AN ATTEMPT AT THE LABORATORY TESTING OF HONEY PRODUCTIVITY
tekst: Ladislav Kepeňa
Pszczelnicze Zeszyty Naukowe, Rok XXIX, 1985 — Ladislav Kepeňa
strona 103PSZCZELNICZE ZESZYTY NAUKOWE Rok XXIX 1985
Ing. Ladislav Kepeňa, CSc.
Bee Research Institute Liptovský Hrádok, Czechoslovakia
The most significant criterion of the efficiency of bee colonies is honey yield which, however, depends on a number of external and internal factors. Without flow sources, or without favourable weather in the flow season, even the colonies with the best gene poll fail to bring nectar to the hive. A bee-keeper is able, to some extent, to control mainly some external factors and to secure higher honey yields in this way. Colonies of — at first sight — about the same strength often happen to produce very different honey yields under the same conditions. Research efforts are focused on finding the factors underlying the efficiency of colonies.
A stimulus to this study was provided by a trial conducted by Kulinčevič et al. (1974) who had found a correlation between syrup intake under laboratory conditions and the honey yield of colonies obtained under natural flow conditions. The problem of the laboratory testing of colonies in relation to colony productivity was studied also by other authors (Milne Ch. 1977, 1980, Free 1980, 1982, Eischen et al. 1983).
MATERIAL AND METHODS
1. A FORTY-EIGHT-HOUR LABORATORY TRIAL OF SYRUP GATHERING
Bees were prepared for the laboratory tests in two ways: a) Combs with sealed brood were left to hatch in the incubator, a temperature-controlled oven. In this way, bees of known age were obtained from each colony tested. Until the sixth day of life the house bees were left to „ripen” in the temperature-controlled oven and were given pollen and syrup ad libitum. Then groups of 70 six-day-old bees were placed in wooden laboratory cages 165×85×55 mm in size. A numerated comb section, light brown in colour, was placed in each cage. The dimensions
strona 104of these comb sections were 50×50 mm; before use, each of them was exactly weighed. A soaking feeder with 1 : 1 sugar syrup was laid on the ceiling of each cage. In the oven, at the incubator temperature of 34°C and for 48 hours, the bees consumed syrup and stored it in comb cells. The difference in comb weight before the onset and after the termination of the laboratory test indicated how hard the bees worked to build their food stores.
b) The other way of preparing the bees was to fill the cages with house bees directly from the colony. Having examined the colony we chose a comb with compact older and open brood. The comb was hanged on a stand to let the foragers leave; then we could catch the nurse bees and place them — again in groups of 70 — in laboratory cages. After the termination of the 48-hour trial the bees in the cages were always killed to check the number of bees in each cage again. When a difference was found, the given cage was eliminated from the trials.
Line colonies of the Carniolan breed (Apis mellifica carnica Pollm.) with inseminated queens were used for the trials.
2. BEE NUTRITION IN THE LARVAL PERIOD AND LABORATORY TESTS
The bee queen was released on a comb in an isolator. Twelve hours after oviposition the queen was removed from the isolator. The eighth day from comb filling with eggs when comb cells were occupied by five days old larvae, a comb section 150×150 mm in size was cut from the comb. This section, free from bees, was placed in the incubator a temperature-controlled oven (34°C, relative humidity 90%). The larvae in the oven were left to starve for 8 hours. Then the comb section was pushed back into the comb. The 20th day from oviposition, the comb section was taken out again to be placed in an isolator net and, together with the net, in a temperature-controlled oven. The same was done with an adjacent part of brood which had been fed and nursed without interruption throughout larval development. The hatched bees were left in both isolators, kept in the temperature-controlled oven, for 5 days. Honey and pollen in small combs obtained from heavily stocked mating hives were used as food. The six days old bees were transferred to laboratory cages and were subjected to a 48-hour laboratory test for syrup storage.
RESULTS
1. THE 48-HOUR LABORATORY TEST FOR SYRUP GATHERING
In 1977, preliminary trials were performed according to the procedure described by J. Kulinčevič. Groups of 50 hatched bees were placed in our laboratory cages. Food intake was observed and recorded.
strona 105During the first days of life the bees do not take in the syrup very intensively and do not deposit it in the cells at all. Therefore we decided to investigate food intake by the bees in the age interval from 3 to 20 days. In this period, the average daily syrup intake per bee was 0.035—0.092 ccm. A higher intake started from the 6th day of life. The fact that no correlation was found between the results of food intake and honey yields under natural conditions is ascribed to the low number of colonies (7) involved in the trial.
Then we studied syrup intake by bees above 25 days of age (25—39 days). The old bees had a much lower syrup intake under laboratory conditions. The average daily syrup intake per bee was 0.022—0.041 ccm.
Trials were also performed to see what was the optimum number of bees to be kept in our laboratory cages. When the cage held only 30 bees, the cell-filling activity of the bees was low, reluctant. No greater improvement was observed when 50 bees were kept in a cage. However, when then number of bees was increased to 75, the bees immediately started to fill the comb cells with syrup. A hundred bees is too high a number and the cages are overfilled. The bees were observed to be very nervous, even panic-stricken. We tried to add to the cages a tampon with an alcohol extract of macerated heads of bee queens. However, the bees did not improve their working activity in the cages.
The preliminary trials (1977) followed the procedure described by Kulinčevič. In another study we aimed at determining the amount of syrup deposited in comb cells within a given period of time without being too much concerned about the amount of syrup taken from the feeder. Some 70-bee samples were found to be able to almost completely fill a 50×50 cm comb section on both sides within 48 hours. The filling of the cages with bees was also different from the previous trial: we caught the young-looking bees directly in the hive on a comb with opened older brood. (We assumed, as generally recognized for a long time, that 5—12 days old nurse bees could be found there).
In 1978 the trials involved four colonies of each of six different lines of the Carniolan bee created through insemination in the preceding years. The result of the tests is shown in Table 1.
Although different lines gathered different amounts of syrup, varian-
Table 1 48-hour laboratory test (year 1978)
| Bee line | No of colonies | Average amount of stored syrup (g) (x̄ ± s_x̄) | Reducing sugars in radom samples (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| ČA | 4 | 7.0425±2.7310 | 37.6 |
| SA | 4 | 10.3503±3.6371 | 37.5 |
| SE | 4 | 11.0023±2.5087 | 44.1 |
| TA | 4 | 11.6449±2.6907 | 46.3 |
| JU | 4 | 13.4161±3.0802 | 44.4 |
| VU | 4 | 16.8893±1.7899 | not determined |
ce analysis did not confirm a difference in the amount of stored syrup between different bee lines in the laboratory test (F=1,230; F0.05=2.77).
The percentage of reducing sugars was tentatively investigated in the syrup stored by the bees. Where the bees gathered the syrup less intensively (ČA line), the percentage of reducing sugars was also lower and vice versa, where the bees deposited more syrup in the cells (where they worked harder) the percentage of reducing sugars was higher (e.g. JU line).
The year 1978 was bad for honey flow, hence we were not able to compare the results of laboratory trials with flow results.
Four lines, each represented by six colonies, were subjected to trials in 1979. Again, the cages were filled with bees caught directly on combs with open brood. Variance analysis for the amount of stored reserves under laboratory conditions suggested that the difference between the lines was highly significant: F=5.835, F0.01=4.68 (Table 2).
Table 2 48-hour laboratory test (year 1979)
| Bee line | No of colonies | Amount of stored syrup (g) (x̄ ± s_x̄) | Reducing sugars in stores (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| SE | 6 | 10.7950±1.5318 | 49.20±1.94 |
| SA | 6 | 11.8644±1.8584 | 50.61±1.52 |
| JU | 6 | 16.79 ±1.2255 | 50.60±2.35 |
| TA | 6 | 18.05 ±1.2319 | 51.59±1.63 |
Reducing sugars in stored reserves were measured in all samples. Preceding year’s assumption of a positive correlation between stored reserves under laboratory conditions and reducing sugars (%) in these reserves was confirmed (r=+0.484, p0.05=0.45).
Again, owing to bad flow conditions we were unable to compare the relation between laboratory stores and the honey yields of colonies under natural conditions.
Twenty-two colonies were tested in 1980. The laboratory cages were filled with bees hatched from the brood combs in the incubator temperature-controlled oven. The hatching time was the first decade of May. The sixth day of life they were placed in laboratory cages to be tested like in the preceding years (Table 3).
In the amount of stored syrup the difference between the lines was almost at the 5% confidence level: F=2.427, F0.05=2.66.
The flow conditions were good, allowing for a comparison of the results of laboratory tests with the honey yields of the colonies under natural conditions. A correlation was demonstrated, as r=+0.675, P0.01=0.536.
The amounts of sirup stored in the comb sections during the 48-hour test were much lower in some bee samples (e.g. ČA, VU lines), as com-
strona 107Table 3 48-hour laboratory test (1980)
| Bee line | No of colonies | Amount of stored syrup (g) |
|---|---|---|
| ČA | 3 | 2.4766±0.2062 |
| VU | 3 | 2.7333±0.2698 |
| JU | 4 | 5.8525±0.7735 |
| SE | 4 | 6.2375±0.9159 |
| SA | 4 | 7.9600±1.8165 |
| TA | 4 | 8.4275±2.1724 |
pared with the preceding years (Table 3). It can be assumed that the bees used for laboratory testing came from colonies in which nutrition was not good.
The last trial was performed in 1982. Twenty-eight colonies were subjected to laboratory trials, irrespective of their origin. The cages were filled with bees caught from combs with open brood. The average amount of stored syrup in laboratory cages was 14.09 ± 0.76, i.e. about the same as in 1978, 1979. The amount of syrup stored under laboratory conditions was correlated with the honey yields of colonies under field conditions: r=+0.377, P0.05=0.349.
2. BEE NUTRITION IN LARVAL PERIOD AND THE LABORATORY TESTS
The lower amounts of syrup stores gathered under laboratory conditions in the 1980 trials served as a stimulus for trials to find the reason. The bees used in these trials were hatched in the first half of May when the nutrition conditions in the colony were not optimum for the larvae; thus individuals of weaker constitution and poorer physiological characteristics might develop. This was confirmed by a special trial. The bees prepared for the laboratory test were left to starve 8 hours in the period of the 5th day of larval development. Bees continuously nursed and fed served as a control group, as described in the recommended procedure. Several larvae fell out of the cells and died (about ten) when left to starve for 8 hours. Some of the larvae were found to be half-way out of the cells after 8-hour starvation; we assumed that if they were left to starve longer they would also have left the cells and died. When the comb section with the brood was returned to the colony, the bees immediately started nursing the brood again. The bees hatched from the brood appeared to be normal. These trials were performed repeatedly in 1982 and 1984.
The results of laboratory tests with 9 replicas indicated that the bees whose nutrition was disturbed by starvation in the larval period were able to store only 1.584 ± 0.195 g of syrup during the 48-hour laboratory trial, whereas the bees normally fed throughout their larval life filled
strona 108Table 4
| Test No. | Larval nutrition: disturbed by starvation — Amount of syrup stored (g) | Larval nutrition: undisturbed — Amount of syrup stored (g) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.2669 | 9.1147 |
| 2 | 2.3061 | 6.2363 |
| 3 | 0.5955 | 2.9630 |
| 4 | 1.2783 | 6.3521 |
| 5 | 2.0451 | 8.4257 |
| 6 | 2.1862 | 8.0325 |
| 7 | 1.8745 | 9.2432 |
| 8 | 0.9634 | 5.7420 |
| 9 | 1.7453 | 9.8776 |
| 1.5845±0.1959 | 7.3318±0.7338 | |
| t = 8.027 < P0.01 |
comb cells with almost five times more syrup (7.331 ± 0.733 g). The difference between the groups is highly significant (t=8.027; P0.01).
During the ontogenesis of bees, nutrition plays an important role and exerts a positive influence on the size of bees’ body parts (Kresák 1974); it can also be considered as a criterion underlying the physiological activity of bees. This aspect should also be considered during the laboratory testing of bees for the evaluation of their activity in store gathering.
DISCUSSION
Although the procedure of our trials was different, our results correspond with those published by Kulinčevič J. (1974): in two years (1980, 1982) we found (like Kulinčevič) a positive correlation between the amount of syrup stores in laboratory test and the honey yields under natural conditions. We assume that the laboratory test can be used in certain circumstances for the evaluation of the performance of thoroughbred lines, although we obtained positive results in this direction only sporadically. Brückner D. (1980), using the Kulinčevič procedure in laboratory tests with 9 inbred colonies and 11 hybrid colonies, found a statistically significant difference in sugar syrup intake in favour of the hybrid colonies.
The procedure used in our trials takes into account the food already deposited in comb cells, partly enriched with enzymes and ferments — not the amount of sirup taken by the bees from the feeder. Processing nectar or another food source into honey, bees add to their product the secretion of their glands, rich in enzymes and ferments, particularly invertase.
strona 109Zherebkin M. (1970) investigated the invertase of the pharyngeal glands and found a relationship between the activity of this ferment and the honey yield of colonies. We also confirmed.
REFERENCES
- Brückner D., 1980: Hoarding behaviours and life span of inbred, non-inbred and hybrid honeybees. J. apic. Res. 19 (1): 35—41.
- Eischen F. A., Rothenbuhler W. C., Kulinčevič J. M.: Brood rearing associated with a range of worker-larva relations in the honeybee. J. apic. Res. 22 (3): 163—168.
- Free J. B., Williams J. A., 1972: Hoarding by honeybees (Apis mellifera L.) Anim. Behav. 2: 327—334.
- Free J. B., 1980: Differences in food consumption of caged honeybees from different colonies. J. apic. Res. 19 (2): 112—114.
- Kepeňa L., 1980: Využitie importovanej kranskej včely v podmienkach Slovenska (Záverečná správa). (Using imported Carniolan bees under the conditions of Slovakia /Concluding report/). Bee Research Institute, Liptovský Hrádok.
- Kresák M., 1974: Výskum vplyvu výživy a teploty na kvantitatívne zmeny v ontogenéze včiel. (Research on the effect of nutrition and temperature on quantitative changes in bee ontogenesis). Pol’nohospodárstvo 20 (4): 322—330.
- Kulinčevič J. M., Thompson V. C., Rothenbuhler W. C., 1974: Laboratory and field measurements of hording behaviour in the hoheybee. Am. Bee J. 3: 93—94.
- Milne P. Ch., 1977: An improved laboratory measurement of hoarding behaviour in the honeybee. Am. Bee J. 8: 502—507.
- Milne P. Ch., 1980: Laboratory measurement of honey production in the honeybee. J. apic. Res. 19 (2): 122—126.
- Zherebkin M. V., 1970: Aktivnost’ invertazy i medoproduktivnost’. (Invertase activity and honey productivity). Pchelovodstvo 11: 10—11.
PRÓBA LABORATORYJNEGO OKREŚLENIA PRODUKTYWNOŚCI MIODOWEJ PSZCZÓŁ
L. Kepeňa
Streszczenie
Siedemdziesiąt robotnic trzymano w klateczkach w inkubatorze, które gromadziły pokarm z podkarmiaczki do komórek plastra. Przez 48 godzin gromadziły pokarm. Znaleziono korelację w gromadzeniu zapasów u rodzin trzymanych w warunkach polowych i tych z laboratorium po 48 godzinach. Stwierdzono ponadto korelacje między ilością zapasów w rodzinach laboratoryjnych i ilością cukrów redukujących w zapasach.
Wynikało, że deficyt pokarmu w stadium larwalnym wpływa negatywnie na ilość gromadzonych zapasów przez takie pszczoły w laboratoryjnych warunkach.
strona 110ПОПЫТКА ЛАБОРАТОРНОГО ОПРЕДЕЛЕНИЯ МЕДОПРОДУКТИВНОСТИ ПЧЕЛ
L. Kepena
Резюме
Семьдесят рабочих пчел держали в клеточках в инкубаторе, которые накапливали пищу из кормушки в клетки сота. В течение 48 часов пчелы накапливали пищу. Обнаружено корреляцию в накапливании запасов у семьей, находящихся в полевых условиях и у тех из лаборатории спустя 48 часов. Кроме того, констатировано корреляцию между количеством запасов в лабораторных семьях и количеством редуцирующих сахаридов в запасах.
Обнаружено, что дефицит пищи в стадии личинки отрицательно влияет на количество накопленных запасов такими пчелами в лабораторных условиях.
Errata — błędy druku znalezione podczas digitalizacji
- s. 103: „gene poll” → gene pool
- s. 105: „then number” → the number
- s. 105: „50×50 cm” → 50×50 mm
- s. 105, tab. 1: „radom” → random
- s. 109, piśmiennictwo: „hording” → hoarding
- s. 109, piśmiennictwo: „hoheybee” → honeybee
- s. 110, streszczenie: „у семьей” → у семей
