariancji, a ocenę istotności różnic przeprowadzono posługując się testem Duncana. Dla oceny korelacji między badanymi cechami posłużono się metodą regresji wielokrotnej, a dla oceny istotności współczynnika korelacji metodą analizy wariancji w regresji. Wszystkie analizy wykonano przy poziomie istotności = 0,05.

Przeprowadzone badania doprowadziły do istotnego wniosku. Dla rodzin potencjalnie skłonnych do wejścia w nastrój rojowy charakterystyczne są w pierwszych tygodniach sezonu produkcyjnego następujące cechy: znaczna siła, znaczna ilość czerwiu pszczelego i trutowego, a także znaczna skłonność do budowy miseczek matecznikowych. Na szczególną uwagę zasługuje przy tym równoczesność wystąpienia wymienionych cech, co nie było dotychczas podkreślane. Zaakcentowania wymaga też ścisły związek między ilością czerwiu trutowego a liczbą miseczek matecznikowych, których obecność uważana jest za jeden z najbardziej początkowych objawów nastroju rojowego. Wydaje się, że w rodzinach silnych, wychowujących wiosną znaczne ilości czerwiu trutowego, w których licznie pojawiają się miseczki matecznikowe, należy spodziewać się w późniejszym okresie sezonu pszczelarskiego wystąpienia nastroju rojowego.

Słowa kluczowe: nastrój rojowy, skłonność do rójki, wskaźniki.


Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji

  • s. 75: „Reaserch” → Research
  • s. 77: „maited” → mated
  • s. 77: „and than an average” → and then an average
  • s. 78, tab. 1, 2×: „preperations” → preparations
  • s. 79, tab. 2: „mumbers” → numbers
  • s. 80: „occuring” → occurring
  • s. 82, literatura: „equlibrium” → equilibrium
  • s. 83, literatura: „substace” → substance

Podobne wpisy